Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Samuel
2 Samuel 17-18 — with Whedon
Opening
Beloved, we gather in the spirit of Wesleyan holiness to open Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for 2 Samuel chapters 17-18. With Arminian warmth we trace the sovereign grace that overrules rebellion and the fatherly heart that still yearns amid judgment. May the Spirit quicken our reading so that every line draws us nearer to the cross where mercy and truth meet.
Read
Let us now read together 2 Samuel 17-18, listening for the living Word that confronts pride and kindles repentance. Read slowly, allowing the narrative to search the heart. Note each turn of counsel, each clash in the wood, and the cry that rises from the gate tower. The Lord himself meets us in these ancient pages.
Study
Whedon opens by numbering the forces David assembles at Mahanaim.
Verse 1. THE BATTLE IN THE WOOD OF EPHRAIM, AND DEATH OF ABSALOM, 2 Samuel 18:1-33 . 1 . Numbered the people Josephus says he found them to be about four thousand. Others have inferred, from 2 Samuel 18:3 , that they were ten thousand. Many had probably rallied to his standard at Mahanaim.He next unfolds the dramatic reversal of Ahithophel's counsel through Hushai.
Verses 1-14. THE COUNSEL OF AHITHOPHEL DEFEATED BY HUSHAI, 2 Samuel 18:1-14 . Most vividly graphic is this sketch of what Kitto calls “the first cabinet council to which history admits us.” It would be difficult to find in the same space a more perfect word picture. After his most shameful incest in the sight of all Israel, Absalom returns for further counsel, and finds his great adviser full of deep-laid plans for future action. He would have the prince continue his lewd pleasures at Jerusalem, whilst himself, at the head of a strong force, would pursue the fugitive David, steal upon him in the still darkness of the night, paralyze his heart and hands with fear, scatter his defenders, and smite him whom alone it was necessary to smite in order to crush all opposition.Whedon then situates the battle within the tangled terrain of the wood of Ephraim.
Verse 6. 6 . Against Israel Alas! It was Israel against Israel. But it had come to pass that strong prejudices were manifest between the people of Israel and the men of Judah. The wood of Ephraim A forest evidently not far from Mahanaim, and probably near the Jordan, but its exact locality and the origin of its name are now unknown. Grotius conjectured that it took its name from the great slaughter of the Ephraimites recorded Judges 12:1-6 ; and the Jews have a tradition that Joshua, who was an Ephraimite, permitted the people of his tribe to pasture their flocks in this forest. Keil argues that it was on the west of the Jordan in the tribe-land of Ephraim, which, according to Joshua 17:15 , abounded in wood. But as David was at Mahanaim, and Absalom in Gilead, ( 2 Samuel 17:20 ,) this battle doubtless took place on the east of the Jordan.He presses onward to the moment Absalom is caught fast in the oak.
Verse 9. 9 . Absalom met the servants of David And probably darted rapidly one side through the forest to avoid them, when he met with the accident which exposed him helpless to his enemy. His head caught hold of the oak Probably entangled by his hair, (compare 2 Samuel 14:26 ,) and so Josephus affirms.
Consider
Whedon weighs the painful necessity of Joab's decisive stroke against Absalom.
Verse 14. 14 . I may not tarry I have no time to lose in thus talking with thee, and am not thus careful to obey the king in this matter. Absalom’s life, says Clarke, “was quadruply forfeited to the law. (1) In having murdered his brother Amnon; (2) In having excited an insurrection in the state; (3) In having taken up arms against his own father, ( Deuteronomy 21:18 ; Deuteronomy 21:21 ;) (4) In having lain with his father’s concubines. Leviticus 18:29 . Long ago he should have died by the hand of justice.” But we cannot, with Clarke and others, denounce this act of Joab as a cowardly murder, base and disloyal. True, he disobeyed the king, but he felt it a duty to disobey. He was too much of a warrior and statesman to think that the rebellion could be successfully subdued without the death of Absalom, and he afterwards vindicated himself before David with a severity of rebuke which the king dared not gainsay or resist. 2 Samuel 19:1-8 . Yet alive Compare note on 2 Samuel 18:10 .Finally he lingers over David's lament and the warning legacy of a reckless son.
Verse 33. 33 . The chamber over the gate An apartment in the upper part of the tower of one of the gates. O my son Absalom This lamentation is the most touchingly pathetic of all David’s elegies, and it sprung from the deepest depths of his heart. One hardly knows which most to wonder at, the excessive tenderness of the father, or the pitiable weakness of the king. In the life and death of Absalom we have a picture of the fast young man. At an early period of his life a bitter hatred towards his brother soon ends in impious fratricide, and a soul thus passionate and rash can easily find its way to the crimes of an incendiary. 2 Samuel 14:30 . Excessively vain, he loves to display his beauty, and have his praises spoken of in Israel; and this path of vainglory leads him rapidly on to an ostentatious prodigality that affects regal pomp and splendour, ( 2 Samuel 15:1 ,) and even erects a pillar to perpetuate his name. For a youth thus reckless and headstrong it was no difficult matter to plot treason, (even against a father’s throne,) seduce the people, betray the innocent, and commit the most shameful incest. Such abandoned characters are sure to meet with a miserable end.
Respond
1. Where in my own life has pride dressed itself as wise counsel? 2. How does David's torn heart instruct me to hold both justice and compassion? 3. What warning does Absalom's end speak to the ambitions I still cherish?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the faithful witness of Daniel D. Whedon and for the Scripture that lays bare both sin and mercy. Grant us grace to heed the counsel of thy Spirit rather than the voices of ambition. Keep us from the path that leads to the oak and the pit. May the same love that wept over Absalom melt our hearts toward those who rebel against thee. Through Christ our Lord, amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →