Eterniseed › Curriculum › James
James 2 — with Barnes
Opening
In the clear exegetical spirit of nineteenth-century Presbyterian scholarship, we turn today to Albert Barnes's Notes on the Bible for an attentive walk through James chapter 2. Barnes guides readers verse by verse with careful attention to the apostle's logic, historical setting, and practical demands. His treatment highlights the unity of Christian faith and conduct, showing how genuine religion refuses partiality and insists on wholehearted obedience. As we listen, we seek the same reverence for Scripture that shaped Barnes's work and the same desire to let the text form holy living.
Read
With open Bibles we now read James chapter 2 in full. Let the words of the inspired apostle settle in the heart before we examine Barnes's exposition. Read slowly, noting the repeated calls to impartial love and consistent obedience. Ask the Spirit to prepare the mind for the careful observations that follow.
Study
Barnes opens by dividing the chapter into its three principal discussions.
Introduction. This chapter is evidently made up of three parts, or three subjects are discussed: I. The duty of impartiality in the treatment of others, James 2:1-9 . There was to be no favoritism on account of rank, birth, wealth, or apparel. The case to which the apostle refers for an illustration of this, is that where two persons should come into an assembly of Christian worshippers, one elegantly dressed, and the other meanly clad, and they should show special favor to the former, and should assign to the latter a more humble place.He then expounds the opening verse on showing no partiality in faith.
Verse 1. My brethren - Perhaps meaning brethren in two respects - as Jews, and as Christians. In both respects the form of address would be proper. Have not the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ - Faith is the distinguishing thing in the Christian religion, for it is this by which man is justified, and hence, it comes to be put for religion itself. Notes, 1 Timothy 3:9 . The meaning here is, “do not hold such views of the religion of Christ, as to lead you to manifest partiality to others on account of their difference of rank or outward circumstances.” The Lord of glory - The glorious Lord; he who is glorious himself, and who is encompassed with glory. See the notes at 1 Corinthians 2:8 . The design here seems to be to show that the religion of such a Lord should be in no way dishonored. With respect of persons - That is, you are not to show respect of persons, or to evince partiality to others on account of their rank, wealth, apparel, etc. Compare Proverbs 24:23 ; Proverbs 28:21 ; Leviticus 19:15 ; Deuteronomy 1:17 ; Deu 10:17 ; 2 Chronicles 19:7 ; Psalms 40:4 . See the subject explained in the Acts 10:34 note; Romans 2:11 note.Next he addresses the necessity of obeying the entire law without exception.
Verse 10. For whosoever shall keep the whole law - All except the single point referred to. The apostle does not say that this in fact ever did occur, but he says that if it should, and yet a man should have failed in only one particular, he must be judged to be guilty. The case supposed seems to be that of one who claimed that he had kept the whole law. The apostle says that even if this should be admitted for the time to be true in all other respects, yet, if he had failed in any one particular - in showing respect to persons, or in anything else - he could not but be held to be a transgressor, The design of this is to show the importance of yielding universal obedience, and to impress upon the mind a sense of the enormity of sin from the fact that the violation of any one precept is in fact an offence against the whole law of God.
Consider
Barnes presses the key distinction regarding the place of works after justification.
If it is not shown by works corresponding to its nature, it will be certain that there is no true religion, or that his professed faith is worth nothing. The “stand-point” from which James views the subject, is not that faith is unnecessary or worthless, or that a man is not justified by faith rather than by his own works, in the sense of its being the ground of acceptance with God; or, in other words, the place where the apostle takes his position, and which is the point from which he views the subject, is not before a man is justified, to inquire in what way he may be accepted of God, but it is after the act of justification by faith, to show that if faith does not lead to good works it is “dead,” or is of no value; and that in fact, therefore, the evidence of justification is to be found in good living, and that when this is not manifest, all a man’s professed religion is worth nothing.He concludes by underscoring that any single violation renders one guilty before the whole law.
This does not affirm that he is as guilty as if he had violated every law of God; or that all sinners are of equal grade because all have violated some one or more of the laws of God; but the meaning is, that he is guilty of violating the law of God as such; he shows that be has not the true spirit of obedience; he has exposed himself to the penalty of the law, and made it impossible now to be saved by it. His acts of obedience in other respects, no matter how many, will not screen him from the charge of being a violator of the law, or from its penalty. He must be held and treated as a transgressor for that offence, however upright he may be in other respects, and must meet the penalty of the law as certainly as though he had violated every commandment. One portion of the law is as much binding as another, and if a man violates any one plain commandment, he sets at nought the authority of God.
Respond
How does the call to impartiality confront favoritism still present in our congregations? In what ways does the demand for wholehearted obedience expose areas where we excuse partial compliance? Where do we see evidence that genuine faith is producing the works James requires?
Pray
Gracious God, grant us grace to receive the word of James without partiality and to walk in the obedience that flows from living faith. By your Spirit keep us from every form of favoritism that dishonors the Lord of glory, and strengthen us to fulfill your whole law in the liberty of the gospel. May our works confirm the reality of our faith and bring all honor to Christ alone. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →