← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Matthew

Matthew 16 — with Whedon

Matthew 16Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal devotion and Arminian confidence in prevenient grace, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s clear, Scripture-saturated exposition opens Matthew 16 with the demand for a sign, the warning against leaven, Peter’s confession, and the Lord’s first plain announcement of the cross. His words guide us to see both the apostolic foundation and the suffering road that every true disciple must walk.
Read
Let us now read the entire sixteenth chapter of Matthew, listening for the Savior’s call to discern the signs of the times, confess him as the Christ, and take up the cross that follows such a confession.
Study
Whedon opens by presenting the solemn turning point at which our Lord endows the apostolic college with the keys. Verses 13-19. § 73. THE ENDOWMENT OF THE APOSTOLIC COLLEGE WITH THE KEYS, Matthew 16:13-19 . Our Saviour’s ministry has now drawn to its zenith. He has exhibited his character and laid his lessons before his disciples. He has trained them so that while the rest of the world is in wonder and doubt about him, expressing its various conjectures, they will be ready to confess him clearly and solidly to be the Christ. He has so impressed upon their minds his history and doctrine, that when he shall leave them, under the aid of the pentecostal spirit they will be able to found his kingdom and Church on earth. He now proceeds after solemn prayer to assemble them together and in a formal manner to require the common profession of faith; to lay them as a foundation for his Church, of which himself was the ground; to promise them the victory over the powers of hell; and to give them the apostolic keys by which, endowed with power from on high, they should be able to open and shut the doors of the Church, in such a way as should be ratified in heaven. After that, he dares fully open before them the prospect of his death and sufferings. This, the opening of the SIXTH PERIOD, must therefore be considered as a most important turning point in our Lord’s history. Thenceforward his is a Ministry of Sorrow. See Historical Synopsis. He then expounds the renewed name given to Peter and the rock upon which the Church is built. Verse 18. 18 . Thou art Peter With thy renewed apostleship (for it is indeed a new one) I give thee a renewed name. As Peter signifies stone, and as thou and thy fellow-disciples are to be the foundation stones of my new Church, I name thee forever by that symbolical title of Peter, that is, stone. Upon this rock The material of which thou art composed, as the apostolic foundation stone. In the Syriac language, in which our Lord spoke, the word Peter and this word rock were doubtless the same word. But they were all as truly stones, and made of rock, as he. But as he alone spoke the verbal confession, so to him alone was addressed and belonged the verbal title which commemorated it. Indeed, they are expressly called stones, ( Ephesians 2:20 ; Revelation 21:14 ,) though the word in the original, lithos , is a different without being a less expressive word than Petros. Whedon next distinguishes his reading of the rock from the claims of Rome and other interpretations. They hold it to be derogatory to Christ’s dignity for there to be any other foundation stone of his Church than Christ himself. They hold that our Lord said: Thou art Peter, a stone, and upon this rock (pointing perhaps to himself) I will build my Church. But this is inconsistent with the laws of a natural interpretation. Others understand that the confession which Peter made was a rock. Thou art a stone, and upon this rock of truth which thou hast confessed, and upon this faith which thou hast professed, will I build my Church. But Biblical language always holds men, not truths, to be foundation stones. The rock is not the doctrine, nor the confession, but the confessor. I understand that it is the apostle himself who is the rock; yet not as a man, nor as a private confessor of the Saviour’s Messiahship, nor as Lord of the apostolic twelve, but as a specimen and representative of what all the twelve were.
Consider
Whedon weighs the several historic constructions of the rock and states his own conclusion. The expression, this rock upon which I will build my Church, has received very different interpretations from the doctors of the Church in various ages. The first is the construction given by the Church of Rome, and made the basis of the enormous imposture of the papacy. It affirms that the rock is Peter individually, that the commission constituted him supreme apostle, with authority, inherited from him by the bishops of Rome. But 1 . As may be shown, not Peter alone, but each apostle, was a rock and a recipient of the keys, and all were coequal in powers. 2. Were the authority conveyed to Peter alone and personally, it must still be shown that this personal prerogative was among the successional attributes conferred upon him. 3. That Peter was ever bishop of Rome is without historical foundation; and the pretense of a succession from him by the Romish bishop is a fable. Some have made the word rock designate Christ himself. Finally he shows how the promise of the Son of man coming in his kingdom is fulfilled at the resurrection. Verse 28. 28 . Verily I say The accomplishment of the enterprise for which they toil and earn a martyr’s reward is now stated. Son of man coming Is parallel with Matthew 10:23 ; both are fulfilled at Christ’s resurrection. As the Son of man would be come before the apostles had gone over the cities of Israel, so these same apostles standing here should see the Son of man coming. Some standing here would refer to the eleven apostles, excluding Judas, who did not behold Christ in his resurrection power. These eleven were only some, not all, of those standing here; for it appears by Mark 8:34 , that Jesus had called the people to be present at this discourse with his disciples. The declaration that they should see the Son of man at that time is too plainly literal for any fulfilment at the destruction of Jerusalem.
Respond
1. Where in my own life am I still demanding a sign from heaven rather than heeding the signs of the times already given? 2. How does Whedon’s portrait of the apostles as foundation stones encourage me to stand firm under trial? 3. In what concrete way is the Lord inviting me to take up my cross and follow him this week?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the clear testimony of thy servant Whedon and for the apostolic confession he so faithfully expounds. Grant us the same Spirit-wrought faith that enabled Peter to own Jesus as the Christ, the Son of the living God. Keep us from the leaven of unbelief and from every desire for a crown without a cross. Build us, with all the saints, upon that rock which is Christ and his chosen apostles, that the gates of hell may never prevail against thy Church. Through the same Lord Jesus Christ, who liveth and reigneth with thee and the Holy Ghost, one God, world without end. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →