Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges
Judges 1-2 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in prevenient grace, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s careful exposition of Judges chapters 1–2 traces Israel’s first faltering steps after Joshua, showing how divine appointment meets human hesitation. His notes illuminate the call to Judah, the sectional league with Simeon, and the costly hesitation before iron chariots. Through his guidance we are invited to examine how obedience and unbelief shape the life of God’s people across generations. May the same Spirit who stirred those ancient elders quicken our hearts to faithful action.
Read
Let us now read together Judges chapters 1 and 2, listening for the Lord’s direction to his people and their response. As the tribes inquire who shall lead against the Canaanites, notice the interplay of promise, partial obedience, and the first shadows of compromise. Read slowly, allowing the narrative to reveal both the faithfulness of God and the frailty of his people.
Study
Whedon opens by setting forth the national inquiry that follows Joshua’s death.
Verse 1. PART FIRST. INTRODUCTION. CHAPTERS Judges 1:1 to Judges 3:6 . THE LEADERSHIP, Judges 1:1-2 . 1 . After the death of Joshua Probably not long after. Till Joshua died the affairs of the nation were closely associated with one great master mind, upon which came the chief responsibility of government. Moses and Joshua were to Israel like the chief generals of a great army, and the great body of the people had little sense of a national responsibility. But as soon as these great leaders are gone there comes a dawning sense of national unity and responsibility, and now not one man, but the whole people, the children of Israel , ask counsel of Jehovah. The children of Israel are here to be understood as the tribes west of the Jordan, represented by their elders. Asked the Lord By means of the urim and thummim. See note on Joshua 1:1 . The people and the elders had not forgotten the last counsels of Joshua. Joshua 23-24.He next unfolds the Lord’s designation of Judah for leadership among the tribes.
Verse 2. 2 . Judah The tribe; the individual had long been dead. Deuteronomy 1:35 . This designation of Judah to the pre-eminence was in substance a repetition of the prophetic blessing of dying Jacob: “Thou art he whom thy brethren shall praise; thy hand shall be upon the neck of thine enemies; thy father’s children shall bow down before thee.” Genesis 49:8 . But although God thus clearly designated Judah for the leadership, the tribe failed to understand that from among its thousands a personal leader and national executive should be sought, and measures at once be taken to organize a strong central government, and realize as soon as possible the ideal presented in the book of the Law. Here was Judah’s divine call, but the tribe neglected it, entered into a league with Simeon, andthrough all the period of the Judges kept sinking into comparative insignificance. In Samson’s time this tribe seems to have been the most cowardly in Israel, and utterly afraid to resist the Philistine conquerors. Compare Judges 15:11 , note. Not until David attained the throne did Judah recover from the effects of the failure to improve fully this divine call. I have delivered It was the divine purpose that the ultimate and complete conquest of the Promised Land should be wrought by Judah’s sceptre, but it was not done till the days of David. The land Not only the lot of Judah, but the whole land of Canaan.Whedon then explores the consequences of Judah’s encounter with iron chariots in the valley.
Verse 19. 19 . And he drave out the inhabitants of the mountain Hebrews, he seized or possessed the mountain. In ordinary cases of foreign invasion the mountains are the fortresses which are last to surrender. But the Israelites, having confidence only in mountain warfare, concentrated their energies upon these fastnesses and secured their possession. But could not drive out Literally, for not to drive out the inhabitants of the valley; that is, they were not to be driven out, or, as one might say, there was no driving them out. The word rendered valley is עמק , emek, and does not necessarily refer at all to the Philistine plain, which is called the Shephelah, Judges 1:9 . Emek denotes any valley, basin, or depression between mountains, and may here refer to plains situated among the mountains of Judah or elsewhere. Because they had chariots of iron This we are doubtless to take as the occasion, not the necessitating cause, of Judah’s ultimate failure to conquer all his foes. Iron chariots could not withstand the forces of Joshua ( Joshua 11:4-9 ) nor of Barak, ( Judges 4:15 ,) when the people of Jehovah fought with faith in his power, and Judah might likewise have conquered; but we understand that, after many triumphs, when Judah was brought to face these chariots of iron instruments of warfare strange and terrible he hesitated, wavered, gave way to fear, and thus lost faith in God, and then there was no driving out his enemy.
Consider
Whedon closes the section by weighing the deeper spiritual cost when strength leads only to tribute rather than obedience.
Verse 28. 28 . When Israel was strong The lack of strength was the excuse for their cowardice and disobedience to a positive command, notwithstanding they had the assurance of aid from God. Perhaps, too, their previous weakness was owing to their fear of the war chariots. See note on Judges 1:19 . Nearly all these towns were on the great plain of Esdraelon; and bordering, as they did, the track of oriental commerce with the great cities of Phenicia, they were probably well fortified. But, in course of time, it seems that Israel became strong enough to bring them into subjection. They put the Canaanites to tribute The love of money is now added to their love of ease and disobedience. When they became strong they were no more disposed to obey the voice of God than they were before. By long familiarity with them their pagan foes had ceased to be abominable in their eyes, while the command to exterminate them had become in their estimation more and more unreasonable and barbarous. Yet they soon learned, to their sorrow, that they had planted the seeds of social and national ruin by refusing to apply to themselves the divinely appointed safeguard of their well-being the radical extermination of their enemies.
Respond
1. Where in my own life has the Lord clearly designated a path that I have met with hesitation rather than wholehearted advance? 2. How might sectional or self-protective alliances be limiting the fuller obedience God desires from his people today? 3. When have I allowed fear of formidable obstacles to eclipse trust in the God who has already promised victory?
Pray
Gracious God, who appoints leaders and calls thy people to courageous trust, we thank thee for the light shed by thy servant Whedon upon these opening chapters of Judges. Forgive us when we inquire of thee yet shrink from the battle thou hast assigned. Strengthen our hearts against the chariots of fear and the subtle lure of compromise. Raise up in our day a people who, like Judah of old, move forward in the strength of thy promise. May the same grace that sustained Israel’s better moments now form us into a faithful witness, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →