Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 5-6 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Welcome to this daily lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary on the first book of Samuel. In these chapters the sacred text recounts the mysterious journey of the ark among the Philistines and its return to Israel. Haydock's Catholic Commentary gathers the insights of earlier Catholic exegetes to illuminate the events, the judgments of God, and the reverence due to holy things. Over the next twenty minutes we will read the Scripture, study selected passages from the commentary, consider their deeper meaning, respond in reflection, and conclude in prayer.
Read
Take up your Bible and read slowly through 1 Samuel chapters 5 and 6. Notice the successive judgments that fall upon the Philistines, the counsel of their priests and diviners, and the contrasting reverence or irreverence shown by the Israelites when the ark returns. Allow the narrative to unfold without haste, preparing the heart for the commentary that follows.
Study
Haydock opens the section on chapter 5 by reflecting on the ark's arrival among the Philistines.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Azotus, one of the principal cities of the Philistines. It is astonishing that God permits these infidels to touch the ark, He who resented the conduct of Oza, and of the Bethsamites, with such severity. But the law regarded the Israelites, and the pagans were ignorant of it. (Calmet) --- The servant, who knows his master will, and does not obey, shall suffer many stripes; [Luke xii. 47.] and those who have the happiness of professing the true religion, and dishonour it by their immorality, must expect to feel the heavy hand of the judge, much more than ignorant unbelievers. (Haydock) --- The Philistines could not suppose that they had gained a victory over God, since they knew he might be displeased with the conduct of his people; and they soon began to perceive that they had brought the greatest misfortunes upon themselves.He next examines the idol Dagon and its fate before the ark.
Dagon is the same as Derceto, Atergatis, Venus, and the moon, (Calmet) and was represented like a woman, (Tirinus) as far as the waist, and a fish below. (Haydock) (Judges xvi. 23.) --- The ark was placed near the idol, out of respect; (Calmet) or as a trophy of the victory, which they attributed to Dagon. (Menochius) --- Thus they hung up the arms of Saul in the temple of Asteroth; (chap. xxxi. 10,) and David placed the sword of Goliah[Goliath] in the tabernacle.Haydock then turns to the counsel given by the Philistine priests and diviners.
If, &c. The lords were already determined to send back the ark. But the priests knew that some still would not believe that it was the cause of their affliction. To convince all, they try an experiment, which would decide the matter; and in case the ark went back, some suitable presents must accompany it, as a propitiation (Haydock) for the sin which they would not (Menochius) then doubt had been incurred. (Haydock) --- Though God stands in need of nothing, all must acknowledge their dependence on him. The pagans always made some present, when they appeared before their idols or monarchs, and God requires the like testimony of submission, Exodus xxiii. 15.
Consider
Haydock considers the judgment that fell upon the Bethsamites for their irreverence toward the ark.
Seen; and curiously looked into. It is likely this plague reached to all the neighbouring country, as well as the city of Bethsames. (Challoner) --- For we need not suppose that all these deaths took place in one day. The ark seems to have continued there for some time, ver. 18. Hebrew, "because they had looked into, or at the ark." (Haydock) --- It was unlawful, even for the Levites, to touch or to look at the ark uncovered; (Tirinus; Numbers iv. 15, 20,) and the Hebrew expression into, is often taken in this sense, Proverbs vii. 15., and xi. 4. --- Men of rank. (St. Gregory, &c.) "Ancients," Chaldean. Some would suppose that only these 70 perished, and were of as much value as 50,000 of the common people: for they will not allow that he latter number was slain. Out of that number, 70 were made victims of the divine justice. (Tirinus; Sa) --- Bochart translates, "he slew 70 out of 50,000." The Syriac and Arabic read, "5070 men." Josephus only admits 70 who were slain, "because they dared to touch the ark with their profane hands, as they were not priests." Hebrew, "and he slew of the people 70 men, 50,000 men. (Calmet) --- Kennicott seems to suspect that a cipher has been added in the Hebrew at the end. Protestants, "50,000, and threescore and ten men." (Haydock) --- Some would insert aderant in the Vulgate, and 50,000 "were present." (Du Hamel) --- The Chaldean, Septuagint, &c., constantly retain these numbers, and we must not judge of God severity by our feeble reason. (Calmet) --- This decision is the most common. (Menochius) --- The people had indulged their curiosity, to see whether the Philistines had taken the tables of the law out of the ark, &c. (Serarius) --- As the ark was terrible to the infidels, so it was also to those true believers, who treated it with disrespect. (Worthington)
Respond
How does the commentary's emphasis on reverence for sacred things challenge my own attitude toward the Eucharist and the liturgy? In what ways might I be tempted to treat holy realities as ordinary objects? What practical step can I take this week to grow in the awe that the ark inspired in those who approached it rightly?
Pray
Lord of hosts, you alone are God and you defend the honor of your dwelling-place. Grant us the faith to approach your mysteries with holy fear and loving confidence. May the example of both judgment and mercy recorded in these chapters move us to deeper reverence for the Blessed Sacrament and for every vessel and rite that serves your worship. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, form our hearts to be true tabernacles of your presence. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →