← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Mark

Who Do You Say That I Am? The Confession and the Cross

Mark 8Catena Aurea — the Golden Chain of the Fathers on the Gospels22 min
Opening
Mark 8 is the hinge of the whole Gospel. It opens with a second feeding — four thousand in the wilderness — and the dull-heartedness of disciples who still do not understand the loaves; it heals a blind man at Bethsaida in two stages, by degrees. Then at Caesarea Philippi comes the question on which everything turns: "Whom do men say that I am?... But whom say ye that I am?" Peter answers, "Thou art the Christ." And immediately the Lord begins to teach what kind of Christ He is — One who must suffer, be killed, and rise — and that whoever would follow Him must take up the cross. Confession and cross are bound together here: to name Him rightly is to be summoned to die with Him.
Read
Read Mark 8 — the feeding of the four thousand; the Pharisees seeking a sign and the warning against the leaven of the Pharisees and of Herod; the blind man of Bethsaida healed in two touches; Peter's confession at Caesarea Philippi; the first prediction of the Passion and the rebuke of Peter ("Get thee behind me, Satan"); and the call to deny self, take up the cross, and follow — for "what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?"
Study
The Lord does not work wonders to dazzle, but only where there is real need, and St. Theophylact notes the restraint even in His mercy: For He did not always work miracles concerning the feeding of the multitude, lest they should follow Him for the sake of food; now therefore He would not have performed this miracle, if He had not seen that the multitude was in danger. Even the disciples' forgetfulness is turned to their schooling; Theophylact sees providence in the empty basket: By a special providence also the disciples forgot to take bread, that they might be blamed by Christ, and thus become better, and arrive at a knowledge of Christ's power. Then comes the great question, and St. John Chrysostom shows how the Lord asks it in stages, raising them above the crowd's guesses to a true confession: From the manner, however, itself of the question, He leads them to a higher feeling, and to higher thoughts, concerning Him, that they might not agree with the multitude.
Consider
No sooner has Peter confessed Christ than he recoils from the cross — and the Lord's sharp answer, St. John Chrysostom teaches, is meant to bind the disciple's salvation to the same cross he is refusing: As is He would say to Peter, Thou indeed dost rebuke Me, who am willing to undergo My passion, but I tell thee, that not only is it wrong to prevent Me from suffering, but neither canst thou be saved unless thou thyself diest. To deny oneself, then, is to hold even one's own body lightly for Christ's sake; Chrysostom defines it plainly: And a man denies himself when he cares not for his body, so that whether it be scourged, or whatever of like nature it may suffer, he bears it patiently. And the confession Peter made with his mouth is required of every believer, not as a private opinion but as an open word, for St. Theophylact says faith and confession sanctify the whole person together: For that faith which only remains in the mind is not sufficient, but the Lord requires also the confession of the mouth; for when the soul is sanctified by faith, the body ought also to be sanctified by confession.
Respond
Christ still puts the question to you personally: not "what do people say," but "whom say ye that I am?" It is possible to give the right answer about Jesus and still refuse the cross that the right answer carries — that was Peter's error a single breath after his confession. To say "Thou art the Christ" is to accept a crucified Messiah, and to take up your own cross and follow. Ask yourself honestly what you are trying to gain by losing your soul — what "whole world" you are bargaining for. And do not keep your faith locked silently in your mind: Theophylact reminds you that the Lord requires "the confession of the mouth," that the body too may be sanctified. The blind man saw by degrees, "men as trees walking" before he saw clearly; if your sight of Christ is still dim, stay under His hand until you see Him whole.
Pray
Lord Jesus Christ, who asked Your disciples "Whom say ye that I am?" and bound the confession of Your name to the carrying of Your cross: grant me to answer with Peter, "Thou art the Christ," and not to flee the cross that confession carries. Teach me to deny myself, to hold my own comfort lightly, and to follow You even into suffering. Let my faith not stay hidden in my mind, but be confessed boldly with my mouth, that soul and body alike may be sanctified in You. Lay Your hand upon my dim eyes until I see You clearly, and let me never trade my soul for any gain of this passing world. For to You be glory, with the Father and the Holy Spirit, now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.

Catena Aurea — the Golden Chain of the Fathers on the Gospels · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →