Eterniseed › Curriculum › Job
Job 21-22 — with Whedon
Opening
In the quiet strength of Wesleyan assurance we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Across Job chapters 21 and 22 the venerable exegete traces the deepening colloquy between suffering integrity and its accusers. With calm Arminian clarity he shows how Job meets the friends’ doctrine of present retribution while refusing to surrender trust in the living God. Whedon’s measured exposition invites us to listen again for the gospel note that even the darkest enigma cannot silence.
Read
Let us now read Job 21–22 aloud, allowing the measured cadence of the text to prepare our hearts. As the words of Job and Eliphaz rise before us, may the Spirit grant patience to hear both the honest lament of the righteous and the searching reply of divine wisdom.
Study
Whedon opens by presenting Job’s sixth reply to the friends.
Verse 1. JOB’S SIXTH REPLY. 1 . But Job answered The friends have to the last adhered to their main proposition, that the wicked are punished in this life. Job now meets it for the first time face to face; devoting the entire speech to its consideration. He more discreetly than before makes an appeal to facts, and shows that in their entire life the wicked are eminently prosperous, and that even in the article of death their lot is easier than that of the righteous.He then unfolds the main division concerning the divine administration of awards in this world.
Verse 7. Main division THE DIVINE ADMINISTRATION OF AWARDS IN THIS WORLD TENDS TO CONFOUND MORAL DISTINCTIONS, Job 21:7-26 . First half THE WICKED DEFY GOD, AND YET GOD PROSPERS THEM EVEN UNTO SHEOL, Job 21:7-16 . First strophe Instead of suffering punishment, as Zophar maintained, the wicked live, grow old surrounded by their families, and safe from the discipline of Heaven , Job 21:7-11 . 7 . Wherefore do the wicked live Zophar’s assertion ( Job 20:5 ,) calls forth the counter thesis of this verse. The existence of evil is a mystery, among the first to perplex and the last to leave the mind. The question why the wicked live is but one of its phases, and is of personal interest, for it concerns ourselves. The question does not so often assume the form why we should live, as why others should, whom we suppose to be much more depraved than ourselves.Whedon next introduces the third address of Eliphaz and its direct accusations.
Verse 1. The third stage of the controversy. Chaps. 22-26. THIRD ADDRESS OF ELIPHAZ. 1 . Then Eliphaz… answered God is all-sufficient, and if he punish, it is not for his own profit, much less for the sake of human piety, but on account of the sins of men. It is therefore plain that an infinite sufferer must have been an infinite sinner, (2-5.) Job’s exaggerated description of the prosperity of the wicked seems to Eliphaz a denial of Divine Providence. He now proceeds to refute Job by indirectly arguing the doctrine of such Providence, and carries the war into Africa by an assault upon Job himself. He charges upon him the guilt of oppression and cruelty to the weak and defenceless. Under his emirship might and violence prospered. Moreover, he was a sceptic, well skilled to make “the worse appear the better reason,” (12-15.) That Job should suffer was due to sins such as these, and demonstrated that the wicked are punished in this life. The antediluvians lived just such lives as those of the happy wicked, and their foundation of bliss and security was poured forth like a stream. The triumphant song of the survivors furnishes a text from which Eliphaz confidently urges Job to return to God, with the assurance of returning prosperity, which will manifest itself not so much in worldly good as in joy in God, the consciousness of spiritual uprightness, and the bliss of doing good to others.
Consider
On the undisturbed faith marking Job’s later speeches, he presses:
It is to be remarked that the first of Job’s discourses since his triumph of faith in the nineteenth chapter, (25-27,) like the others yet to follow, is marked by calm and dispassionate argument; by a greater freedom from personalities; by a more confident view of the darkest phases of evil; and by a faith which the darkness around him has no more power to disturb than the shadow of the night has to unsettle the fastnesses of the mountain, all which is in itself an earnest of the victory soon to follow.Finally he underscores the decisive moment of Job’s repudiation of the wicked.
Verse 16. 16 . Their good This verse is parenthetical. Notwithstanding their godlessness, God gives them good. (The same word as wealth in Job 21:13 .) He, not they, is the author of their happiness, which to Job is an astounding feature of moral government. Astounded at himself, he adds, The counsel of the wicked, far be it from me! ( Job 22:18 .) Job’s exclamation is of great moment in its bearing upon the problem of the book. ( Job 1:11 ; Job 2:5 .) Instead of repudiating God, he repudiates the entire counsel and views ( עצה ) of the wicked. Right in the midst of the whirlpool we still see the brow of the rock, and feel it is immovable.
Respond
1. Where in my own trials have I been tempted to measure God’s justice by present circumstances alone?
2. How does Job’s refusal to adopt the counsel of the wicked strengthen my resolve to walk uprightly?
3. In what ways can the church today bear patient witness when the prosperity of the unrighteous seems to mock the promises of God?
Pray
Gracious and all-sufficient God, we thank Thee for the steady light of Thy servant Whedon’s exposition. Grant us, like Job, a faith that the shadows of this present world cannot unsettle. Keep our hearts from envy of the prosperous wicked and from the pride that would justify ourselves before Thee. May the same Spirit who sustained Job teach us to rest in Thy perfect knowledge and to walk in cheerful obedience. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →