← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Maccabees

1 Maccabees 9-10 — Eterniseed (Catholic with deuterocanon)

1 Maccabees 9-10Eterniseed Original — Catholic Voice22 min
Opening
The ninth and tenth chapters of 1 Maccabees carry the reader through the death of Judas Maccabeus at the battle of Elasa and the succession of his brother Jonathan to the leadership of the Jewish resistance and to the high priesthood itself. The book passes here from the heroic phase of the revolt into the political and dynastic phase, in which the Maccabean leader becomes an actor on the wider stage of Seleucid succession crises and Roman diplomacy. Judas falls in chapter nine outnumbered twenty to one at Elasa, his death lamented by all Israel in a manner the inspired author records with deliberate echoes of the lamentation for Saul and Jonathan at Mount Gilboa. Jonathan succeeds his brother in the leadership of the band of Hasidim that survives, conducts a long guerrilla war against Bacchides, and in chapter ten is courted in turn by Demetrius the First Soter and by Alexander Balas, the pretender to the throne, both of whom offer Jonathan the high priesthood in exchange for his political alignment. Jonathan accepts the offer from Alexander, dons the sacred vestments at the feast of Tabernacles in the one hundred and sixtieth Seleucid year, and from that moment the Maccabean family combines in itself the offices of military leader, political ruler, and high priest. The Church reads this development with attention to its mixed character: the political acquisition of the high priesthood by a non-Zadokite family was the proximate cause of the later split within Judaism between the Sadducean (Zadokite-claimed) party and the Pharisaic party, and the Maccabean fusion of political and priestly office prefigures by contrast the New Testament's careful distinction of the spiritual authority of Peter from the temporal authority of Caesar.
Read
Read 1 Maccabees chapters 9 and 10 with attention to the human texture of Judas' death and the political texture of Jonathan's succession. In chapter nine, attend to Bacchides' return to Judea after Nicanor's defeat; the great army he brought against Judas; the rapid melting away of Judas' force when they saw the size of the Syrian army; Judas' refusal to retreat though only eight hundred remained with him; the battle at Elasa; Judas' fall at the moment when the Syrian right wing began to collapse before him; the lamentation of all Israel that the strong one had fallen; and the burial of Judas at Modin in the tomb of his fathers. In chapter ten, attend to the rise of Alexander Balas claiming descent from Antiochus Epiphanes; the bidding war between Demetrius Soter and Alexander for Jonathan's allegiance; the offers of high office, of the priesthood, of confirmation in independence; Jonathan's choice of Alexander; his vesting in the sacred robes at the feast of Tabernacles in the one hundred and sixtieth Seleucid year; the marriage alliance of Alexander with Cleopatra Thea of Ptolemaic Egypt at Ptolemais; and Jonathan's attendance at that festival as honored guest of both kings.
Study
The death of Judas Maccabeus at the battle of Elasa is recorded by the inspired author with deliberate echoes of the death of Saul and Jonathan at Mount Gilboa in the first book of Samuel. Both narratives begin with the catastrophic disparity of forces; both record the desertion of the troops at the sight of the enemy; both end with the death of the leader despite his personal valor; both close with national lamentation. The author's purpose in this typological framing is theological: he places Judas in the line of the great Israelite leaders fallen in defense of the covenant, even as he records the political complications that follow Judas' death and that distinguish the Maccabean era from the period of the kings. The lamentation of Israel is recorded in striking terms: how is the strong one fallen, the savior of Israel; and the people went into mourning and wept many days. The Church has read this lamentation as a particular witness to the bond of love that the people of God bear toward those whom God has raised up among them, and as a foreshadowing of the lamentation that the women would utter at the foot of the cross of the true Savior of Israel who fell at his own Elasa called Calvary. The succession of Jonathan to the leadership of the Hasidim band is described with attention to the formal continuity of the family. The brothers gather to take counsel; they elect Jonathan to be their leader in place of Judas; and Jonathan accepts the office. The Church recognizes in this transition the principle that providence may bring forth gifts of leadership in a family across generations, and that the Maccabean charism was not exhausted in the heroic figure of Judas but continued in different forms through Jonathan and then through Simon. The chapter then narrates the long guerrilla war that Jonathan conducted against Bacchides in the wilderness east of the Jordan and in the Judean hill country: the brothers ambushed and outmaneuvered the Syrian general repeatedly until Bacchides finally concluded a treaty that left Jonathan in effective control of the countryside while the citadel of Jerusalem remained in Syrian hands. The tenth chapter then opens the political phase of Jonathan's leadership. The rise of Alexander Balas as a pretender to the Seleucid throne claiming descent from Antiochus Epiphanes set up a bidding war between him and Demetrius Soter for the political support of Jonathan, whose brigand force had become a significant factor in the Judean countryside. The text records the letters and offers with notable detail. Demetrius first offered Jonathan the position of king's friend and the right to gather an army and to retain the fortified strongholds; Alexander then offered Jonathan the high priesthood itself, the title of king's friend, the right to wear royal purple and a golden crown. Jonathan accepted Alexander's offer and donned the sacred vestments at the feast of Tabernacles in the one hundred and sixtieth Seleucid year, which corresponds to October of 152 BC. The Church reads this acceptance with mixed judgment. On one hand the de facto restoration of a Jewish high priesthood under Jewish military protection was the practical fulfillment of the Maccabean cause, since the high priestly office had been emptied by the murders of Onias the Third and the apostasy of his successors. On the other hand the Maccabean family was not Zadokite — was not descended from Zadok the priest of Solomon's age whose family had held the high priestly office from Solomon to Onias — and the acquisition of the high priesthood by a non-Zadokite family through political appointment by a Gentile king was theologically irregular and would prove the seed of the later split within Judaism between the Sadducees (the Zadokite-loyalist party, whose name derives from Zadok's) and the Pharisees (the Hasidic-descended party that accepted the Hasmonean dynasty). The New Testament inherits this tension: the priestly families opposing Jesus are not Zadokite either but the Hasmonean and Herodian appointees of the Roman period, and Jesus' announcement that he is the true temple and the true high priest in the manner of Melchizedek (Hebrews 7) cuts through the entire Hasmonean and Sadducean claim. The Church reads the Hasmonean fusion of priestly, political, and military office in chapters nine and ten as the negative foil to the Petrine principle later articulated, by which the spiritual authority of the keys is held in the line of the apostles without being fused with the temporal authority of Caesar.
Consider
Consider Judas Maccabeus' death at Elasa as a school of leadership that does not abandon its post even when outnumbered twenty to one. The text takes pains to record that when Judas saw the size of the Syrian army most of his soldiers melted away, that he was urged to retreat, that he refused saying he would not turn away from the enemy even if their hour had come, that he engaged battle with the eight hundred who remained, and that he fell when the Syrian right wing had begun to collapse before him. The Church has read this scene from the patristic period as a school of the priestly and pastoral courage that does not abandon the flock when the wolves grow numerous. Where in your own pastoral or familial or vocational responsibility have you been tempted to retreat when the disparity of forces seemed overwhelming? Consider too Jonathan's acquisition of the high priesthood. The Catholic moral tradition has been clear about the difference between legitimate political support of the Church and the political appointment of bishops by lay rulers — the long medieval struggle of the Investiture Controversy under Saint Gregory the Seventh and beyond is precisely the Church's working out of the lesson the Maccabean precedent embodied in its problematic form. The spiritual office must not be in the gift of the temporal ruler; the Church's freedom from civil patronage is itself a constituent of her catholicity. Where do you see in the present life of the Church or of your country the same temptation to fuse spiritual office with political appointment? Consider finally the providential irony of the Maccabean tension. The very family whose heroism delivered the temple from Antiochus would become through its political acquisition of the priesthood the family whose successors would put to death the Messiah who came to fulfill all that the temple had foreshadowed. The Church holds this tension without dissolving it; the Maccabean witness remains luminous, and the Hasmonean error is recorded honestly.
Respond
Pray a decade of the Sorrowful Mysteries this week for the priestly state — for the bishops and priests of your own diocese who must navigate the perennial tensions between the temporal powers that court the Church and the spiritual authority of the keys that belongs to her alone. As you pray each Hail Mary, hold before your interior eye the long line from Mattathias and Judas and Jonathan through Peter and the apostles to the present successor of Peter, asking that the spiritual office be kept free of temporal entanglement.
Pray
Almighty and eternal God, who in Judas Maccabeus' death at Elasa preserved for the lamentation of your people the memory of the savior of Israel who would not turn his face from the enemy even when outnumbered twenty to one, sustain in your bishops and priests the same pastoral courage that does not abandon the flock when the wolves grow numerous. Where the Maccabean acquisition of the high priesthood by political appointment of a Gentile king prefigured the perennial temptation to fuse spiritual office with temporal patronage, keep your Church free of every such entanglement, that the office of the keys may remain in the apostolic succession unburdened by the gift of any civil ruler. By the intercession of Saint Peter to whom the spiritual authority was first entrusted, and through the prayers of the Blessed Virgin Mary, mother of the priestly people who lament their fallen leaders and pray for those still on the field, give us shepherds whose love of you exceeds their love of office. Through Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, forever and ever. Amen.

Eterniseed Original — Catholic Voice · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.