Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 John
1 John 4 — with Coke
Opening
In the warm spirit of early Methodism, we open Thomas Coke's Commentary on the Holy Bible to hear its steady witness to the truth of 1 John chapter 4. Bishop Coke, Wesley's trusted companion and the first Methodist bishop, wrote with pastoral clarity and evangelical fire. His words invite every believer to test every spirit, rest in the love of God made visible in Christ, and let that same love overflow toward one another. May the Spirit who inspired the apostle guide our reading and our living today.
Read
Let us now read 1 John chapter 4 slowly and prayerfully, listening for the apostle's call to discern the spirits and to dwell in the love that comes from God. Pause after each section, allowing the words to settle in the heart before the Lord.
Study
Coke opens by directing attention to the testing of spirits.
Verse 1. 1 John 4:1 . Believe not every Spirit, — By the spirits, understand not the men pretending to inspiration, nor the doctrines which they delivered, but the spirits from whence the doctrines proceeded; namely, first, the Spirit of God; secondly, the spirit of the man himself; or, thirdly, a demon, or wicked spirit. Having taken notice, ch. 1Jn 3:24 that true Christians had the Spirit, the apostle here insinuates, that the false prophets had either never received the Spirit, or had entirely quenched it. They therefore were not to believe every one who pretended to be inspired by the Spirit of God, but to try the spirits. We should observe, that this rule is directed to Christians in general; to the people, as well as ministers; and if the people think and believe at all, they must judge and believe for themselves. A man must either take somebody for his infallible guide, or he must try and judge for himself. How much soever some churches or particular Christians have condemned the liberty of private judgment, the Christian religion encourages the most generous and extensive liberty, or freedom of inquiry: and all Christians ought to assert that liberty, and make the proper improvement of it; neither lightly receiving, nor rejecting what is proposed to them.He then turns to the command to love one another.
Verse 7. 1 John 4:7 . Beloved, let us love one another: — St. Jerome tells us, that when this blessed evangelist had continued at Ephesus to extreme old age, and was with difficulty carried to the church between the arms of some of the disciples, being unable to pronounce more words, he was wont, every time they assembled, to say nothing but this, "Little children, love one another." In the verse before us, the apostle assigns a strong reason why we should love one another;— for love is of God. He who planted the principle of attraction in the material world, plants the principle of benevolence in intelligent creatures; and has in particular enjoined Christians to love one another. He therefore who, through grace, possesses and cultivates this disposition, manifests that he is a Christian, born into the family of God; and that he continues to be a true child of God, resembling his heavenly Father; and that he knows the nature and will of God, so as to comply therewith. Others may pretend to great knowledge and sound faith, or just sentiments in religion; but he who does not love his Christian brethren, has not that disposition, and does not thoseactions, which are agreeable to the nature and command of God, and pleasing and acceptable in his sight. See the next note.Next he unfolds the manifestation of divine love in the sending of the Son.
Verse 9. 1 John 4:9 . In this was manifested the love of God, &c.— All the blessings of Providence are effects of the divine love to man; but St. John has said, 1Jn 4:8 that God is Love itself; and to illustrate that, he here pitches upon the most remarkable proof and instance of God's love to man. The love of God was the source and origin of the plan of our redemption: the eternal Son of God, by his patient suffering and perfect obedience unto death, purchased or obtained of his great Father, to be the person who should be honoured with carrying this glorious plan into execution, which in time he will finish in the most complete manner, for all his faithful saints. God's sending his Son into the world, includes his dying for us; see 1 John 4:10 . He became the great vicarious Sacrifice, and, through the complete atonement which he has made, God the Father may now be just, and yet a Justifier of those that believe in Jesus. Those false prophets who denied Jesus to have a real body, and really to suffer and die, took away entirely the love which God manifested, in sending his only and dearly-beloved Son to die, that we might live through him. They not only invalidated the force of Christ's example, and the infinite merit of his atonement, but, of consequence, the greatness of his love, which appeared most illustriously in his willing sufferings and cheerful dying for us: and no wonder that they who thus enervated the love both of the Father and the Son, should not be moved by such infinitely amiable examples to love their Christian brethren.
Consider
Coke presses the central truth that God is love.
Verse 8. 1 John 4:8 . For God is love. — God is the most benevolent of all beings, full of love to his depending creatures; so that in him there is nothing wanting to the highest perfection of love. See 1 John 4:9-16 , &c. He is the great fountain and exemplar of love; he recommends it by his law, and produces and cherishes it by his influences; and the due contemplation of him, will of course inflame our hearts with love to his Divine Majesty, and to our fellow-creatures for his sake, whose creatures they are, but especially to our fellow-christians.He closes the section with weighty inferences for the church.
—How astonishing is the free love of God towards such sinful creatures as we are, that he (as his inspired servants testify,) has sent his beloved Son into the world to be the propitiation for our sins, that we might live in all blessedness and glory for ever with him! This is a high demonstration indeed, that God is Love; and we must be utter strangers to his amiable excellencies, if we do not love him: not that we are or can be beforehand with him in loving; for we love him, because he first loved us, and because we are brought under its influence and manifestation, to know and believe it. This melts our hearts and gains over our affections to him, and to his children for his sake. And what a sure token is this of our being born of God, and of his dwelling by his Spirit in us, and of our union and communion with him!
Respond
1. Where in my daily life am I most tempted to accept teaching without testing it against the apostolic word?
2. How does the love God has shown me in Christ shape the way I regard my brothers and sisters today?
3. In what concrete way can I let perfect love cast out fear and move me toward bolder witness?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the clear light of thy word and for the faithful labors of thy servant Thomas Coke. Grant us the Spirit of truth to discern every spirit and the Spirit of love to dwell in thee and in one another. May the love thou hast shown in sending thy Son fill our hearts, cast out every slavish fear, and make us bold to confess Jesus Christ come in the flesh. Keep us, we pray, in living union with thee until the day of judgment, when we shall stand with humble confidence before thy throne; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →