← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Ecclesiastes

Ecclesiastes 1-2 — with Whedon

Ecclesiastes 1-2Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of our Wesleyan heritage we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. With reverent attention we listen as this faithful Methodist voice guides us through the searching wisdom of Ecclesiastes chapters 1 and 2, inviting heart and mind to weigh the true profit of life under the sun.
Read
Let us read together the first two chapters of Ecclesiastes, allowing the Preacher's measured words to settle upon us. As we listen, may the Spirit prepare our hearts to receive the searching commentary that follows.
Study
Whedon opens the study by establishing the solemn keynote. Verse 2. 2 . Vanity of vanities This utterance, like a prelude, gives the solemn keynote of the book. As we proceed, we shall see that it means, not that the works of God or the callings of men are unreal and delusive, but that the struggle to satisfy the heart in worldly things is vain. By repetition the writer makes his thought conspicuous and impressive, like a proposition in science which he goes on to prove. He then states the outcome of his initial survey. Verse 14. 14 . I have seen Meaning, “I have looked at, or considered.” The author is conscious of having done his work. Behold, all is vanity Koheleth states the result before he gives us the process by which he reached it. The phrase vexation of spirit is strangely inaccurate. It should be, a grasping after wind. So it is properly rendered in Hosea 12:1 , “feedeth on wind.” Whedon next compares the pursuits of wisdom and folly. Verse 11. 11 . Then I looked Hebrew, Then I turned. The result is, that not one or all of these gathered delights quieted the craving of the mind or gave lasting happiness. All was vanity and a grasping at wind, and there was no gain from them at all. Now follows a comparison of wisdom and folly, as Koheleth tried them. Wisdom has the advantage in value, but not so very much, for neither can exempt a man from the common lot of suffering and sorrow.
Consider
In conclusion, Whedon draws the inference for daily living. Verse 24. 24 . Nothing better We now have the inference drawn from the investigations here recorded, as a conclusion to the first section of the book. The best way, seeing that neither wisdom nor pleasure can appease the craving soul, is to mingle moderate and cheerful self-indulgence with the reasonable business of life, pushing neither study nor pleasure to excess, but acknowledging the good hand of God as balancing the gifts it confers. Finally he affirms the advantage granted to the obedient. Verse 26. 26 . God giveth A final comparison to the advantage of obedience to God, is now drawn. No solid, satisfying good is obtained from worldly pursuits, as thus far tried. But Koheleth affirms from his experience that God gives to the obedient much gratification as they pass through life, and the sinner seems often as a servant working for the happiness of better men than himself. Yet even this the experience of a brief and transient life cannot satisfy the craving of a human soul. Leaving now the experiments of wisdom and pleasure, which are so entwined with each other by comparison and contrast that we have to treat them as one, Koheleth proceeds to investigate concerning industry, or, as we would be more likely to say, business, to see what it can do to relieve a dejected mind.
Respond
Where in your present labors do you sense the Preacher's question pressing most keenly? How might moderate enjoyment joined with grateful acknowledgment of God steady your heart today? In what way does the assurance that God gives to the obedient invite you to renewed trust?
Pray
Gracious God, who orders all things in wisdom and love, grant us grace to receive the searching word of Ecclesiastes through the faithful exposition of thy servant Whedon. Keep us from vain striving after wind, and teach us instead the cheerful trust that acknowledges thy good hand in every gift. May the light of obedience shine upon our path, and may we rest at last in the portion thou hast prepared for those who love thee; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →