Eterniseed › Curriculum › Joshua
Joshua 15-16 — with Whedon
Opening
In the quiet discipline of daily Scripture study we turn again to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. With reverent attention and Wesleyan clarity this nineteenth-century Methodist scholar guides us through the allotments recorded in Joshua. His work invites us to trace the faithfulness of God in the inheritance of Judah while holding fast to the Arminian confidence that every promise is offered to obedient hearts. May the same Spirit who inspired the text open our understanding as we listen.
Read
With Scripture open before us we now read Joshua chapters fifteen and sixteen. Let the measured cadence of the ancient record settle upon the heart. Notice the careful boundaries, the named cities, and the quiet courage of Caleb's house. Read slowly, allowing each place-name to become a testimony of divine provision and human responsibility.
Study
Whedon opens by recording the original lot of Judah.
Verses 1-63. ORIGINAL LOT OF JUDAH, Joshua 15:1-63 . [The tribe of Judah received the first allotment, and a very disproportionate share of the Land of Promise, for its territory embraced nearly the half of western Palestine. This original lot, however, was afterwards diminished by assigning a part of it to Simeon. Joshua 19:1 . The original borders, districts, and cities of Judah are detailed with great minuteness in this chapter, and to a much greater extent than those of any other tribe. Grove suggests that “this may be due either to the fact that the lists were reduced to their present form at a later period, when the monarchy resided with Judah, and when more care would naturally be bestowed on them than on those of any other tribe; or to the fact that the territory was more important, and more thickly covered with towns and villages, than any other part of Palestine.” Smith’s Bib. Dict.He next traces the detailed boundaries of that inheritance.
Verse 12. 12 . To the great sea and the coast That is, the coast of the Mediterranean from Jebneel southward formed Judah’s western boundary. The writer, having now given the boundaries of Judah, is about to give a list of the cities within these bounds. But before proceeding to do so he enters a brief account of Caleb’s conquest of his portion, which Joshua had allotted him. See Joshua 14:6-15 . As Caleb’s possession included the most important city and central seat of the whole tribe of Judah, it is natural that the fact of its conquest should be recorded here. As Joshua 15:13-19 are nearly identical with Judges 1:10-20 , some have supposed that this passage in Joshua was copied from that in Judges; and others, on the contrary, maintain that the passage in Judges was taken from this. Keil, however, urges that both passages were drawn from one common source, a document older than either the Book of Joshua or that of Judges.]Whedon then arranges the cities into four geographical divisions.
Verse 19. 19 . A blessing A special favour, a gift. Springs of water As her portion was a field having a southern exposure to blazing suns and sultry winds, she argues the eminent propriety of supplementing the gift by adding a well-watered adjoining tract. He gave her the upper springs and the nether , a tract of hill and dale abounding in water. The cities of Judah are grouped in four divisions corresponding to the physical geography of Judah’s lot: the NEGEB, or south country, Joshua 15:21-32 ; the SHEPHELAH, or valley, Joshua 15:33-47 ; the MOUNTAIN, Joshua 15:48-60 ; and the WILDERNESS, Joshua 15:61-62 . The cities of the Shephelah and the Mountain are enumerated by groups. These cities are nearly all unknown. For an elaborate attempt to identify them, see Wilton’s Negeb, Part III, page 70. In the following notes nothing is said on the names of those places of which no modern trace has been certainly discovered.
Consider
Whedon reflects on the prophetic blessings that rested upon Judah's portion.
Many and great were the prophetic blessings pronounced on Judah by his father. Genesis 49:8-12 . He was to be the pride and glory of his brethren, the mighty conqueror, whose symbol was the lion, and whose pre-eminence was represented by the sceptre and the ruler’s staff, never to depart “until Shiloh come.” The same prophetic blessing also characterized his section of the Promised Land. “The elevation of the hills and tablelands of Judah is the true climate of the vine, and at Hebron, according to the Jewish tradition, was its primeval seat. He bound ‘his foal unto the vine, and his ass’s colt unto the choice vine; he washed his garments in wine, and his clothes in the blood of grapes.’ Genesis 49:11 . A vineyard on a hill of olives, with the ‘fence,’ and the ‘stones gathered out,’ and the ‘tower in the midst of it,’ is the natural figure which, both in the prophetical and evangelical records, represents the kingdom of Judah.He closes the section by weighing the numerical discrepancy among the listed cities.
Verse 32. 32 . All the cities are twenty and nine This does not agree with the names detailed in the text, which are thirty-six at least. To remove this discrepancy the Rabbins assume that the cities given to Simeon are not counted. But there were twelve or fifteen given to that tribe. Others suggest that several of these places were mere hamlets, and were not counted; or that compound names have been separated, or epithets prefixed been made into names; still others, that one place may have had several names, or that there is an error in the numerical letters for twenty-nine. The Syriac reads thirty-six, an evident change in that version to meet the difficulty. It is more probable that several names were added by a later hand after the country was more thickly peopled, possibly to gratify local pride, and the number twenty-nine was not changed.
Respond
How does the generous portion given to Judah stir gratitude for the inheritance we have received in Christ? In what ways does Caleb's steadfast faith challenge our own readiness to claim God's promises? Where might the careful ordering of Judah's cities invite us to steward our own daily allotments with greater faithfulness?
Pray
Gracious God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, we thank Thee for the sure word preserved in Joshua and illumined by Thy servant Whedon. Grant us the same spirit of conquest and contentment that marked Caleb's house. May the boundaries Thou hast drawn for Thy people become for us paths of holiness and service. Keep us from murmuring over our portion and fill us with zeal to occupy every city Thou hast appointed. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →