Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judith
Judith 5-6 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Welcome to this lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Commentary on the fifth and sixth chapters of Judith, where Achior the Ammonite rises before the assembled war council of Holofernes and gives a theological discourse on the God of Israel and his ways with his covenant people. Haydock preserves the patristic tradition that reads Achior as the first sustained piece of Old Testament theology placed on the lips of a Gentile, anticipating the great moment in the Acts of the Apostles when Saint Peter would go down to the household of Cornelius and proclaim that God is no respecter of persons but in every nation the one who fears him and works righteousness is accepted by him. Haydock's notes on these chapters thread Worthington, Calmet, Tirinus, and Menochius into a coherent witness to the Catholic typological reading.
Read
Read Judith chapters 5 and 6 attentively, marking Achior's discourse and Holofernes' rejection of it. Notice how Achior surveys the history of Israel from Abraham through the wilderness wandering and the conquest of Canaan into the Babylonian exile and the recent return; his central thesis that when Israel was faithful to her God no power on earth could stand before her, and when she sinned she was given into her enemies' hand. Then watch Holofernes' reaction: mockery, threats, and the order to bind Achior and deliver him over to the Israelites at Bethulia. Hold in mind Achior's unexpected welcome among the elders of Bethulia at the close of chapter six.
Study
Haydock's commentary on Achior's discourse in chapter five and on Holofernes' rejection in chapter six gathers the Catholic-tradition voices that have read these chapters as a particular witness to the universal scope of God's election.
Battles. He seems to speak of the captivity of Manasses, (Worthington) of the ten tribes, and of the loss sustained by Achaz, 2 Paralipomenon xxviii. 5. (Menochius) --- By many. Greek, "exceedingly; and they were led captive into a land which was not their own, and the temple of their God became as a pavement, and their cities were taken by the enemies. But now, returning to their God, they are come up from the places to which they had been scattered, and have possession of Jerusalem, where is their sanctuary; and they have inhabited the mountainous country, for it was a desert." (Haydock) --- Our adversaries would infer from this, and similar passages, that the siege of Bethulia could not have taken place till after the captivity of Babylon; and this many Catholics allow. But the proof is not conclusive, as all this might be verified under Manasses: (Calmet) "the temple was trampled on," (Syriac, Greek: egennethe eis edaphos) and profaned. See chap. iv. 2., and 1 Machabees iii. 51., and Luke xxi. 24. It had been pillaged by Sesac and the Assyrians, and had stood in need of great repairs under Ezechias, Josias, &c. Several of the Israelites had escaped from the hands of their oppressors, (2 Paralipomenon xxxiv. 9.) and the Jews had regained their strength after the captivity of Manasses, (Calmet) having retired before into their strong holds in the deserts. (Haydock)
Plague. Greek adds, "for which there was no remedy. And the Egyptians cast them out from among them. And God dried up the Red Sea before them, and conducted them to Mount Sinai and Cades-Barne, and cast out all the inhabitants of the desert; and they dwelt in the land of the Amorrhites, and exterminated all the Hesebon, by their power. Then crossing the Jordan, they took as their inheritance all the mountainous parts, and ejected the Chanaanite, Pherezite, Jebusite, Sichem, and all the Gergesites, and dwelt therein many days. And, " ver. 21. (Haydock) --- The environs of Sichem belonged to the Hevites. (Calmet)
Pride. God will not fail to reward those who trust in him, (Haydock) and to humble the presumptuous. (Worthington) --- Saints. Syriac, "sanctuary." This version and the Greek have only, "Look upon the face of the persons (or things) sanctified unto thee on this day. And they consoled Achior, and praised him greatly. And Ozias took him from the assembly to his own house, and made a feast (literally, drinking) for the ancients, and they invoked the God of Israel to assist them during all that night." (Haydock)Haydock then turns to the chapter six confrontation between Holofernes and the testimony Achior has given.
Bethulia. Travellers, depending on the uncertain traditions of the country, generally place this fortress in the tribe of Zebulon, about three miles west of Tiberias. See Brochard., &c. But St. Jerome places it near Egypt; (Vita Hil.) and the Scripture speaks of Bethul, in the tribe of Simeon, (Josue xix. 4.) to which Judith and the ancients belonged. Holofernes left his camp near Scythopolis, (chap. vii. 1.) when he proceeded (Calmet) to attack the southern countries. (Haydock)
Consider
Haydock's commentary preserves the Catholic theological vision that places Achior the Ammonite among the great Old Testament catechumens — figures like Rahab the Canaanite, Ruth the Moabitess, Naaman the Syrian, and the queen of Sheba, whose hearts were drawn toward the God of Israel before the gospel had been fully revealed. The Church teaches that the knowledge of God is accessible in principle to every honest mind that reckons with the structure of providence; Achior is a luminous instance. Where in your own life have you encountered persons outside the visible boundaries of the Church who speak truth about God with a clarity that puts the faithful to shame? Consider too Holofernes' response to Achior. The proud general does not refute the speech but mocks it, threatens it, and tries to silence it by humiliation. The Catholic tradition has long observed this pattern as the perennial response of the spirit of empire to the prophetic word, and the Church must be prepared to bear such mockery without losing her composure.
Respond
Identify one person within your circle of acquaintance whose honest reckoning with the world has drawn them toward the truth though they remain outside the visible boundaries of the Church. Offer a decade of the Glorious Mysteries this week for their full reception of the truth, and consider whether you have welcomed them into your own household as the elders of Bethulia welcomed Achior.
Pray
Almighty God, eternal Father, who through the testimony of Achior revealed your dominion over every nation and the unfolding of all history, deepen our trust that you alone direct the affairs of peoples and protect those who hope in your covenant. By the prayers of the holy patriarchs and the communion of saints, open our hearts to read the signs of our times with steadfast faith in your saving power. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →