Eterniseed › Curriculum › Exodus
Exodus 21-22 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Welcome to today's six-beat lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary. In these chapters the inspired text sets forth the practical statutes that ordered Israel's common life, and Haydock gathers the Church's ancient interpreters to unfold their meaning. His notes reveal both the letter of the law and its deeper call to justice and mercy. As we move through the commentary we will see how these ancient ordinances still shape Christian conscience and point toward the perfect law of charity fulfilled in Christ.
Read
Take up the sacred text and read Exodus chapters 21 and 22 slowly and prayerfully. Listen for the voice of the Lord who gives order to human society and protects the vulnerable. Notice the careful distinctions between accidental harm and willful wrongdoing, between property and person. Let the measured cadences of the law prepare your heart for the commentary that follows.
Study
Haydock opens the commentary on Exodus 21 by addressing the status of servants.
Servant, or slave. A man might sell himself and his children. But if they were females, under age, God prescribes how they are to be treated, ver. 7. --- Six years: in case he were brought immediately after the expiration of the Sabbatic law: none could be detained for a longer period. If a person lost his liberty in the fourth year after the general release, he would recover it in the space of two or three years at latest. (Haydock) (Bonfrere)The commentary then examines the penalties for striking another with intent.
With a will. The Hebrew and Septuagint do not express this, but the context shews it to be necessary. --- Death, by the sword, as people soliciting idolatry to others were also. Eighteen crimes were punished with lapidation, ten with fire, or melting lead poured down their throats, and six with strangling. The royal tribunals always commanded the criminal's head to be struck off. (Calmet) --- When the punishment is not defined, stoning must be understood; (Rabbins and Selden, Syned ii. 13.) at least when it is said, his blood be upon him. But when it is only determined that he shall die, Grotius understands he must be strangled, with towels put round the malefactor's neck, while he stands up to the knees in a dunghill; (Drusius) as he does also when he is to be killed with melted lead. Murder was punished by the ancient Greeks with exile. (Plato, &c.) "At that time it was deemed unlawful to inflict a capital punishment upon any, who, however criminal, were still men." (Lartant 2.) But as these crimes became more frequent, God enacts this law of retaliation, blood for blood, Genesis ix. 6. Ten paces from the place of execution, the criminal Hebrew had to confess his sin. (Maimonides) (Calmet)Haydock next discusses the principle of retaliation in cases of injury.
Eye. "This law tended to restrain, not to encourage, fury and revenge." (St. Augustine, contra Faust. xix. 25.) Some explain it, as if a sum of money could only be required, equivalent to the ransom of an eye, in case a person should be under a necessity of losing or of redeeming it. (Muis; Jonathan) --- Retaliation was not left to the injured party's discretion. The judge was to decide. Christ enjoins what is more perfect, ordering us to turn the left cheek, when we have received a blow on the right. The canon law inflicts the punishment of retaliation upon the calumniator. (Calmet)
Consider
Haydock connects these statutes to the prohibition of usury later in the same chapter.
Poor. Such are often most in want. Usury is not lawful, even with respect to the rich. The Hebrew terms it a bite. (Menochius) --- "What is usury, said Cato, but to kill a man." The Romans required thieves to restore double, but usurers were to render four times as much as they had taken. (Varro Rustic. i.) --- Restitution is prescribed, 2 Esdras v. 11. Some Calvinists have stood up in its defence, in opposition to the Scriptures, fathers, and Councils of the Catholic Church. Lend, hoping to gain nothing by it, Luke vi. 35. "Let him who loves money,.…lend (in the persons of the poor) to Him who says, Give, and it shall be given to you." (St. Leo, ser.) The Jews themselves have reprobated usury in any use. (Calmet)
Respond
How does the commentary's treatment of servants invite me to examine my own attitudes toward those who serve me? In what ways does the law of measured retaliation challenge my instinctive desire for revenge? Where might the warning against usury call me to greater generosity with the goods God has entrusted to me?
Pray
O God of justice and compassion, who delivered to Israel statutes that guarded the weak and upheld the dignity of every person, pour forth your grace that we may fulfill your law in the freedom of the Gospel. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, form our hearts to repay evil with good and to lend without hope of return, that the order you established of old may lead us into the perfect liberty of your kingdom. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →