← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges

Judges 17-18 — with Whedon

Judges 17-18Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Wesleyan holiness and the earnest pursuit of scriptural truth, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. This revered Methodist Episcopal resource opens the often-overlooked chapters of Judges 17 and 18 with careful historical and theological insight. Whedon guides readers through the irregularities of Israel's tribal life, the rise of private sanctuaries, and the enduring call to covenant fidelity. His work invites us to examine both the failures and the persistent grace that mark this season of Israel's story, strengthening our own walk of obedient faith.
Read
With hearts prepared by the Spirit, let us read Judges chapters 17 and 18. These passages recount Micah's household shrine, the wandering Levite, and the Danite migration northward. As we listen, may the Lord grant us discernment to receive both the warning and the mercy contained in these ancient records of his people.
Study
Whedon opens by explaining the verse that accounts for the lawlessness of the period. Verse 6. 6 . No king This verse seems here, as everywhere, to explain the irregularities and evils of the age. It here explains how a man in central Palestine could establish such a semblance of idolatry, and profanely make a priest contrary to the requirements of the law. There was no central government to look after such irregularities, and bring the whole nation to uniform methods of worship, or counteract and destroy the growth of various evils. He next shows Micah's relief upon securing a Levite as priest. Verse 13. 13 . Now know I Micah had not felt easy and safe before. He seems to have feared that he had gone too far, and he evidently knew enough of the law to understand that the tribe of Levi had been set apart to the priesthood and ministry of the sanctuary. But now, having a priest from the divinely chosen tribe, he begins to feel sure of Jehovah’s favour. Whedon then explores the divine response given through an irregular priestly ministry. Verse 6. 6 . Before the Lord is your way That is, ordered of him, and acceptable in his sight. The Danites requested him to inquire of God ; he reports a favourable response from Jehovah, and in this interchange of the names Elohim and Jehovah some find that Micah’s illegally constituted priest had purer notions of religion than these Danites. They speak more like idolaters, he like a true prophet. But did Jehovah really answer through the medium of this illegal priest? Why should he not? Did he never use for communication of his will any medium but that of a person altogether pure and good and conformed to his law? Or is it clear that a refusal to answer through this Levite would, in this case, have been wiser, or accomplished a better purpose, than the answer that was given? God winked at ( Acts 17:30 ) the darkness and ignorance of those times, and we do wrong to judge those ancient characters and facts by the standard of New Testament ethics. Micah and his priest had certainly turned aside from the exact regulations of the law of Moses, but everything recorded of them shows an earnest purpose to serve and please Jehovah. Their fault was largely excused by the circumstances of their age, and the response which Jehovah gave this inquiring Levite is a representative of the ten thousand instances in which his blessings have come to devout worshippers through systems and forms of religion far from pure.
Consider
Finally Whedon weighs the deliberate textual alteration introduced to shield the name of Moses. Here, then, has doubtless been a wilful corruption of the sacred text, made with the pious design of shielding the venerable name and character of Moses. Jewish zeal thought it detrimental to Moses to have a near descendant so far gone aside from the Law as this Levite was, and therefore attempted to substitute the hated name of Manasseh, the idolatrous son of Hezekiah. As the Levite was a young man, ( Judges 18:3-15 ,) it is probable that he was not strictly the grandson of Moses, but a near descendant, probably a great-grandson, for the word בן , son, is often used in this sense. Such a near descendant of Moses would very naturally be widely known in Israel, and hence his recognition by the Danites. Judges 18:3 . But such was the looseness of the age, and the want of a powerful central government, that this descendant of the great Lawgiver was a homeless wanderer, and became one of the first ministers of an illegal sanctuary service.
Respond
1. Where in our own day do we risk creating private forms of worship that drift from God's appointed means? 2. How does the narrative challenge us to value a rightly ordered church life under the lordship of Christ? 3. In what ways might God still work through imperfect instruments while calling his people to greater purity?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the light of thy Word and for faithful servants such as Daniel D. Whedon who have labored to expound it. Forgive the ways we fashion religion after our own liking and grant us grace to walk in the order thou hast established. Keep thy church from every idol and every irregular ministry that would grieve thy Spirit. Raise up pastors and people who serve thee with clean hands and pure hearts. May the study of these chapters stir us to renewed covenant faithfulness until Christ returns. In the name of Jesus we pray. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →