Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 John
1 John 3 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal devotion we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments, a classic Arminian-Wesleyan exposition marked by clear doctrinal insight and warm scriptural fidelity. Whedon’s treatment of 1 John 3 unfolds the wonder of divine sonship, the necessity of practical holiness, and the abiding power of the regenerate life. His words invite us to examine our own hearts in the light of apostolic truth, holding together the assurance of grace with the call to persevering righteousness. As we listen, may the same Spirit who inspired the apostle quicken our understanding and confirm our adoption.
Read
Let us now give reverent attention to the third chapter of the First Epistle of John. Read the chapter slowly and prayerfully, allowing its searching yet comforting words to rest upon the heart. Note especially the apostle’s testimony concerning our present sonship, the hope that purifies, the incompatibility of sin with the regenerate life, and the love that marks the children of God. Receive the passage as a living word for the church today.
Study
Whedon opens by directing attention to the present and future glory of our sonship.
Verse 2. 2 . Now… yet Contrast of the humble present with the transcendent future. Are Emphatic; true, in spite of the occultness of our sonship and non-recognition by the world . Even what we shall be , does but very dimly appear. But at the resurrection, as Paul says, a “glory shall be revealed in us.” And then will be “the manifestation of the sons of God.” Romans 8:18-19 . Like him… see him as he is From the certainty that we shall see him as he is, we know that… we shall be like him ; for it is only like natures that truly realize each other. The brute can realize man only just so far as he resembles man; and man can realize spirit only just so far as he is like spirit; and the human can see God only so far as it is like him .He then shows how that hope moves the believer to active purification.
Verse 3. 2 . Purification from actual sin the test of our sonship , 1 John 3:3-10 . 3 . And Even in our humble state the very hope inspires every man to purify himself , aspiring even now to a divine likeness. Purifieth himself Outwardly, by abstaining from the external acts of sin; inwardly, by cultivating the grace of the sanctifying Spirit within us. He God. If our faith holds to an impure God above us, we are indeed abandoned to impurity; but if the divine holiness is ever our standard of character, then we aspire to the high and holy.Turning to the test of righteousness, Whedon stresses the continuous practice that alone proves genuine sonship.
Verse 7. 7 . Let no man deceive you An earnest warning against the Nicolaitan doctrinaries who taught that holiness is consistent with licentious deeds and open wicked life. Doeth The continuous present. Not he that merely once doeth , but who permanently practiseth righteousness is righteous . There is no righteousness in the man that doeth not righteousness . By their fruits shall ye know them.On the divine seed he affirms its permanent yet incompatible presence with sin.
Verse 9. 9 . His (God’s) seed The regenerate vital principle divinely implanted remaineth as a permanent though not irremovable element in him . This definition of the seed accords essentially with the various definitions given by most commentators. So Luther, “natura spiritualis,” spiritual birth-nature; De Wette, “the power of the divine life;” Braune, “the spirit of God.” Alford less happily refers it to “the divine word of truth.” While the fixed purpose of faith abides he cannot sin , or be a regular sinner, any more than ice can bear caloric, for the two things are incompatible. The falsely regenerate Nicolaitan can grossly and continuously sin , and retain his pseudo-regeneration; but the truly regenerate cannot practise sin, because he is genuinely born of God ; and while so, sin-practice is for him an incompatibility, not a volitional impossibility.
Consider
Whedon presses the full force of the text upon doctrines of perseverance and sinlessness.
Those who press the terms of this text to prove the infallible perseverance of all regenerate persons must accept them in their full literality: and then they will prove, not only certainty of not apostatizing, but an incapability to even sin, an impeccability in the regenerate. Nor can the text prove the sinlessness of merely the entirely sanctified, or the class of “perfect Christians,” for the predicates are affirmed of all that are born of God . If the words prove that a regenerate person cannot become a sinner, then Romans 8:7 proves that no carnally minded man can ever become subject to the law of God; for the same word for cannot is there used. See our note. Alford, Wordsworth, and others remark here again the import of the Greek perfect tense as having the force of a present; which, indeed, is well expressed in our English translation is born .He further clarifies the present force of the perfect tense in the believer’s ongoing life.
The Greek aorist would be was born, and Alford remarks pointedly that in practice the force of the perfect in Christian life is sadly apt to degenerate from the is to the was; the former expressing present regenerate life, in which to practice sin is impossible; the latter the departed vitality, in which the impossible has become easy. The verb sin, in Hebrews 10:26 , clearly means to become a sinner, in opposition to being a Christian. In this chapter, ( 1 John 3:8 ,) sinneth is in the continuous present, and means permanently practises sin. See note on 1 John 5:18 . But the true meaning is simply this: The Gnostic, in his false regeneration, can consistently live in the practice of sin; but a Christian cannot practice sin, for as a Christian he retains a regenerate principle incompatible with sin. He cannot practice sin and stay a Christian. Wordsworth gives a pertinent passage from Ignatius, who was born before St. John’s death.
Respond
1. How does the hope of being like Christ at His appearing stir you to greater purity of heart and life today? 2. In what ways does your daily conduct give evidence that the seed of God truly abides in you? 3. Where might the Lord be calling you to move from mere profession to the active, commandment-keeping love that marks the children of God?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank Thee for the clear light of Thy word as opened by Thy servant Whedon. Grant us the full assurance of our adoption while we walk in the purifying hope of Christ’s appearing. Keep the divine seed alive within us, that we may neither practice nor excuse sin. Form in us that practical righteousness and brotherly love which alone prove we have passed from death unto life. May the witness of Thy Spirit confirm every sincere act of obedience, and may our lives display the holiness without which no man shall see the Lord. Through Jesus Christ our Savior. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →