Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges
Judges 19-20 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in Scripture’s plain testimony, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s verse-by-verse exposition of Judges 19–20 confronts the shocking moral collapse within Israel and the costly discipline that followed. His careful attention to chronology, custom, and covenant responsibility guides us through these difficult chapters with both candor and reverence. As we listen, we are invited to trace how the absence of a king in Israel exposed the hardness of human hearts and the necessity of humble dependence upon the Lord. May the same Spirit who moved Whedon’s pen quicken our hearts to receive the word with meekness.
Read
With hearts prepared by prayer, let us read Judges chapters 19 and 20 in full. Hear the Levite’s journey, the horror at Gibeah, the gathering of the tribes at Mizpeh, and the fierce civil war that nearly extinguished Benjamin. Read slowly, allowing the narrative’s weight to press upon the conscience. Note each refusal to seek the Lord early and every costly consequence that followed. The word of God still speaks; let us attend to it together.
Study
Whedon opens by establishing the historical setting of the Levite and his concubine.
Verse 1. THE LEVITE AND HIS CONCUBINE, Judges 19:1-30 . 1 . In those days When Phinehas, the grandson of Aaron, was high priest, ( Judges 20:28 ;) consequently, not long after the days of Joshua. Sojourning on… mount Ephraim So that he was in the same vicinity where Micah dwelt. Judges 17:1 . A concubine A wife of second rank, who had no other rights than those of cohabitation and subsistence, and even then the husband could send her away with a small present, as Abraham did Hagar. Genesis 21:14 . The practice is condemned by New Testament ethics, but by this standard we are not to judge the examples of Nahor, ( Genesis 22:24 ,) Abraham, ( Genesis 25:6 ,) Jacob, ( Genesis 30:3 ; Genesis 35:22 ,) and other of the Old Testament worthies. The Law of Moses made provision for concubinage; but even its regulations touching man and wife were set aside by our Lord, and treated as a politic measure, in view of the hardness of the people’s hearts. Matthew 19:8 .He then describes the depravity of the sons of Belial in Gibeah.
Verse 22. 22 . Making their hearts merry By eating, drinking, and conversation. This indicates the warmth and cheer of ancient friendship and hospitality. Sons of Belial Low, lewd, worthless fellows, such as their conduct showed them to be. See note on 1 Samuel 1:16 . Bring forth the man Most shameful and impudent demand, the revived voice of wicked Sodom. Compare Genesis 19:1-11 . That we may know him “These,” says Clarke, “were genuine Sodomites as to their practice; rascals and miscreants of the deepest dye; worse than brutes, being a compound of beast and devil inseparably blended.”Whedon proceeds to the assembly of Israel at Mizpeh.
Verse 1. THE COUNCIL AT MIZPEH, Judges 20:1-11 . 1 . From Dan even to Beer-sheba The common formula to designate the entire country, from its northern to its southern boundary. Compare 1 Samuel 3:20 ; 2Sa 3:10 ; 2 Samuel 17:11 ; 2 Samuel 24:2 ; 2Sa 24:15 ; 1 Kings 4:25 . In the later books the formula is reversed: 1 Chronicles 21:2 ; 2 Chronicles 30:5 . On Dan, see at Judges 18:7 ; Judges 18:29 ; on Beer-sheba, Genesis 21:31 . Land of Gilead The country east of the Jordan. See on Judges 10:8 ; Judges 10:17 . Unto the Lord The meaning is, that the assembly was held as in the sight of the Lord. The tribes came together in the name of the Lord, and bound themselves by solemn oaths and execrations to destroy Benjamin. Compare Judges 21:15 ; see note on Judges 11:11 . In Mizpeh Not the Mizpeh in the land of Gilead, where the eastern tribes assembled in the time of Jephthah to prepare for war against Ammon, ( Judges 10:17 ,) but the Mizpeh of Benjamin, which is mentioned in Joshua 18:25-26 , in connexion with Gibeon and Ramah, and which was probably identical with the modern Neby Samwil, a little northwest of Jerusalem. See note on 1 Samuel 7:5 . This was an appropriate place for the council. Commanding a wide prospect, it was a central place for all the tribes, and was in the territory of Benjamin, near the spot where the offence took place, so that all proper witnesses to the case might be near at hand.Finally he narrates the initial defeats in the war against Benjamin.
Verse 21. THE WAR AGAINST BENJAMIN, Judges 20:20-48 . 21 . Destroyed down to the ground That is, smote them so that they lay dead upon the ground. Twenty and two thousand Almost as many as all Benjamin’s host contained. Compare Judges 20:15 . But of the Benjamites very few seem to have fallen.
Consider
Whedon concludes the chapter by noting the unparalleled nature of the deed.
Verse 30. 30 . No such deed done nor seen It has its only parallel in the history of ancient Sodom, long before Israel’s exodus from the land of Egypt. Compare Genesis 19:1-11 .On the outcome he tallies the heavy losses among the Benjamites.
Verse 35. 35 . Twenty and five thousand and a hundred The historian here gives the result of the battle, and then proceeds, in Judges 20:36-46 , to give more of the details. It appears that eighteen thousand fell in battle, ( Judges 20:44 ,) five thousand were gleaned along the highways, ( Judges 20:45 ,) and that two thousand more were killed as they fled to Gidom. This makes exactly twenty-five thousand; but no account is given in this latter part of the other one hundred. So also no account at all is given of the number of Benjamites who fell in the previous battles. According to Judges 20:47 only six hundred men of Benjamin escaped; but before the first battle they numbered twenty-six thousand seven hundred. Judges 20:15 . Consequently twenty-six thousand one hundred were killed and missing in the war. The historian records twenty-five thousand one hundred killed on this last day of battle; the other one thousand, not accounted for, probably fell in the battles of the previous days, for it is not supposable that the Benjamites killed twenty-two thousand on one day ( Judges 20:21 ) and eighteen thousand on another without any loss to themselves.
Respond
1. Where in our own communities do we risk excusing sin under the banner of tribal loyalty? 2. How might earlier, deeper seeking of the Lord have altered the course of these events? 3. What does the Lord’s patient humbling of Israel teach us about genuine repentance today?
Pray
Gracious and covenant-keeping God, we bow before the searching light of Thy word. Forgive the hardness of heart that allows iniquity to be sheltered among Thy people. Grant us the grace to seek Thee first, before strife or self-confidence leads us into needless sorrow. Humble every proud thought and teach us to weep with those who weep, yet never to defend what Thou hast condemned. Raise up in our day leaders after Thine own heart who will purge evil without partiality and restore the fallen with holy compassion. Through the merits of Christ our Lord, who bore our shame and purchased our peace, we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →