← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel

1 Samuel 15-16 — with Whedon

1 Samuel 15-16Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the reverent tradition of Methodist Episcopal study, we open Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments to trace the solemn transition recorded in 1 Samuel chapters 15 and 16. Whedon's Arminian-Wesleyan exegesis highlights divine sovereignty, the testing of kings, and the Spirit's movement upon the heart. As we listen, we are reminded that obedience remains the true measure of covenant faithfulness and that God's electing grace moves beyond outward appearance. May these pages stir holy fear and steadfast hope in every reader today.
Read
With quiet attention, read 1 Samuel chapters 15 and 16. Listen for the Lord's clear command to Saul, the sorrow of the prophet, and the unexpected anointing of the youngest son of Jesse. Let the narrative unfold without haste, allowing each scene to speak of both judgment and promise.
Study
Whedon opens by framing the war with Amalek as Jehovah's final test of Saul. Verses 1-9. SAUL’S WAR WITH AMALEK, 1 Samuel 15:1-9 . Jehovah deigns to give Saul’s obedience one more test. He has already warned him that, because of disobedience, his kingdom shall not be established in his posterity, ( 1 Samuel 13:14 ;) but ere he utters the final oracle of rejection he affords him one more trial. Occasion for this is found in the war with the Amalekites, those ancient enemies whose wanton hostility to the chosen people had, even in the days of Moses, drawn down upon them the curse of God. See Exodus 17:8-16 ; Deuteronomy 25:17-19 . He next presses the prophetic declaration that obedience surpasses every sacrifice. Verse 22. 22 . To obey is better than sacrifice For all the sacrifices and ceremonies of religion are to aid and promote obedience, not to be made a substitute for it. Disobedience can never be made a virtue even though attended by thousands of sacrifices. Samuel’s words here “rise far above the special occasion, and contain the key-note of the long remonstrance of the prophets in all subsequent times against an exaggerated estimate of ceremonial above obedience. The very flow of the words recalls to us the form, as well as the spirit, of Amos and Isaiah.” Stanley. Whedon then affirms the unchanging constancy of the Strength of Israel. Verse 29. 29 . Strength of Israel Jehovah, thus called not only because of his omnipotence, but also because of his constancy and truth the glorious object of Israel’s confidence. Will not lie nor repent Compare 1 Samuel 15:11 and note there. Jehovah has feelings of love and anger: love for the righteous and anger towards the wicked. If the righteous man turn from his righteousness, or the wicked from his wickedness, towards him correspondingly Jehovah’s feelings change. This is often called repentance in God. But beyond this the divine Nature is not subject to change. In man, however, repentance implies sinfulness and fallibility, and involves a moral and religious change, so that it is never after the manner of man that God repents.
Consider
Whedon concludes by presenting David as the man after Jehovah's heart who receives the Spirit from that day forward. Verses 1-13. THE ANOINTING OF DAVID, 1 Samuel 16:1-13 . We are now about to be introduced to him who figures in the following history as one of the most interesting and honoured personages of the olden time that neighbour of Saul, ( 1 Samuel 15:28 ,) that man after Jehovah’s heart, ( 1 Samuel 13:14 ,) who is to succeed Saul on the throne of Israel, and be the brightest star in all the host of kings. Soon after his anointing he is providentially introduced into the royal household, and still later, by his victory over Goliath, he suddenly becomes the idol of the nation’s heart. But from that proud day until the death of Saul he is persecuted by the jealous king, and flies from the court and from his home, and wanders up and down as an exile and outlaw.
Respond
Where in my life has partial obedience replaced full surrender? How do I guard against measuring others by outward stature rather than the heart? In what ways am I inviting the Spirit's daily renewal as David did?
Pray
Gracious Lord, who searches the heart and weighs every motive, grant us the grace of prompt and complete obedience. As Samuel mourned and David was anointed, teach us to yield to Thy electing purpose without murmuring. Remove from us every trace of vainglory or covetousness that would withhold what Thou hast commanded. Fill us afresh with Thy Spirit, that we may walk as those after Thine own heart. Through Christ our King we pray. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →