Eterniseed › Curriculum › Apology of the Augsburg Confession
Apology — Of Confession and Satisfaction — Book of Concord
Opening
Today we turn to the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, specifically its article Of Confession and Satisfaction. This portion of the Lutheran Confessions defends the Gospel freedom Christ gives His Church while upholding the comfort of private absolution. It shows why the doctrine of repentance must rest on contrition and faith rather than on human requirements that burden consciences. The article matters because it keeps the forgiveness of sins anchored solely in Christ’s promise, guarding believers from the anxiety that comes when works are added to grace.
Read
Read the full article Of Confession and Satisfaction in the Apology. The text rests especially on passages such as Psalm 32, Psalm 51, Matthew 3:8, Romans 6:19, and Matthew 18:18, showing how Scripture supports the retention of absolution while rejecting any claim that enumeration of sins or canonical satisfactions are required by divine law.
Study
The Confession opens by
Good men can easily judge that it is of the greatest importance that the true doctrine concerning the above-mentioned parts, namely contrition and faith, be preserved. [For the great fraud of indulgences, etc., and the preposterous doctrines of the sophists have sufficiently taught us what great vexation and danger arise therefrom if a foul stroke is here made. How many a godly conscience under the Papacy sought with great labor the true way, and in the midst, of such darkness did not find it!] Therefore, we have always been occupied more with the elucidation of these topics, and have disputed nothing as yet concerning confession and satisfaction. For we also retain confession, especially on account of the absolution, as being the word of God which, by divine authority, the power of the keys pronounces upon individuals. Therefore it would be wicked to remove private absolution from the Church. Neither do they understand what the remission of sins or the power of the keys is, if there are any who despise private absolution.It continues by addressing
But in reference to the enumeration of offenses in confession, we have said above that we hold that it is not necessary by divine right. For the objection, made by some, that a judge ought to investigate a case before he pronounces upon it, pertains in no way to this subject; because the ministry of absolution is favor or grace, it is not a legal process, or law. [For God is the Judge, who has committed to the apostles, not the office of judges, but the administration of grace, namely, to acquit those who desire, etc.] Therefore ministers in the Church have the command to remit sin; they have not the command to investigate secret sins. And indeed, they absolve from those that we do not remember; for which reason absolution, which is the voice of the Gospel remitting sins and consoling consciences, does not require judicial examination.Turning then to satisfactions, the Confession states
For also the heathen had certain expiations for offenses through which they imagined to be reconciled to God. Now, however, although the custom has become obsolete, the name satisfaction still remains, and a trace of the custom also remains of prescribing in confession certain satisfactions, which they define as works that are not due. We call them canonical satisfactions. Of these we hold, just as of the enumeration, that canonical satisfactions [these public ceremonies] are not necessary by divine Law for the remission of sins; just as those ancient exhibitions of satisfactions in public repentance were not necessary by divine Law for the remission of sins. For the belief concerning faith must be retained, that by faith we obtain remission of sins for Christ’s sake, and not for the sake of our works that precede or follow [when we are converted or born anew in Christ].It further explains
Again, our adversaries will condemn many most generally received teachers if they will contend that in confession an enumeration of offenses is necessary according to divine Law. For although we approve of confession, and judge that some examination is of advantage, in order that men may be the better instructed [young and inexperienced persons be questioned], yet the matter must be so controlled that snares are not cast upon consciences, which never will be tranquil if they think that they cannot obtain the remission of sins, unless this precise enumeration be made. That which the adversaries have expressed in the Confutation is certainly most false, namely, that a full confession is necessary for salvation. For this is impossible. And what snares they here cast upon the conscience when they require a full confession! For when will conscience be sure that the confession is complete? In the Church-writers mention is made of confession, but they do not speak of this enumeration of secret offenses, but of the rite of public repentance.
Consider
In closing the argument the Confession affirms
15:9, that they are vain acts of worship, we can safely affirm that canonical satisfactions are not necessary by divine Law for the remission of guilt, or eternal punishment, or the punishment of purgatory.
Respond
How does the retention of private absolution strengthen your daily assurance of forgiveness? Where have you felt the burden of thinking your repentance must be complete before God can absolve you? What difference does it make to rest forgiveness on Christ’s satisfaction alone rather than on any works we might add?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank You for preserving in the Confessions the pure comfort of absolution spoken by Your command. Keep us from every teaching that would turn repentance into a work we must finish or a list we must complete. Let the voice of the Gospel daily assure us that sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake alone. Strengthen our faith to bring forth good fruits freely, without fear that they earn what grace already gives. Guard Your Church from the old error that adds human satisfactions to Your Son’s perfect redemption. In His name we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →