Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 31 — with Clarke
Opening
In the warm light of Wesleyan grace we open Adam Clarke's Commentary on the Whole Bible and listen for the plain sense of Scripture that leads every believer toward practical holiness. Today the final chapter of First Samuel invites us to trace both the sorrowful end of a troubled king and the steadfast mercy of God that still calls hearts to repentance and trust.
Read
With quiet attention read 1 Samuel 31 aloud, letting the narrative of defeat, loyalty, and burial settle in the heart. Ask the Spirit to prepare you to receive the wise observations Clarke offers on these closing scenes.
Study
Clarke opens by recounting the opening of the battle on Mount Gilboa.
Verse 1. CHAPTER XXXI A battle in Mount Gilboa between Israel and the Philistines; in which the former are defeated, and Saul's three sons slain , 1, 2. Saul, being mortally wounded, and afraid to fall alive into the hands of the Philistines, desires his armour-bearer to despatch him; which he refusing, Saul falls on his sword, and his armour-bearer does the same , 3, 6. The Israelites on the other side of the valley forsake their cities, and the Philistines come and dwell in them , 7. The Philistines, finding Saul and his three sons among the slain, strip them of their armour, which they put in the house of Ashtaroth, cut of their heads, send the news to all the houses of their idols, and fasten the bodies of Saul and his three sons to the walls of Beth-shan , 8-10. Valiant men of Jabesh-gilead go by night, and take away the bodies; burn them at Jabesh; bury their bones under a tree; and fast seven days , 11-13. NOTES ON CHAP. XXXI Verse 1 Samuel 31:1 . Now the Philistines fought — This is the continuation of the account given in 1 Samuel 29:1-11 . The men of Israel fled — It seems as if they were thrown into confusion at the first onset, and turned their backs upon their enemies.He then examines the ancient tradition concerning the sword by which Saul fell.
Verse 4. Verse 1 Samuel 31:4 . Draw thy sword, and thrust me through — Dr. Delaney has some good observations on this part of the subject: "Saul and his armour-bearer died by the same sword. That his armour-bearer died by his own sword is out of all doubt; the text expressly tells us so; and that Saul perished by the same sword is sufficiently evident. Draw THY sword , says he to him, and thrust me through ; which, when he refused, Saul , says the text, took THE sword , (את החרב eth hachereb, the very sword,) and fell upon it . What sword? Not his own , for then the text would have said so; but, in the plain natural grammatical construction, the sword before mentioned must be the sword now referred to, that is, his armour-bearer's, 1 Chronicles 10:4-5 . Now it is the established tradition of all the Jewish nation that this armour-bearer was Doeg , and I see no reason why it should be discredited; and if so, then Saul and his executioner both fell by that weapon with which they had before massacred the priests of God. So Brutus and Cassius killed themselves with the same swords with which they stabbed Caesar ; and Calippus was stabbed with the same sword with which he stabbed Dio ."Clarke next celebrates the grateful courage of the men of Jabesh-gilead.
Verse 11. Verse 1 Samuel 31:11 . When the inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead heard — This act of the men of Jabesh-gilead was an act of gratitude due to Saul, who, at the very commencement of his reign, rescued them from Nahash, king of the Ammonites, (see 1 Samuel 11:1 , &c.,) and by his timely succours saved them from the deepest degradation and the most oppressive tyranny. This heroic act, with the seven days' fast , showed that they retained a due sense of their obligation to this unfortunate monarch.
Consider
Clarke concludes his exposition by surveying the whole course of Saul's reign.
Verse 13. Verse 1 Samuel 31:13 . And fasted seven days. — To testify their sincere regret for his unfortunate death, and the public calamity that had fallen upon the land. THUS ends the troublesome, and I had almost said the useless, reign of Saul. A king was chosen in opposition to the will of the Most High; and the government of God in effect rejected, to make way for this king. Saul was at first a very humble young man, and conducted himself with great propriety; but his elevation made him proud, and he soon became tyrannical in his private conduct and in his political measures. His natural temper was not good; he was peevish, fretful, and often outrageous; and these bad dispositions, unchecked by proper application to the grace of God, became every day more headstrong and dangerous.He closes with a careful pastoral judgment on the manner of Saul's death.
He was to all appearance mortally wounded, when he begged his armour-bearer to extinguish the remaining spark of life and he was afraid that the Philistines might abuse his body, if they found him alive; and we can scarcely say how much of indignity is implied in this word ; and his falling on his sword was a fit of desperation, which doubtless was the issue of a mind greatly agitated, and full of distraction. A few minutes longer, and his life would in all probability have ebbed out; but though this wound accelerated his death, yet it could not be properly the cause of it, as he was mortally wounded before, and did it on the conviction that he could not survive.
Respond
Where in my own story do I sense the danger of rejecting God's clear word as Saul did? How does the loyalty of Jabesh-gilead stir me to show gratitude through costly action? In what area of life am I invited to surrender pride and rest again in the mercy that Clarke so warmly commends?
Pray
Gracious Lord, thank you for the honest witness of Scripture and for the faithful labors of Adam Clarke that open its plain meaning. Keep us from the pride that ruined Saul and teach us instead the humility that receives your grace. May the loyalty shown at Jabesh-gilead awaken in us a like readiness to honor those who have blessed us. Through the Spirit form us in practical holiness until we see you face to face. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →