← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Job

The Lord Answers out of the Whirlwind

Job 37-38Morals on the Book of Job (Moralia in Iob) by St. Gregory the Great22 min
Opening
For thirty-seven chapters Job has wrestled with his grief and answered his friends; now the long argument is hushed, and a greater Voice speaks. Out of the whirlwind the Lord Himself answers Job — not to crush a sufferer, but to lift a soul that had stood firm under every wound and now needed one thing more: to be humbled before the unsearchable majesty of God. Elihu had already pointed to the storm where God's glory thunders; and then the storm opens, and God asks the question that silences every creature: "Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth? when the morning stars sang together?" The Christian East loves St. Gregory the Great, the Dialogist — venerated on 12 March, whose Liturgy of the Presanctified Gifts is sung through Orthodox Lent — for reading this theophany Christologically: the incomprehensible God who meets the humbled soul is the same God who would appear "humble in weakness" yet remain "lofty in strength." The whirlwind is not God's anger but His school.
Read
Read Job 37–38 — Elihu's closing hymn to the God whose voice marvellously thunders, who seals up the hand of every man, who balances the clouds and spreads the light; "with God is terrible majesty." Then, in chapter 38, the great turn of the whole book: "the LORD answered Job out of the whirlwind, and said, Who is this that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge? Gird up now thy loins like a man; for I will demand of thee, and answer thou me. Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth?… When the morning stars sang together, and all the sons of God shouted for joy?" Question upon question follows — the sea shut up with doors, the morning commanded, the gates of death — and Job, who had longed to plead his case, is brought to the threshold of a silence deeper than speech.
Study
Why does God speak from a whirlwind, and not from the gentle inward voice? St. Gregory hears two distinct modes of the divine address, and the storm is the one that tames pride. For God in truth lifts up His voice in the cloud, when He frames His exhortation to the darkened hearts of unbelievers, by the tongues of His preachers. The terror is mercy in another key: For by the gentle address of the Lord, is shewn His affectionate sweetness, but by His terrible, is pointed out His dreadful power. And St. Gregory names the very danger the whirlwind exists to cure — the subtlest peril of a holy man who has conquered every outward trial. For what commonly slays a soul more fatally than consciousness of virtue? Job had borne the loss of goods, children, and health unbroken; the one wound left was the weapon of pride. So God, by sheer questioning, lays bare how little the creature knows, that the creature may know its Maker.
Consider
"Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth?" The question is not God boasting of His power, but God enlarging the soul until it can adore what it cannot comprehend. St. Gregory insists that the nearer the mind is caught up, the further it sees that God exceeds it: For though our mind is caught up on high, yet it is transcended by the immensity of His greatness. And the right posture before judgments we cannot fathom is reverent stillness, not argument: We ought, therefore, to rest the more silent under His judgments, the more we see that we perceive not the reason of His judgments. Then the whirlwind unveils its hidden joy: when "the morning stars sang together," it was the very angels, St. Gregory teaches, who would one day adore the Redeemer; the Elect angels glorify even with redeemed men in the end of the world the bounty of heavenly grace. The God who founded the earth is the God who came to redeem it; the storm that humbles Job opens onto the song of heaven.
Respond
When the unanswerable questions of your own life rise up like a whirlwind — Where were you? Why this loss, this silence, this delay? — hear them not as God's contempt but as God's nearness, the very mode by which He "frames His exhortation to the darkened hearts" of those He loves. Beware the wound St. Gregory names: "consciousness of virtue," the quiet pride that creeps in after we have borne our trials well. The cure is the whirlwind's own lesson — to rest "the more silent under His judgments, the more we see that we perceive not the reason of His judgments." You will not be given the blueprint of the foundations of the earth; you will be given the God who laid them. And the same Voice that humbles you was the joy of the morning stars at the creation and will be your joy in the end — for He who is "lofty in strength" stooped to become "humble in weakness" for your sake. Let the storm do its work, and adore.
Pray
O God who answerest out of the whirlwind, who laidst the foundations of the earth while the morning stars sang together: I cannot search out Thy ways, and I would not, if I could, escape the holy fear with which Thy greatness fills me. Save me from the consciousness of my own virtue, that secret pride which no outward trial can reach; humble me beneath Thy mighty hand, that I may be exalted in due time. Teach me to rest silent under judgments I cannot perceive, trusting that Thou who art terrible in majesty art tender in love, and forsakest me not even when I have rejected Thee. Lift up my heart with the song of the morning stars to adore Thee, who in Thy strength art lofty, and in Thy mercy didst become humble for my salvation. To Thee, the Maker of all and the Redeemer of all, with the Father and the Holy Spirit, be glory now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.

Morals on the Book of Job (Moralia in Iob) by St. Gregory the Great · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →