← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel

1 Samuel 3-4 — with Whedon

1 Samuel 3-4Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the quiet hours before the lamp of God went out, the Lord raised up Samuel as a faithful witness amid a generation grown deaf to his voice. Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments opens the sacred record of 1 Samuel chapters 3 and 4 with reverent clarity, tracing the divine call that awakened a child-prophet and the solemn judgments that followed upon an unfaithful house. Rooted in the Arminian-Wesleyan conviction that grace may be resisted yet mercy still pleads, this study invites us to listen again for the word that never falls to the ground.
Read
With hearts stilled before the Lord, let us read together 1 Samuel chapters 3 and 4. Hear how the child Samuel answers the thrice-repeated call, how Eli receives the word of judgment, and how the ark itself is taken while the house of Eli falls. Receive the narrative as living Scripture, asking the Spirit to quicken every line for our instruction and comfort today.
Study
Whedon opens by setting the scarcity of revelation against the sin of priest and people. Verse 1. SAMUEL’S CALL, 1 Samuel 3:1-21 . 1 . Samuel ministered See note on 1 Samuel 2:11 . According to Josephus, Samuel was now about twelve years old. The word of the Lord was precious in those days יקר , precious, costly; an epithet applied frequently to very rare and costly stones. 2 Samuel 12:30 ; 1Ki 10:2 ; 1 Chronicles 20:2 ; Ezekiel 27:22 . The meaning is that direct revelations from God had become exceedingly rare, and this fact was owing to the lamentable sinfulness of the priesthood and the people. As sinfulness in the individual heart drives away the Holy Spirit, so in the Hebrew nation it drove away the spirit of prophecy. A direct communication from God at such a time would truly be a precious thing. Unless we reckon Deborah, who is called a prophetess, ( Judges 4:4 ,) so far as we know only two prophets had appeared in Israel (see Judges 6:8 , and 1 Samuel 2:27 ) during the period that intervened between the time of Moses and this call of Samuel. No open vision Literally, No divine communication was spread; that is, published abroad, made known. If, perchance, God revealed himself to pious individuals here and there, he gave them private revelations; but the persons thus honoured were not thereby constituted public prophets, nor sent to publish their communications to the people. In the midst of such spiritual darkness Samuel arose as a new luminary in Israel. He next unfolds the visible appearance by which the Lord confirmed his call to the child. Verse 10. 10 . The Lord came, and stood From 1 Samuel 3:15 we learn that Samuel beheld a vision as well as heard a voice, and, therefore, it is most natural to understand the words came and stood as designating a visible appearance. God was not only personally but visibly there, either in human form ( Genesis 18:2 ; Genesis 18:33 ; Joshua 5:13-15 ) or in some angelic or surprising manifestation. Exodus 3:2-6 . Hitherto Samuel had seen nothing, but had only heard the voice. Thrice the voice had called, and thrice the child had gone to Eli, supposing he had called. All this served as preparation for the vision, not only rousing Eli from his thoughtlessness, and putting his mind in a state of anxious expectation, but also impressing Samuel with a feeling that something remarkable was pending. Having thus prepared the way, the Lord not merely called as at other times , but he also came and stood, that is, revealed himself by some visible manifestation; and this, perhaps, so awed and surprised the child that he omitted the name of the LORD from the answer which Eli had directed him to make in case he heard the voice again. Whedon then records Eli’s humble submission once every word is declared. Verses 17-18. 17, 18 . What is the thing that… said unto thee It will be observed that the English version supplies the words the LORD, but in his question Eli seems to have intentionally omitted the subject of the verb said. His words imply that he himself was uncertain who had called Samuel. He was doubtless strongly persuaded that it was Jehovah, for this had been his conviction when the child came to him the third time, ( 1 Samuel 3:8 ,) but not until Samuel had told him every whit , ( 1 Samuel 3:18 כל הדברים , all the words, that is, the entire communication of 1 Samuel 3:11-14 ,) was he absolutely sure; then he said, It is the Lord , and bowed in humble submissiveness before the sad and solemn prophecy. If he had entertained any doubts respecting the message of 1 Samuel 2:27-36 , all doubt must have vanished now, as that message received confirmation through the child Samuel, whose word he could not doubt. Finally he shows how Samuel’s word was established throughout Israel. Verse 19. 19 . Let none of his words fall to the ground Let none of his prophecies fail of fulfilment, so that it soon became known, far and near, that he was a divinely accredited prophet, and all his sayings surely came to pass. Compare 1 Samuel 9:6 .
Consider
Whedon presses the weightiest conclusion that the word of the Lord, once rare, became continual through Samuel. Thus was Samuel caused to ask of Jehovah, that is, caused to be in continued intercourse with him, as he himself might ever be reminded by his very name. See note on 1 Samuel 1:28 . Accordingly, the word of the Lord was no longer so costly and rare as it had previously been in Israel, ( 1 Samuel 3:1 ,) for throughout the land Samuel was known to habitually receive communications from Jehovah. “He is, also, the first instance of a prophet gradually raised for his office from the earliest dawn of reason. His work and his life are the counterparts of each other. He closes the section by tracing the beginning of Eli’s downfall in the capture of the ark. Verses 1-11. CAPTURE OF THE ARK, AND DEATH OF ELI’S SONS, 1 Samuel 4:1-11 . This section records the beginning of the downfall of Eli’s house, and that bitter affliction of the tabernacle the loss of the sacred ark. See note on 1 Samuel 2:32 . Led by Jehovah’s word, as communicated through Samuel, Israel goes out to battle with the Philistines; but it is that it may be made to feel its utter weakness without Jehovah’s constant aid. The impiety of the nation demanded a signal chastisement, especially in the persons of its religious leaders, and Divine Wisdom saw fit to inflict it in the way here recorded. In the first engagement four thousand Hebrews are left dead upon the field. The survivors hasten to their camp, and whilst all hearts are quaking with terror, or quailing under a sense of bitter loss, the elders hold a speedy consultation. It was probably a midnight conference. They feel that Jehovah is not with them as he had been with their fathers, but they vainly imagine that to have the ark of the covenant among them will be to have a talisman against all possibility of failure. Delusive trust! They had yet to learn that in a wicked age, and under the ministry of a flagitious priesthood, Jehovah’s presence may forsake even the sacred symbols. The ark was brought, and with it Eli’s sons, but Jehovah came not.
Respond
1. Where in my life has sin made the word of the Lord seem rare, and how am I inviting fresh hearing? 2. Like young Samuel, am I quick to rise and answer when the Lord calls my name? 3. In what ways am I guarding against the partial affection that hindered Eli’s faithful oversight?
Pray
Gracious Lord, who once called Samuel in the stillness of the tabernacle, call us again by thy living word. Grant us ears attentive and hearts obedient, that none of thy promises may fall to the ground among us. Deliver us from the partial love that spares what thou hast condemned, and from the presumption that would treat thy presence as a charm rather than a covenant. Raise up in our day faithful witnesses like Samuel, that thy word may again be precious and published abroad. Through the same Spirit that raised prophets of old, conform us to the image of thy Son, in whose name we pray. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →