Eterniseed › Curriculum › Ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes 7-8 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Wesleyan inquiry and holy living, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for its measured exposition of Ecclesiastes chapters 7 and 8. With Arminian warmth and Methodist reverence for Scripture, Whedon guides us through the sage's counsel on prudence, the limits of human wisdom, and patient submission under God's providence. His words invite us to weigh discretion against the mysteries of life and death, always pointing toward a faith that trusts the unseen hand. Let this study steady our hearts in the present moment while we await the fuller light of the gospel.
Read
With quiet attention, open the sacred text to Ecclesiastes 7 through 8. Listen for the measured voice of Koheleth as he weighs the value of a good name, the discipline of sorrow, the perils of excess, and the call to patient obedience under authority. Read slowly, allowing each proverb to settle in the heart, and note how the Preacher repeatedly returns to the fear of God amid life's uncertainties. Let the Spirit make these ancient words living counsel for today.
Study
Whedon opens by introducing Koheleth's discussion on the scope and advantage of prudence.
Introduction. Koheleth next discusses the scope and advantage of prudence and discretion what the Greeks call sophrosyne, but for which the English has no single term, unless it be the ungraceful one, rightmindedness. The taste and usage of the East, as well as his own professional habit as a hakim, or public teacher, lead Koheleth to use the proverbial or sententious sometimes called gnomic style of expression. “He sought out and set in order many proverbs.”He then addresses the counsel against excessive righteousness from the standpoint of simple discretion.
Verse 16. 16 . Be not righteous overmuch The Hebrew is very deficient in the little words that guide thoughts and make transitions easy, such as, “also,” “therefore,” “moreover,” etc. This verse is rested on the preceding, and should be introduced by then Be not , then, etc. Remember, this is the language of prudence. Common sense makes no martyrs. They come from a loftier sentiment. It sees little good in self-denial, though much in moderation. It averages things and holds a “golden mean.” Had Koheleth foreseen how this verse was to perplex and scandalize many good men, he would hardly have had courage to write it. But he has spoken faithfully from his standpoint of simple discretion. There is some truth in this precept for all time. In this generation no men have been so popular as Mr. Lincoln, who was broad but moderate in politics, and Mr. Beecher, who is broad but moderate in religion. One need not call them the highest of the day, as statesmen or divines, but they carried the largest masses, and, to a certain degree, for their good.Turning to chapter eight, he explores the value of prudence as it relates to submission to rulers.
Introduction. The value of prudence as relating to submission to rulers is now discussed. The Greek and Roman idea of personal independence was of something proud, irritable, and defiant. A different sentiment breathes from this chapter. In the sore trials of many ages and in many lands the Jews have been a patient people: “Sufferance is the badge of all our tribe.” The philosophy and advantage of patience are now unfolded.
Consider
Whedon concludes his search by affirming that man's own inventions account for the race's wickedness.
Verse 29. 29 . Man… many inventions The one abiding and ever-true result of Koheleth’s search is this that the “inventions,” devices of man’s own heart, are enough to account for all the appalling wickedness of the race. No necessity to sin is framed into our original constitution, or laid upon us by the order of providence.Finally, he presses the absolute incomprehensibility of God's ways among men.
Verse 17. 17 . A man cannot find The sad, weighty conclusion is, that the way and work of God among men is absolutely beyond comprehension. Every effort to compute it is entirely unavailing. Many, many questions may be asked to which God is pleased not to answer, and which man, at his wisest wisdom, cannot. The problem, ever unsolved, stares at him like the sphinx in the desert, “with calm, eternal eyes.”
Respond
1. Where in my daily walk do I sense the Spirit inviting a prudent middle path rather than anxious excess? 2. How does the call to patient submission under authority test my trust in God's unseen ordering of events? 3. In what present circumstance am I tempted to repine instead of receiving both prosperity and adversity as from the Lord's hand?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank Thee for the steady light of Thy Word and for faithful expositors who have gone before us. Grant us, by Thy Spirit, the prudence that fears Thee without despairing of Thy mercies. Keep us from the folly of hasty anger and from the presumption that would unravel Thy counsels. Teach us to receive both joy and sorrow as Thy wise appointment, and to walk before Thee in the liberty of holy love. May the same grace that raised our Lord Jesus from the dead strengthen us to endure and to do good in the day of small things. In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →