← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Tobit

Tobit 11-12 — drawing on Aquinas (Summa II-II q.83 a.11 saints intercession + I q.113 angels)

Tobit 11-12Saint Thomas Aquinas — Summa Theologiae + Catena Aurea + Commentary on Sentences22 min
Opening
The eleventh and twelfth chapters of Tobit set forth the healing of Tobit's blindness through the angelic medicine and the great revelation of Raphael's identity and mission. The angel discloses that he has been one of the seven who stand before the throne of God, that he has been the bearer of the prayers of Tobit and Sarah to that throne, and that he has been sent to test, to heal, and to bring news of God's mercy. Drawing on Aquinas's treatment of prayer in Summa II-II q.83 and especially of the intercession of the saints in q.83 a.11, and his treatment of the angelic ministry in I q.113 already considered, we may approach these chapters as the explicit revelation of the theological architecture that has been hidden through the narrative. The Church reads Raphael's revelation as one of the foundational Old Testament witnesses to the doctrine of the communion of saints and to the doctrine of the intercession of created persons before the divine throne — doctrines Aquinas articulates with scholastic precision and that the Catechism of the Catholic Church preserves at numbers 956 (intercession of the saints) and 957 (communion with the saints).
Read
Read Tobit chapters 11 and 12 with attention to the moment of revelation. In chapter eleven, mark the return of Tobiah and his bride to Nineveh; Anna seeing them from the road and running to embrace her son; Tobit's tearful greeting; the application of the fish's gall to Tobit's eyes per the angel's earlier instruction; the immediate healing of the blindness that had afflicted Tobit for years; the celebration; and the introduction of Sarah into the household with Anna. In chapter twelve, attend especially to the moment of revelation: Tobit's instruction to Tobiah that they should pay Azarias half of all they had brought home as wages; the conversation with Azarias in which the angel reveals himself as Raphael, one of the seven who stand before the throne of God, who has presented their prayers to the Holy One, who has been sent to test their righteousness and to heal them; his teaching about the value of almsgiving and prayer; his disclosure that he had appeared to eat and drink but did not in fact consume the food; and his ascent back to him who sent him.
Study
The revelation of Raphael in chapter twelve is one of the most theologically loaded passages in the deuterocanonical literature, and Aquinas's scholastic apparatus enables the contemporary reader to see in it the working out of multiple theological doctrines. The first doctrine the chapter discloses is the bearing of human prayer before the divine throne by angelic intermediaries. Raphael states explicitly: when you prayed, and Sarah your daughter-in-law, I brought the remembrance of your prayer before the Holy One. Aquinas treats this principle in II-II q.83 a.12 (whether angels and the souls of the dead intercede for us). His response is yes — the angels bring our prayers before God not because God needs the intermediary in order to hear (God hears every prayer immediately by virtue of his omniscience) but because the order of charity and the hierarchy of the universe involves the higher creatures in the ministry of the lower. Augustine in De Vera Religione 55 had articulated the same principle: the angels are charged with the ministry of bringing the affections of human prayer into the wider economy of the communion of charity. The Catechism preserves this doctrine at 336 (the role of angels in God's plan) and 350 (angels in the Church). The second doctrine the chapter discloses is the intercession of created persons before the divine throne — the principle Aquinas treats in q.83 a.11 (whether we ought to pray to the saints). His response, drawing on Saint Augustine and on the consistent patristic tradition, is yes: while God is the principal cause of all grace and the soul's prayer is ultimately addressed to him, the intercession of the saints (including the angels and the souls of those who have died in grace) is a real and effective instrument by which God ordinarily distributes the grace he has determined to give. The Tobit episode is the paradigmatic Old Testament instance of this principle. Raphael does not himself heal Tobit by his own power; God heals through Raphael's instrumental ministry. Raphael does not himself answer the prayer; God answers through Raphael's bearing of the prayer. The doctrine of the intercession of the saints articulated by Aquinas in q.83 a.11 is precisely the doctrine Raphael's revelation discloses. The third doctrine the chapter discloses is the proper ordering of human almsgiving and prayer. Raphael's discourse in chapter twelve includes the famous teaching that prayer is good with fasting, and alms with righteousness — better than to lay up gold treasures. The threefold pillars of the religious life that Catholic spirituality has preserved (prayer, fasting, almsgiving) find their Old Testament foundation in Raphael's teaching, and Aquinas treats each in his moral synthesis: prayer in II-II q.83, fasting in II-II q.147 (whether fasting is an act of religion), almsgiving in II-II q.32 already considered. Saint Leo the Great's sermons on Lent (which Aquinas cites in q.147) preserve the threefold pattern as the substantive content of the Lenten discipline that the Church has practiced since the patristic age. The fourth doctrine concerns the proper attitude toward the angelic ministry. Raphael's disclosure includes the discipline of withdrawing: when his mission is accomplished, he ascends back to him who sent him; he does not remain as an object of continuing devotion for its own sake. Aquinas in I q.62 (on the perfection of the angels in glory) holds that the perfected angels exist in perpetual contemplation of the divine essence, leaving that contemplation only to fulfill their missions and returning to it when the mission is accomplished. The Catholic veneration of the angels (dulia) is therefore ordered toward the divine source they reflect, not toward the angels as terminal objects of religious affection. The fifth doctrine concerns the literary form of the chapter itself. The angel's revelation includes the explicit statement that he appeared to eat and drink but did not consume the food. Aquinas in I q.51 a.3 already considered uses this verse explicitly: it is the Old Testament foundation of the scholastic teaching that angelic bodies are assumed for the purpose of the mission without performing the natural vital operations of human bodies. Tobit and Tobiah are taught by the angel himself that what they had perceived was the appearance of human eating without the substance of it; the scholastic articulation Aquinas provides is not an imposition on the text but the recognition of what the text itself discloses. The Catena Aurea on Luke 24:43 (the risen Christ eating fish before the apostles) preserves the patristic distinction that Aquinas develops: the risen body of Christ truly eats because it is the resurrected flesh now glorified, while the assumed body of the angel only appears to eat because it is not the angel's body but only its instrument.
Consider
Drawing on Aquinas's holding in II-II q.83 a.11 that we ought to pray to the saints because the intercession of created persons is a real and effective instrument of the divine economy, consider whether the structure of your own prayer acknowledges this doctrine. The contemporary culture, even within Catholic households, has sometimes drifted toward a prayer focused exclusively on direct address to God without the intercession of the saints. The Catholic tradition has held with steadiness that the saints' intercession is not a deflection from God but a participation in the communion of charity that God himself has established. Have you cultivated relationships with particular saints — the saint whose name you bear, the saints of your parish patronage, the saints whose feasts your liturgical year preserves — and do you regularly invoke their intercession? Consider too the threefold pattern that Raphael teaches: prayer with fasting, alms with righteousness, better than gold. The Lenten discipline of the Church preserves this pattern, but the underlying threefold structure is a year-round substantive of Catholic life rather than a Lenten exception. Have you ordered your weekly life according to the threefold pattern, or has the Lenten observance contracted into a six-week interruption of an otherwise unstructured spiritual life? Consider finally the discipline of the angelic withdrawal. Raphael ascends back to him who sent him when the mission is accomplished. The Catholic tradition has been careful about the distinction between veneration of the angels (which honors them as instruments of the divine providence) and the kind of attachment that would make the angel an object of continuing devotion for its own sake. Where in your devotional life have you maintained this discipline?
Respond
Identify one saint with whom you have not previously cultivated a relationship of regular intercession, and commit this week to invoke that saint's prayers daily for one specific intention. The intention may be small (the success of a particular project, the healing of a particular illness, the conversion of a particular person) but the discipline of the invocation itself is the substantive practice. Drawing on Aquinas's articulation in II-II q.83 a.11, you may invoke the saint with confidence that the intercession is a real instrument of the divine economy rather than a sentimental gesture.
Pray
O God, who through your archangel Raphael revealed the hidden ministry of angels bearing the prayers of the faithful before your throne and restored sight and joy to Tobit and Tobiah, receive our petitions through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints. Grant that we may trust ever more deeply in the communion of angels and saints who present our needs to your merciful heart. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Saint Thomas Aquinas — Summa Theologiae + Catena Aurea + Commentary on Sentences · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →