Eterniseed › Curriculum › Deuteronomy
Deuteronomy 19-20 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in free grace, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s careful exposition of Deuteronomy 19–20 opens the ancient statutes on refuge, testimony, and warfare to the light of impartial justice and the mercy that anticipates the Gospel. His words guide us to see how the law protected life while preparing hearts for the fuller revelation in Christ.
Read
Let us now read Deuteronomy chapters 19 and 20, listening for the careful balance of mercy and judgment that shaped Israel’s life. Attend to the provisions for refuge, the safeguards of truthful witness, and the directions given for future conflicts, asking the Spirit to quicken the text for our own discipleship.
Study
Whedon opens by setting forth the regulations for cities of refuge.
Verses 1-13. REGULATIONS IN REFERENCE TO CITIES OF REFUGE, Deuteronomy 19:1-13 . Comp. Exodus 21:13 , and Numbers 35:9-34 ; Deuteronomy 4:41 . Six cities were to be designated. Moses had already named the three east of the Jordan. Deuteronomy 4:41-43 . The three that were for the west were Kadesh in the north, Shechem in the centre, and Hebron in the south. In Joshua 20:7 , the names of the cities, both on the east and the west of the Jordan, are given.He next distinguishes the protection given the unintentional manslayer from the judgment required for the murderer.
Verses 11-13. 11-13 . But if any man hate The appointment of cities of refuge was a merciful provision for the security of those who unintentionally should shed blood. The usage in the time of Moses evidently was the carrying out rigorously the law of retaliation. But if life had been taken without malice this provision for cities of refuge afforded a place of escape from the avenger of blood. But they were not to be places of refuge for murderers. They were not to protect those who had slain their fellow-men through hatred or for gain. Such guilty ones were to be taken from the cities by the magistrates and given up to the avenger of blood. Human life was sacred among the Hebrews. We see how carefully it was protected, how stringent was the legislation. Moses made provision for the protection of property also.Whedon then turns to the military resources of opposing nations and the call to trust the Lord.
Verse 1. 1 . Seest horses, and chariots Of the military resources of the Oriental nations, with whom the Israelites would be likely to be brought in hostile contact, cavalry constituted an important part. The Egyptians and the Syrians are especially mentioned for the abundance of their cavalry. Be not afraid The Israelites are to call to mind their past history, when Jehovah overthrew the horse and the rider when he so triumphantly brought up his people out of Egypt.
Consider
Whedon concludes by contrasting the stern requirements of the law of retaliation with the words of Christ.
Verse 21. 21 . Thine eye shall not pity It has been said that this is a harsh and cruel requirement. But it must be borne in mind that the usages which prevailed and the condition of society demanded stringent laws. The wise legislator adapts law to the circumstances of the people. Moses found the law of retaliation deeply seated. It has its foundations in the conception of impartial justice. With all his influence over the people he could not eradicate long-established usages. At the present day in the East there is a most cruel feature of the lex talionis. When the murderer cannot be reached the avengers have the right to kill any member of his family. See THOMSON’S Land and Book, vol. i, p. 448. If we turn to the words of Him who spake as never man spake, we see how the Gospel modifies the stern exactions of this law of retaliation. “Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: but I say unto you, That ye resist not evil.” Matthew 5:38-39 .He presses the justice of divine judgment upon the Canaanite nations.
Verse 16. 16 . Of these people The Canaanites and kindred nations. Thou shalt save alive nothing Not a human being was to be left alive. The abominations of these idolatrous nations were such that only by obliterating them wholly could the Israelites be exempt from their corruptions. The punishment of the Canaanites seems severe, but shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?
Respond
How does the provision of refuge shape our understanding of God’s mercy toward the repentant? In what ways does the requirement of truthful witness call us to greater integrity in our communities? Where do we see the Gospel tempering the strictness of ancient justice in our own lives today?
Pray
Gracious God, we thank Thee for the careful wisdom Thou didst grant to Moses and for the light shed upon it by Thy servant Whedon. Grant us hearts that prize both justice and mercy, that we may protect the innocent and speak truth without fear. As we ponder the stern judgments of old, keep us mindful that the Judge of all the earth does right and that Christ has fulfilled the law in love. Strengthen our resolve to walk in the liberty of Thy grace, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →