Eterniseed › Curriculum › Joshua
A Tithe of Cities and an Altar of Witness: The Priests’ Portion and the Worship Guarded
Opening
Two matters fill these chapters: the cities given to the priests and Levites, and the great altar that the eastern tribes built by the Jordan — which nearly brought all Israel to war. Blessed Theodoret of Cyrus reads both. He asks why the priests received their cities chiefly in Judah, Benjamin, and Simeon, and answers that it was no accident of geography but a thing woven into the economy of salvation: the priesthood was joined to the tribe of Judah from of old, by marriage and by lot, because He who would spring from Judah according to the flesh was to be proclaimed not only King but also High Priest. They were settled in Benjamin because the divine temple was to be built in that tribe's land; and Theodoret sees even in the giving of cities a kind of tithe — as Israel rendered to the priests a tenth of the fruits of the earth and the cattle, so a tithe, as it were, of the cities, paying back the paternal debt of Jacob, who had vowed to give God a tenth of all. Then the altar of witness. When the war was over and the eastern tribes were sent home, they built a very great altar by the Jordan before crossing; and the nine tribes, fearing it was the beginning of impiety, prepared to march against their own brethren — preferring piety to kinship. But Phinehas was sent, and the truth came out: the altar was no rival sanctuary but a monument, a testimony of fellowship, built so that the descendants of the eastern tribes could prove their share in the worship of the one God. Theodoret seals the reading with a startling word to his own day: their altar was not the true altar, but prefigured the true one — the one altar of the Church, where Christ our Pascha is offered, around which the whole people of God is gathered into one.
Read
Read Joshua 21–22 — the heads of the Levites come to Eleazar and Joshua, and "the children of Israel gave unto the Levites… these cities and their suburbs," forty-eight cities with their pasture lands, drawn out of all the tribes by lot, that those whose inheritance was the Lord Himself might have where to dwell. "And the Lord gave unto Israel all the land which he sware to give unto their fathers… there failed not ought of any good thing which the Lord had spoken… all came to pass." Then Joshua sends the Reubenites and Gadites and the half-tribe of Manasseh home across Jordan with his blessing; and at the borders "they built there an altar by Jordan, a great altar to see to." The rest of Israel hears of it, "and the whole congregation… gathered themselves together at Shiloh, to go up to war against them." But first they send Phinehas the priest, who asks, "What trespass is this that ye have committed?" And the eastern tribes answer that they built it not for burnt offering but "for a witness between us and you… that ye have no part in the Lord." And the answer pleased Israel, "and the children of Israel blessed God."
Study
Why were the priests' cities given chiefly in Judah, Benjamin, and Simeon? Theodoret reads the divine purpose: the priesthood was knit to Judah because Christ, who sprang from Judah, was to be both King and High Priest, and to Benjamin because the temple was to stand there:
It was necessary, moreover, for them to dwell also in the tribe of Benjamin, since the divine temple was to be built in their tribe. And the very gift of cities to the Levites Theodoret reads as a tithe rendered to God, the paying of an old debt:
so also He commanded that, as it were, tithes of the cities be given to them. He grounds it in the patriarch's ancient vow, so that the people were repaying a paternal debt and not bestowing a favor:
Therefore, the people were paying a paternal debt, not offering a gift. So the gift of cities, like the tithe of crops and cattle, fulfills the word Jacob had once vowed at Bethel — that of all God gave him he would render a tenth to God. The Levites' inheritance was not a portion of the land but the Lord Himself; and the people, in granting them cities out of every tribe, were simply paying what their father had promised.
Consider
Theodoret has gathered both chapters toward Christ and His Church. The priestly cities planted in Judah are, for him, a quiet prophecy: the tribe of Judah carries the priesthood near because from Judah would come the One who is at once King and High Priest — "the Lord sware… Thou art a priest for ever after the order of Melchizedek" (Heb 7:17), the King of kings who is also the Priest who offers Himself. And the altar of witness opens the deepest theme of all: the unity of the one true worship. The eastern tribes built their altar not to divide Israel but to bind it — a testimony that they too had part in the Lord, lest their children be cut off from the festivals of God. The near-war and its peaceful resolution teach that the worship of the one God must be guarded jealously and yet that fellowship must not be broken on a misunderstanding: the nine tribes, fearing impiety,
wished to march against them with the whole people, preferring piety to kinship; and yet, finding their brethren faithful, they blessed God and were reconciled. This is the Church's own discipline — zeal for the truth of worship, joined to a longing for the unity of the brethren. And Theodoret's closing word lifts the whole episode into its fulfillment, turning it even upon the worship of his own day:
that their altar was not the true altar, but prefigured the true one. There is one true altar, the Cross and the Holy Table where Christ our Pascha is offered, around which the whole people of God — Jew and gentile, near and far, the tribes on this side and beyond every Jordan — are gathered into one body. The altar of witness was a monument that none of God's people should be excluded from His worship; the true altar of Christ is the place where all who flee to Him are made one, and from which none who hold the true faith are shut out.
Respond
See first what the priestly cities teach: that the whole history bends toward Christ, the King who is also our High Priest, born of Judah, offering Himself for us. And see that the people gave the Levites their cities not as a gift but as a debt — a tithe owed to God, the paying of an ancient vow. So learn that what you render to God is never a favor you do Him, but a debt of gratitude you owe; give Him the firstfruits and the tithe of your life as one paying what is due, gladly and without grudging. Then learn from the altar of witness a twofold zeal. Be jealous, as the nine tribes were, for the one true worship: prefer piety even to kinship, and let nothing — not friendship, not family, not your own comfort — draw you into a false altar or a counterfeit faith. Yet be slow to condemn your brethren on a misunderstanding: send your Phinehas, ask the question, learn the truth before you go up to war. The tribes who feared an impiety found instead a monument of fellowship, and "blessed God." Above all, gather at the true altar that all these prefigured: the Holy Table where Christ our Pascha is offered. Let no one shut you out of the worship of God, and shut out no one who holds the true faith; for around that one altar the whole people of God, near and far, are gathered into one — and there is room there for every soul that flees to Christ.
Pray
O Lord our God, who didst settle Thy priests in the tribe of Judah, that from Judah might come Thy Christ, both King and High Priest, and didst receive the cities of the Levites as a tithe owed Thee, the paying of an ancient vow: teach me to render unto Thee not as one bestowing a gift, but as one paying a glad debt of gratitude, the firstfruits and the tithe of all my life. Thou didst stir up Thy people to prefer piety even to kinship, zealous for the one true worship; make me likewise jealous for Thy truth, that no friendship nor comfort nor fear may draw me to a false altar. Yet make me also slow to condemn my brethren, sending first to learn the truth, as Israel sent Phinehas, that I may bless Thee for their faith and not war against them in error. And gather me to the true altar which all these prefigured — the Holy Table of Thy Cross, where Christ our Pascha is offered, and around which Thy whole people, near and far, are made one. Shut me not out of Thy worship, and let me shut out none who hold Thy truth. To Thee, O Christ our God, our King and our High Priest, with the Father and the all-holy Spirit, be glory now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →