Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 John
1 John 4 — with Whedon
Opening
Beloved, we open this day’s lesson in the reverent spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry, turning to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for 1 John chapter 4. Whedon’s forthright Arminian-Wesleyan witness guides us through the apostolic tests that distinguish the Spirit of God from antichristic error, leading us into the perfecting power of divine love. May the same Spirit who inspired the apostle grant us discernment and charity as we study together.
Read
Let us now read the entire fourth chapter of 1 John with open hearts. Hear the apostle’s urgent call to test the spirits, to confess the incarnate Son, and to abide in the love that flows from God himself. As the words are read aloud, invite the Holy Spirit to apply each test to your own life and to kindle within you that perfect love which casts out fear.
Study
Whedon turns first to the initial test of true confession.
Verse 2. 2 . Hereby First test of a true spirit. This test is aimed at the Docetist, who denied the flesh and body of Christ, and made him a phantom. Every spirit… of God The apostle’s language is seemingly sweeping. Is the spirit that confesses Jesus come in the flesh , and yet denies other truths, truly of God? Or, as Augustine (quoted by Wordsworth) asks: “Arius, and Eunomius, and Macedonius, and Nestorius, own that Jesus came in the flesh ; are not they, therefore, of God?” To this Augustine answers: “Those heresiarchs did not, in fact, confess Christ come in the flesh , because, whatever they might do in words, they in their works denied him. ( Titus 1:16 .) They have not charity because they have not unity;” that is, unity with the Church. Wordsworth gives a different answer, which is in effect, that to confess Christ come in the flesh is to confess him as Messiah, with all that embraces; namely, his divine atonement for our sins. Compare our notes on 1 John 4:15 and 1 John 5:1 . Perhaps the apostle would say, that whatever error Arius or other heretic believed, he derived from a false spirit; but whatever truth he held, as the incarnation of Christ, came from a good spirit and was of God . The spirit, here, is not wholly the man, but the inspiration from good or evil in the man. But our own view is that the apostle is deciding between two claimants to being of God , the one denying and the other affirming that Jesus is come in the flesh; and he pronounces for the latter. So that of the two sides he that confesseth is of God.He next presents the second test of worldliness.
Verse 4. 4 . Second test of antichristic spirits worldliness. In the contest between the Church and the world , they are on the world’s side. Have overcome By placing faith in Christ, the world’s conqueror. Note on 1 John 5:4 . Them The antichristic spirits, who are identified with the world. He… in you God. In the world Satan, as its inspirer and prince.Whedon then unfolds the confirmatory test of love.
Verse 7. 7 . Love one another Namely, with that elevated love which desires and seeks to do everything for the happiness of the object loved, both temporal and eternal. Our apostle here begins with this spirit of love in our hearts, and traces it to its fountain, God . Knoweth God Philosophers may prove by various arguments the being and attributes of God ; but it is to divine experience we must resort to know God as love . Much of goodness appears in nature, but the fulness of love in God is learned by grace alone.
Consider
Whedon brings the whole matter to its consummation in the perfection of love.
Verse 18. 18 . No fear in love They are contrary affections. So far as love is perfected so far is fear dispersed. So Bengel strikingly gives the grades of our moral state: “Without fear or love; with fear, but without love: with both love and fear; with love without fear.” Casteth out The stronger and better affection expels the weaker and the worse. Fear hath torment And this shows that the exclusion of the apostle’s fear is not the exclusion of that reverential fear which “is the beginning of wisdom.” Torment Sense of guilt and dread of penalty. Feareth The dread of penalty arising from conscious guilt shows us to be not perfect in love . We have here, then, something of a subjective measure of what is sometimes called “Christian perfection.” When there exists within our hearts the consciousness of the full divine acceptance, so complete that we have no fear at the thought of meeting him at judgment , we may trust that our love is perfected . The maintenance of this consciousness, sustained and justified by the external life, is the highest aim of life.
Respond
1. Which of the three tests Whedon expounds most searches your present walk with Christ?
2. How does the call to love one another expose any remaining fear in your heart?
3. In what concrete way will you practice the perfect love that casts out torment today?
Pray
Gracious Father, who hast manifested thy love in sending thine only-begotten Son, grant us now the discerning Spirit that tries every inspiration by the confession of Jesus come in the flesh. Cleanse us from all worldly conformity and from every spirit that refuses the apostolic witness. Perfect thy love within us, O Lord, until fear is cast out and we stand bold on the day of judgment. Unite us in that threefold love which binds us to thee, to one another, and to all for whom Christ died. Through Jesus our propitiation we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →