Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 John
1 John 4 — with John Calvin
Opening
Today we turn to John Calvin's commentary on 1 John chapter 4, where the reformer carefully guides readers through the apostle's instructions on discerning true teaching from error. Calvin's insights help us navigate the spiritual realities John describes, from testing spirits to recognizing the source of genuine love. His verse-by-verse approach brings clarity to this vital portion of Scripture, showing how doctrine and practice belong together in the Christian life. As we listen to Calvin's words, we are invited to grow in both understanding and obedience.
Read
We begin by reading the full text of 1 John chapter 4. Take time to listen prayerfully to John's words about testing spirits, confessing Christ, overcoming the world, and walking in love. Let the passage speak first, preparing your heart for the wisdom Calvin offers in his commentary on these verses.
Study
Calvin opens by outlining the three parts of the apostle's argument.
But what the Apostle says consists of three parts. He first shews an evil dangerous to the faithful; and therefore he exhorts them to beware. He prescribes how they were to beware, that is, by making a distinction between the spirits; and this is the second part. In the third place, he points out a particular error, the most dangerous to them, he therefore forbids them to hear those who denied that the Son of God appeared in the flesh. We shall now consider each in order.Calvin then addresses the command not to believe every spirit.
1 Believe not every spirit When the Church is disturbed by discords and contentions, many, as it has been said, being frightened, depart from the Gospel. But the Spirit prescribes to us a far different remedy, that is, that the faithful should not receive any doctrine thoughtlessly and without discrimination. We ought, then, to take heed lest, being offended at the variety of opinions, we should discard teachers, and, together with them, the word of God. But this precaution is sufficient, that all are not to be heard indiscriminately.Next, Calvin explains the need to try the spirits.
Try the spirits As all were not true prophets, the Apostle here declares that they ought to have been examined and tried. And he addresses not only the whole Church, but also every one of the faithful.Calvin proceeds to give the special mark for distinguishing true prophets.
2 Hereby, or by this, know ye He lays down a special mark by which they might more easily distinguish between true and false prophets. Yet he only repeats here what we have met with before, that as Christ is the object at which faith aims, so he is the stone at which all heretics stumble. As long then as we abide in Christ, there is safety; but when we depart from him, faith is lost, and all truth is rendered void. [82]
Consider
Calvin connects the testing of spirits to the victory believers already possess.
4 Ye are of God He had spoken of one antichrist; he now mentions many. But the many were the false prophets who had come forth before the head appeared. [83] But the Apostle's object was to animate the faithful, that they might courageously and boldly resist impostors, for alacrity is weakened when the issue of the contest is doubtful. Besides, it might have caused the good to fear, when they saw that hardly the kingdom of Christ had been set up, when enemies stood ready to suppress it. Though then they must contend, yet he says that they had conquered, because they would have a successful issue, as though he had said that they were already, though in the middle of the contest;, beyond any danger, because they would surely be conquerors.Calvin returns to the exhortation to love as the mark of knowing God.
7 Beloved He returns to that exhortation which he enforces almost throughout the Epistle. We have, indeed, said, that it is filled with the doctrine of faith and exhortation to love. On these two points he so dwells, that he continually passes from the one to the other.
Respond
How does Calvin's emphasis on testing spirits shape the way you evaluate teaching today? In what areas of your life do you sense the need to rely more fully on God's Spirit for discernment? How might growing in love for others confirm the reality of your knowledge of God?
Pray
Father, by Your sovereign grace You have sent Your Son in the flesh and given Your Spirit to bear witness that Jesus Christ is Lord. Grant us discernment to test every spirit by the truth of Your Word, that we may abide in love for one another as those born of You and confess with boldness that greater is He who is in us than he who is in the world. Cast out fear by the perfect love that flows from Your covenant faithfulness, and keep Your church steadfast until we behold You face to face. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →