← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians

1 Corinthians 5 — with Whedon

1 Corinthians 5Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
Beloved, we open our hearts today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments, that venerable Wesleyan guide whose clear Arminian exposition has long served the Methodist Episcopal pulpit. In his treatment of First Corinthians chapter five, Whedon leads us through the apostle’s first apostolic response to grievous sin within the Corinthian assembly. With reverent precision he unfolds the call to holy discipline, the purging of leaven, and the limits of ecclesiastical authority. May the Spirit who guided Whedon’s pen now quicken our own reading, that the Church of our day might again prize purity without despising mercy.
Read
Let us now give attentive ear to the fifth chapter of Paul’s First Epistle to the Corinthians. As the sacred text is read, listen for the apostolic severity that refuses to tolerate incest within the household of faith, yet always aims at the offender’s ultimate salvation. Receive the chapter as both warning and invitation, that the Spirit may search our own congregations and our own hearts.
Study
Whedon opens by tracing the report’s origin and literal force. Verse 1. PART SECOND. ST. PAUL’S TEN APOSTOLIC RESPONSES, 1 Corinthians 5:1 to 1 Corinthians 16:4 . PAUL’S FIRST RESPONSE: TO THE RUMOURS TOUCHING THE REPORT OF INCEST, 1 Corinthians 5:1-13 . a. Judgment upon the incestuous man, 1 Corinthians 5:1-5 . 1 . Reported This report, like those touching the Church strifes in the first chapter, must have come from the “household of Chloe,” or from the three special messengers; probably the latter. Commonly Literal Greek, wholly. This cannot mean, as it is rendered by some, “every-where,” or “generally;” for in Ephesus it could have not been generally spread, and at Corinth Paul could know nothing of the extent of its spread. The Greek word, with a negative in a sentence, would signify “not at all;” as here, with an affirmative, it must signify, reversely, absolutely, or as Alford, actually. He next contrasts the church’s pride with the grief that ought to have moved them. Verse 2. 2 . Puffed up Note on 1 Corinthians 4:6 . Neither shame nor grief over this foul sin reduced their inflation. Sensuality was a fashionable indulgence in Corinth. The precise shape and rigidity of Christian ethics were not in their minds fixed; the Church took the matter easily; neither its exultation over its worldly prosperity, nor its pride in possession of spiritual gifts, was toned down. Rather mourned Instead of indifference and persistent pride the whole Church should have melted in grief for the downfall of this one man. The Christian body should have sympathetic nerves for the sin or sorrow of each and every member. That To the end that. Their grief should have prompted them to the instant removal of the sin, even at the expense of the excommunication of the sinner. Taken away By the law of Christ, the great head of the Church. That not by death but by excommunication is meant, is clear from Paul’s directions 1 Corinthians 5:4-5 . Whedon then unfolds the pervasive nature of leaven and the command to purge it. Verse 6. b. Sin, like a pervading leaven, must be purged from the Church, 1 Corinthians 5:6-8 . 6 . Your glorying Rather, your ground of boasting; namely, an entire forgetfulness of your disgrace from this sensuality. Not good Not honourable or noble. It was a base insensibility to moral reproach. Know ye not A solemn phrase indicating a truth it behooved them well to know: used by St. Paul in this epistle ten times. Leaven Is a portion of old dough in a high state of fermentation, which, added to a new mass of dough, spreads the fermentation through the whole lump , and so renders the bread, upon baking, porous and light. As this fermentation is a sort of disintegration, and proves so pervasive, the ancients saw in it an image of moral corruption. So Plutarch (quoted by Wetstein) says: “Wherefore is it unlawful for the priest of Jove, called Flamen Dialis, to touch leaven? Because leaven itself comes of putrefaction, and being commingled corrupts the mass; and leaven itself seems, indeed, a putrifying; for by abounding, it altogether acidifies and corrupts the flour.” Wetstein also thus quotes a Jewish author: “Our rabbins call lust a leaven in the lump; for as a little of the yeast impregnates the whole mass and corrupts it, so lust corrupts the whole man.”
Consider
On the purpose of discipline he presses the hope of salvation through severity. Spirit may be saved The excommunication, though an act of severity, is an act of love. It is the Church’s last admonition of the guilty to win him unto repentance. And the destruction of the flesh , by illness or consumption short of death from supernatural infliction, as a divine penalty, would show the truth of Christianity, the value of the Church, and the guilt of sin; and might perhaps bring the apostate to reflection, conviction, and salvation. So St. Paul delivered Hymeneus and Alexander unto Satan , in order that , admonished by the consequent destruction of the flesh, they might learn not to blaspheme . Upon this case St. Paul now ( 1 Corinthians 5:6-8 ) states the object of Church discipline, namely, the purity of the Church, and (9-13) the degree of separation from the wicked required, and the limitation of the Church’s discipline to its own membership. Finally he concludes by affirming that God alone judges those outside the church. Verse 13. 13 . God judgeth Many pagan Corinthians may have been far more corrupt than this incestuous Church member. But they could not be expelled the Church, for they were already without its pale. Nor had the apostle any miraculous power to emaciate their bodies or blind their eyes. If he had possessed such power he would have also had a stupendous amount of penal work on his hands. Judgment enough was impending over them, from inflicting which the apostle was exempt by God’s own power.
Respond
1. Where in our present fellowship might tolerance of known sin be masquerading as Christian liberty? 2. How does the call to purge leaven shape the way we practice both personal and corporate repentance? 3. In what manner can our discipline remain both firm and hopeful, aiming always at the restoration of the offender?
Pray
O Lord of the Church, who hast set watchmen upon Thy walls, grant us the courage of apostolic judgment and the tenderness of apostolic love. Cleanse Thy people from every leaven of malice and sensuality, that the feast we keep may be marked by sincerity and truth. Where sin has been named among us, raise up grief that leads to removal rather than pride that breeds infection. Yet let every act of discipline be undertaken in hope that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus. Keep us from the false separation that flees the world altogether, and from the false fellowship that sanctions evil within Thy household. Through the same Christ who is our Passover, sacrificed for us, we pray. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →