Eterniseed › Curriculum › Tobit
Tobit 5-6 — drawing on Aquinas (Summa I qq.50-64 + q.113 on the angels)
Opening
The fifth and sixth chapters of Tobit introduce one of the most theologically rich figures in the deuterocanonical literature: the angel Raphael, sent in the form of the Israelite Azarias to guide Tobiah on his journey to Media. Drawing on Aquinas's sustained treatment of the angelic substances in Summa Theologiae I qq.50-64 (the so-called Treatise on the Angels) and especially his treatment of angelic mission and guardianship in I qq.111-113, we may approach these chapters with the categorical precision that the scholastic doctor brings to the angelic order. Raphael's apparent humanity, his journey alongside Tobiah, his instruction in the use of the fish's organs, his deception about his identity, and his deeper purpose of healing both Tobit and Sarah — each of these has its place within the architecture Aquinas builds in his treatise. The Church receives the book of Tobit as among the most extensive Old Testament witnesses to the angelic ministry, and Aquinas's scholastic apparatus enables the contemporary reader to see in the narrative the working out of theological principles that the Christian tradition has held since the patristic age.
Read
Read Tobit chapters 5 and 6 with attention to Raphael's introduction and Tobiah's journey. In chapter five, mark Tobit's directive to find a trustworthy companion for the journey to Rages to retrieve the deposit with Gabael; Tobiah's discovery of a man standing nearby whom he does not recognize but who introduces himself as Azarias the son of the great Ananias of Tobit's own kindred; Tobit's questioning of Azarias and apparent satisfaction with his references; the contractual arrangement of the wage; the parting blessings of Tobit and Anna; and Anna's lament at the departure of her only son. In chapter six, attend to the journey to the Tigris where the great fish leaps at Tobiah's foot and the angel directs him to seize it, to gut it, and to preserve its heart, liver, and gall for medicinal use; the angel's instruction during the journey on the use of the fish's organs — the heart and liver for the casting out of demons by being burned as incense, the gall for the anointing of eyes afflicted with whiteness; the angel's revelation of the eligibility of Sarah of Ecbatana as Tobiah's bride according to the law of Moses; and Tobiah's fearful objection regarding the seven husbands the demon had killed.
Study
Aquinas's treatise on the angels in Summa I qq.50-64 articulates the metaphysics of angelic substance with the precision the scholastic method permits. In q.50 a.1 he holds that angels are immaterial substances — pure spirits possessing intellect and will but lacking bodies; each angel constitutes its own species (q.50 a.4) because the principle of individuation in material beings is the matter and angels lack matter. In q.51 a.1 he asks whether angels have bodies naturally united to them, and his response is negative: angels are pure spirits in their own substance. In q.51 a.2 he then asks the question directly relevant to Raphael's apparent humanity: whether angels assume bodies. His response is yes — angels do at times assume bodies, not as forms naturally united to their spiritual substance but as instruments through which they may interact with the material world for the purpose of fulfilling their mission. In q.51 a.3 he asks the more delicate question of whether the bodies angels assume perform vital operations such as eating: his response, drawing on Augustine and on the Tobit narrative itself, is that angels assuming bodies appear to perform such operations but do not perform them in the natural manner of human beings — the food they appear to consume is not actually digested but is consumed in another manner that Aquinas leaves somewhat opaque. The Catena Aurea on Luke 24:43 (the risen Christ eating fish before the apostles) preserves the Augustinian discussion that Aquinas uses, distinguishing between the resurrected body of Christ (which truly possesses the integrity of the resurrected flesh) and the assumed bodies of the angels (which merely appear to perform vital operations). Tobit's book itself is the principal Old Testament occasion of this question; Raphael in chapter twelve will explicitly state that he appeared to eat and drink but did not in fact consume the food, and Aquinas's scholastic synthesis incorporates this revelation. The mission of Raphael falls under the question Aquinas treats in I q.112 on the missions of the angels. He distinguishes between the angels who are sent (missi) and those who, possessing the higher orders of the celestial hierarchy, are not sent but contemplate the divine essence in continuous adoration. In I q.112 a.4 he asks which angels are sent on missions to humans, and his response draws on the patristic distinction between the higher orders (Seraphim, Cherubim, Thrones — who do not leave the immediate divine presence) and the lower orders (Powers, Virtues, Dominions, Principalities, Archangels, Angels — who are sent in particular missions to particular tasks). Raphael, identified in chapter twelve as one of the seven who stand before the throne of God, belongs to the order of Archangels in the tradition that follows pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite (whose hierarchical scheme Aquinas accepts in I q.108) — the order of Archangels being charged with the missions to particular communities or persons that require the special intervention of an angelic substance. The guardianship structure that Raphael's care of Tobiah exemplifies falls under Aquinas's treatment of guardian angels in I q.113. In q.113 a.1 he holds that every man has a guardian angel deputed to him for the care of his salvation. In q.113 a.4 he asks whether a man is committed to an angel's care from baptism or from birth, and his response, drawing on Saint Jerome's commentary on Matthew 18 and on the practice of the Church, is that the guardian angel is given at birth (Jerome had cited the Lord's word in Matthew 18:10 that "their angels in heaven continually behold the face of my Father" referring to the angels of little children, and Aquinas takes this to mean from birth rather than from baptism). Raphael's care of Tobiah and his eventual revelation that he has been the answer to Tobit's prayer and to Sarah's lament fall under the broader category of the providential ministry of the angelic substances that q.113 articulates. The medicinal use of the fish's organs is a particular detail that has occupied patristic and medieval commentators. Aquinas does not treat the specific question, but his general principle in I q.110 (on the action of angels upon the corporeal creation) provides the framework: angels can dispose material causes in ways that achieve effects through natural operations the substances themselves possess. The fish's heart and liver burnt as incense produce a smoke that drives away the demon, not by any magical power but by the disposition of natural medicinal substances under angelic direction — a principle that distinguishes the rite from magical incantation (which Aquinas condemns in II-II q.96) and aligns it with the broader category of providential disposition of created substances. The angel's revelation of Sarah's eligibility as Tobiah's bride falls under Aquinas's treatment of marriage in the Supplement qq.41-68; the eligibility per the Mosaic law of kindred-marriage outside the immediate household is the substrate of the principles q.54-55 develops on consanguinity.
Consider
Drawing on Aquinas's holding in I q.113 a.1 that every man has a guardian angel deputed to him for the care of his salvation, consider whether the structure of your own spiritual life acknowledges the angelic ministry that the Catholic tradition holds with such steadiness. The contemporary culture has tended to collapse the angelic into the sentimental (the cherubic figurine, the warm presence that comforts) or to dismiss it entirely. The scholastic articulation Aquinas provides resists both reductions: angels are pure spiritual substances possessing intellect and will and ordered to particular missions by the divine providence; the guardian angel is a real person assigned to your real soul for the real purpose of helping you toward beatitude. Have you cultivated even the simplest practice of acknowledging your guardian angel — the brief prayer at the day's beginning, the petition before journey or difficulty, the commemoration on the angel's feast day? Consider too the principle Aquinas articulates in I q.51 a.2 that angels assume bodies as instruments of their mission without being naturally united to those bodies. The discipline this principle imposes on Christian devotion is the discipline of receiving angelic ministry without making the angel into the object of religious worship that belongs to God alone. The Catholic tradition has been steady about this — the angels are venerated (dulia) but not worshiped (latria); the worship that belongs to God is not transferred to created spirits however exalted. Where in your devotional life have you allowed the boundary between veneration and worship to blur? Consider finally Raphael's deception of his identity. Aquinas treats angelic veracity in I q.62 a.5 (whether confirmed angels can deceive); his response is that the holy angels never lie in matters of doctrine but may use prudent concealment in the discharge of their mission, much as a physician may not disclose to a patient the full extent of his illness when premature disclosure would impede recovery. Raphael's pseudonym is the paradigmatic instance of this principle: he does not disclose his identity to Tobiah and Tobit because the disclosure would impede the very mission he is sent to accomplish; the truth is preserved (he is indeed of their kindred in the deeper sense of being a fellow servant of the same God) while the manner of its disclosure is reserved.
Respond
Renew this week the simple practice of acknowledging your guardian angel. Pray each morning the Angele Dei prayer (Angel of God, my guardian dear, to whom God's love commits me here, ever this day be at my side, to light and guard, to rule and guide. Amen.) and again before any journey or unfamiliar undertaking. The scholastic articulation of the angelic ministry that Aquinas provides in Summa I q.113 supports rather than complicates this devotion; intellectual clarity about the metaphysics of the angelic substance is the foundation of confident devotion to the real persons charged with the care of your salvation.
Pray
O God of infinite providence, who sent your archangel Raphael to accompany Tobiah and bring healing and safe return, send your holy angels to guard and guide us in every step of our pilgrimage. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the heavenly hosts, strengthen our faith in your unseen care and lead us at last to the joy of your presence. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →