Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 21-22 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Today we enter the turbulent days of David’s flight with Haydock’s Catholic Family Bible Commentary as our trusted guide. This venerable compilation gathers the wisdom of Challoner, Calmet, and other Catholic voices to illuminate every verse of 1 Samuel. As we read chapters 21 and 22, Haydock helps us see both the human drama and the deeper spiritual lessons hidden within David’s trials. May these ancient insights strengthen our own trust in God’s providence during times of uncertainty and persecution.
Read
Take up your Bible and read 1 Samuel chapters 21 and 22 slowly and prayerfully. Picture David arriving at Nobe, then Geth, and finally the cave of Odollam while Saul’s anger grows. Notice the priests, the bread of offering, and the sword of Goliath. Let the narrative unfold without hurry so that Haydock’s commentary may later cast its clarifying light upon each scene.
Study
Haydock opens by locating Nobe and identifying the priest who receives David.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Nobe. A city in the tribe of Benjamin, to which the tabernacle of the Lord had been translated from Silo. (Challoner) --- It was about 12 miles south-west of Gabaa. (Tudelensis.) --- There was another Nobe on the east side of the Jordan, to which Serarius thinks David was three days in travelling. But when David made that assertion, he wished to conceal the real state of his affairs, as he had not seen Saul since he was at Najoth, ver. 5. Nobe was afterwards accounted a sacerdotal city, ver. 19., and 2 Esdras xi. 32. --- Achimelech, who is perhaps the same with Achia (chap. xiv. 3,) and Abiathar, Mark ii. 32. --- With thee. He would not expose his men to the resentment of Saul, (Calmet) though he afterwards gave the priest to understand that he had some attendants, (ver. 2) as the gospel relates, Matthew xii. 3. He dismissed them before he entered Geth. (Calmet)The commentary then addresses the requirement of cleanliness for those who would receive the holy bread.
If the young men be clean, &c. If this cleanness was required of them that were to eat that bread, which was but a figure of the bread of life which we receive in the blessed sacrament [the Eucharist]; how clean ought Christians be when they approach to our tremendous mysteries? And what reason hath the Church of God to admit none to be her ministers, to consecrate and daily receive this most pure sacrament, but such as devote themselves to a life of perpetual purity. (Challoner) --- Women. God required this on many occasions, Exodus xix. 15. Urgent necessity determined Achimelech to grant the loaves, as our Saviour intimates, though it is probable that he first consulted the Lord, chap. xxii. 16. (Calmet) --- David perhaps went to Nobe on purpose to ask advice. (Menochius) --- We have here an example of a dispensation, and of the distinction between lay, or common, and holy bread. (Worthington)Haydock next recounts David’s bold arrival at the court of Achis in Geth.
Achis. He is elsewhere called Achimelech. This bold step was taken by God's order, (Salien) or secret impulse, as the high priest and Doeg knew not whither David had directed his course. (Haydock) --- Sanchez thinks David received no express declaration, as the event was not very prosperous. (Menochius) --- Many great men have taken refuge among their greatest enemies, as Themistocles, Alcibiades, and Coriolanus fled respectively to the Persians, Lacedæmonians, and Volscians, and were received with great respect. Indeed the acquisition of such men is equivalent to a victory. (Calmet) --- Though David might expect that his name would be hateful at Geth, as he had slain their great champion, &c., yet he had done it in an open manner, and had displayed the most heroic courage, so that the king and nobility might raise their thoughts above the vulgar sentiments of jealousy and revenge. (Salien) --- David only retired from the court of this king, to avoid the hatred of the courtiers; he returned again, and was kindly received, chap. xxvii. 1. (Calmet)
Consider
Haydock draws a doctrinal connection between the bread of the Presence and the Eucharist together with priestly purity.
If the young men be clean, &c. If this cleanness was required of them that were to eat that bread, which was but a figure of the bread of life which we receive in the blessed sacrament [the Eucharist]; how clean ought Christians be when they approach to our tremendous mysteries? And what reason hath the Church of God to admit none to be her ministers, to consecrate and daily receive this most pure sacrament, but such as devote themselves to a life of perpetual purity. (Challoner) --- Women. God required this on many occasions, Exodus xix. 15. Urgent necessity determined Achimelech to grant the loaves, as our Saviour intimates, though it is probable that he first consulted the Lord, chap. xxii. 16. (Calmet) --- David perhaps went to Nobe on purpose to ask advice. (Menochius) --- We have here an example of a dispensation, and of the distinction between lay, or common, and holy bread. (Worthington)On the massacre at Nobe the commentary notes the near-extinction of the house of Heli.
Five. Josephus read "385." Septuagint, "305." --- Ephod. They all appeared in this dress, as they were priests. (Calmet) --- It was different from the sacred ephod. (Abulensis) --- Thus the posterity of Heli was almost entirely cut off, as God had threatened, chap. ii. (Du Hamel; Tirinus)
Respond
1. Where in my life am I tempted to conceal the truth out of fear, and how does Haydock’s treatment of David’s words challenge me?
2. How does the commentary’s emphasis on purity before receiving holy bread invite me to prepare for the Eucharist today?
3. In what way does David’s refuge among unlikely allies encourage me to trust God’s protection even when human help seems absent?
Pray
Lord God, as David sought refuge in You amid his wanderings and received the holy bread from Your priests, grant us courage to turn to You in every trial. Purify our hearts that we may worthily receive the Bread of Life, and shield Your Church and its ministers from all persecution. Guide us by Your providence along hidden paths, we ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →