Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
John 10 — with Whedon
Opening
Beloved, we gather today under the steady light of Scripture to hear Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments unfold the tenth chapter of John. With the forthright spirit of Methodist Episcopal teaching and the warm assurance of Arminian truth, Whedon guides us through the voice of the true Shepherd who calls his own. His careful exposition opens the door of faith and shows how the sheep discern their Lord amid every rival claim. May the same Spirit who moved the commentator now quicken our hearts as we listen.
Read
Let us now read aloud the entire tenth chapter of the Gospel according to John. Listen for the clear distinction between the true Shepherd and every stranger, between the door of faith and every false way. Read slowly, allowing each verse to settle in the heart, that the voice of Jesus may be recognized afresh by his sheep.
Study
Whedon opens by expounding the opening verse of the chapter.
Verse 1. 1 . Verily The Pharisees who had ambushed him ( John 9:39 ) were doubtless ready to depart at 41; but Jesus now fixes their attention by opening this new allegorical discourse with this emphatic introduction. In the first paragraph, 1-5, he depicts, in contrast with the interloper, the true shepherd, and the spiritual instinct by which his sheep know his voice and follow his lead. When, 6, they fail to recognize the application, he explicitly identifies the various cases, 7-13. Thence, gradually emerging from the figure, he describes his self-sacrifice by the Father’s will for the salvation of men, 14-18. This is then a most beautiful development and expansion of the first pastoral image. The door Faith in, and divine commission from, Christ. The sheepfold The earthly Church of the justified, both before and after Christ’s coming. Some other way By wicked motives or methods, or by false doctrines. In the case of these leaders it was by a false Mosaicism in doctrine, and by holding a false authority in the Jewish State and Church. A thief Who would seduce away the sheep by secret stealth. Robber Who would drag them off by violence.He next unfolds the meaning of the parable that the hearers failed to grasp.
Verse 6. 6 . Parable Our Lord here uses the ordinary Greek not for parable, but for any allegorical composition. See remarks on page 227. The present passage might easily be made a parable by being put into a narrative form. They understood not The simile of a shepherd was common in the Old Testament; but our Lord had put the case so indefinitely that they were able to overlook its suitableness to their own persons. Jesus proceeds to apply by avowing himself to be the door; but still leaves them to infer who are the thieves and robbers.Whedon then draws the sharp contrast among thief, hireling, and true Shepherd.
Verse 10. 10 . The three characters are here not to be confounded. The thief is the religious impostor, the heretic, the schismatic, and the persecutor. The hireling is the worldly pastor who means no mischief, specially, but regards his own interest solely. The wolf is the devil; presenting himself in all the outward forms of temptation, sin, and destruction. Opposed to all these is the Good Shepherd, with his blessed flock of true pastors, who, as sheep also, take places in the flock and fold through and under him. Kill… life The enemy brings death; the true Shepherd life. More abundantly Not merely a continued living existence, but the fulness of immortal, heavenly, glorified life.
Consider
On the Shepherd's gift of life, Whedon presses the willing sacrifice of the Son.
Verse 15. 15 . Life for the sheep In this verse the Saviour emerges from the figurative, except so far as the term sheep is concerned, and speaks in deep, solemn, literal words. Whilst the thief and robber would slay he would die for the sheep. He dies for them as a shepherd, slain by the wolf in rescuing the sheep, would die for the sheep. No substitutional sacrifice is here expressed; certainly no judicial substitution, by which the Saviour bears a suffering which stands in place of the penalty upon the sinner. And yet there is an alternative substitution; the sheep would die if he does not, and he dies instead of them. The blessed Saviour now speaks in solemn prophecy perhaps to the very men by whose agency the final sacrifice should be made the slaying of the true Shepherd by the wolves. One of the Christian Fathers, who was born before the apostles died, thus testifies to the doctrine of the atonement: “Christ our Lord gave his blood for us by the will of God; and flesh for our flesh, and life for our life.” (Clemens Romanus, 1st Epistle to the Corinthians.) For the sheep This is no proof-text in behalf of a limited atonement. It is not because Christ died for the sheep alone that the sheep alone are mentioned; but, because the sheep are the subject of the discourse, his death for them alone needs to be mentioned. Affirming that Christ died for the sheep is not denying that he died for others besides the sheep.Finally he shows how the sheep remain secure in the Father's hand.
Verse 27. 27 . My sheep hear my voice As the blind-born did. Those who are bent on holiness and salvation show it by listening to Christ and his Gospel. It is very illogical to infer from all this the doctrine that no man will lose or abandon the character of a sheep of Christ, that is, of a true believer. Qualities or conduct ascribed to persons as possessed of a certain character, do not imply that the character itself may not change. A hireling fleeth because he is a hireling; but that does not prove but that the man may cease to be a hireling. A thief and a robber will kill and destroy; but that does not prove that a thief or robber may not, like Saul of Tarsus, cease to be a thief and robber. So a sheep will follow Christ; but that does not imply but that the man may cease to be a sheep and even become a goat. For a man may as truly from a sheep become a goat, as from a goat become a sheep.
Respond
1. How does the voice of the true Shepherd still call you today amid competing claims? 2. In what ways are you entering the fold by the door of faith rather than another way? 3. What assurance do you find that no one can pluck you from the Father's hand?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the faithful witness of Daniel D. Whedon and for the clear voice of thy Son, the good Shepherd. Grant us ears to hear him and hearts to follow wherever he leads. Keep us from every hireling spirit and from the wolves that seek to scatter thy flock. Bind us ever more closely to the door of faith, that we may enter in and find pasture. Strengthen our confidence that none can pluck us from thy hand, and make us true under-shepherds who love the sheep for thy sake. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →