Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians
1 Corinthians 5 — Eterniseed (Reformation-era / historical Protestant)
Opening
The fifth chapter of the first epistle to the Corinthians sets forth the apostle's rebuke of a church that had permitted gross immorality to remain unaddressed within its bounds. The matter concerns one who had taken his father's wife, an offense that violated both natural order and the covenant holiness required of those called by God. Rather than grieving over the sin or acting to remove it, the assembly had continued in its former boasting. This silence reveals a deeper disorder: the failure to reckon with the Lord's sovereign claim upon his people as a purified body. The text therefore moves from exposure of the offense to the prescribed remedy of separation, underscoring that the church's integrity rests not upon human tolerance but upon the decisive action of those who bear Christ's name. In this the sovereignty of God appears, for he alone determines the terms on which his covenant people may remain in fellowship with him and with one another.
Read
Read the chapter in full, attending to the sequence of the apostle's charge. Observe first the report of the specific transgression and the congregation's response of continued pride. Note the call to mourn and to deliver the offender to Satan. Mark the extended figure of leaven and its removal before the feast. Distinguish the judgments required within the church from those left to God concerning those outside. Consider how the final command to put away the wicked person concludes the argument and what this implies for the visible purity of the covenant community.
Study
The chapter opens with the fact of a reported incestuous union that the church had not judged. The apostle declares that such a deed ought not even to be named among the saints, yet the assembly had remained unmoved. Their boasting, already reproved in the preceding chapter as resting upon gifts rather than grace, now appears still more incongruous in the presence of tolerated sin. The prescribed remedy is assembly in the name of the Lord Jesus, with the power of the Lord present, to deliver the offender to Satan for the destruction of the flesh. This act of separation serves both the honor of Christ and the possible salvation of the one removed. The argument then turns to the figure of leaven. A little leaven leavens the whole lump; therefore the old leaven must be purged so that the church may keep the feast with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth. The Passover imagery recalls the once-for-all redemption accomplished by Christ, whose sacrifice defines the terms of continued communion. The distinction between those within and those without follows at once. Judgment of those inside belongs to the church; those outside remain under the judgment of God. The chapter closes with the explicit command to put away from among yourselves the wicked person. Throughout, the text assumes that the church possesses authority to act in Christ's name for the preservation of its covenant standing, and that failure to exercise this authority brings reproach upon the gospel itself.
Consider
The same principle of separation appears in the Lord's instruction concerning private offenses in Matthew 18, where the unrepentant brother is to be treated as a Gentile and a tax collector once the steps of reproof have been exhausted. The Old Testament requirement that evil be put away from Israel supplies the background against which the apostle reasons, now applied to the new covenant people. Later epistles reinforce the pattern: the Thessalonian church is told to withdraw from every brother who walks disorderly, and the pastoral letters direct the handling of those who persist in sin. The Reformation recovery of discipline as a mark of the true church stands in continuity with this apostolic order, recognizing that visible holiness belongs to the very definition of the gathered people of God rather than to an optional improvement upon it.
Respond
In what specific ways does the continued tolerance of known sin within a congregation today contradict the apostle's charge that the church must judge those inside its fellowship? How might a recovery of deliberate separation, undertaken in the name of Christ and with his power, serve both the purity of the body and the ultimate good of the one removed? What safeguards does the text imply are necessary so that church discipline remains an act of covenant faithfulness rather than an expression of human pride or partiality?
Pray
O Lord God, who hast called a people to thyself and hast set the terms of their communion in the blood of thy Son, grant that thy churches may walk worthy of the calling wherewith they are called. Where sin is known and unrepented, give courage to those who bear rule to act in the name of Christ for the removal of the offense. Preserve thy people from the leaven that corrupts the whole lump, and keep them in sincerity and truth. Judge not thy servants according to their own understanding, but according to the word that thou hast spoken. May the visible order of thy house testify to the holiness of him who bought it with his own blood, to the praise of thy sovereign grace alone. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.