Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges
Judges 11-12 — with Whedon
Opening
Beloved, we open our hearts today to the steadfast witness of Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. In these pages the Spirit still speaks through careful exposition of Holy Scripture, guiding Wesleyan pilgrims in the way of faith and obedience. As we turn to Judges chapters eleven and twelve, may the Lord grant us grace to receive the word with meekness, that our lives might be ordered according to his righteous will.
Read
With reverence let us now read aloud the appointed chapters. Hear the account of Jephthah's rise, his solemn negotiations, his costly vow, and the victory granted by the Lord. Read slowly, pausing after each paragraph, that the Spirit may apply the word to conscience and heart.
Study
Whedon opens by setting forth the circumstances of Jephthah's election.
Verse 1. ELECTION OF JEPHTHAH, Judges 11:1-11 . This chapter should have begun with Judges 11:17 of the preceding chapter, where the history of Jephthah properly begins. 1 . Gileadite Like Jair, Jephthah was a native of the land of Gilead, and, what is noticeable also, his father’s name was Gilead. He was probably a descendant of Gilead, the grandson of Manasseh. Numbers 26:29 . We see no sufficient reason to take Gilead here as the name of the country, or a tribal name used in place of an unknown personal name. A mighty man of valour Distinguished for great physical strength, skill in the use of arms, and boldness of character.He next unfolds the measured diplomacy of Jephthah's message to Ammon.
Verse 12. JEPHTHAH’S MESSAGE TO AMMON, Judges 11:12-28 . 12 . Sent messengers He would know the ground and reasons on which the Ammonites pretended to wage war with Israel. “This is highly interesting, because it shows that even in that age a cause for war was judged necessary no one being supposed to war without provocation.” Kitto. Me… my land The messengers speak in the name of the nation, as represented by the chosen leader.Whedon then traces the coming of the Spirit and the utterance of the vow.
Verse 29. JEPTHTHAH’S VICTORY AND VOW, Judges 11:29-40 . 29 . Then the Spirit of the Lord came upon Jephthah He was roused and fired for his warlike work by an extraordinary supernatural influence from on high. But this must not be imagined identical with the New Testament gift of the Holy Ghost, and thence twisted to show that Jephthah’s rash vow was uttered under divine inspiration, and therefore pleasing in the sight of God. Note, Judges 3:10 . Passed over Gilead and Manasseh for the purpose of collecting troops and necessaries for the war. Gilead and Manasseh are here to be taken as a name for the territory of the trans-Jordanic tribes. Mizpeh of Gilead See note on Judges 10:17 . Having collected his warriors, Jephthah passed over the lofty eminence on which Mizpeh was situated, and soon came to the border of the children of Ammon , between whom and himself the Lord was to decide that day. Judges 11:27 . From the heights of Mizpeh the whole camp of the enemy was visible, spread over the beautiful knolls of the undulating plateau towards Rabbah. The sight fired the soul of Jephthah, and led him to utter his rash vow.He presses the precise terms of that vow with searching care.
Verse 30. 30 . Vowed a vow unto the Lord Bound himself by a strong oath and solemn appeal to Jehovah. So Jacob did at Bethel, ( Genesis 28:20 ,) and Hannah at the tabernacle. 1 Samuel 1:11 . Although vows were not commanded in the Old Testament, they were often taken, and the law made provision for different kinds of vows. They might be pleasing or displeasing to God, according to their real character. A rash vow could never be pleasing to God, though it might be excusable from the ignorance of him that vowed. It is not to be assumed that Jephthah uttered this vow under divine inspiration. The Spirit of the Lord came upon him, and quickened him with energy and heroism to go and conquer Ammon, but not to make this vow. It is to be noted that no sacred writer commends Jephthah’s vow.
Consider
On the vow's fulfillment Whedon renders his weightiest conclusion.
Take, for instance, the passage oftenest quoted, Psalms 51:16-17 , where the spiritual idea of sacrifices in general is expressed, and the sacrifice of a broken and contrite heart, so far from being identified with burnt offering, is put in direct opposition to it. The whole attempt to put a figurative or spiritual sense upon the word עולה , especially in our text, is a manifest striving after something which the Scriptures nowhere offer, and a prodigious effort to get rid of the common meaning of an oft-recurring word. It follows, then, that the only translation of this verse that will bear the test of criticism is substantially the following: “Whosoever comes forth from the doors of my house to meet me, when I return in peace from the sons of Ammon, shall be for Jehovah, and I will offer him for a burnt offering.”He closes the matter by recording the deed done according to the vow.
Verse 39. 39 . Did with her according to his vow Literally, Did to her his vow which he had vowed. This plain and positive statement throws us back for the meaning of Jephthah’s act to Judges 11:31 , where the language of his vow is carefully recorded. Whatever act his vow contemplated, that certainly he did. Nothing more, nothing less. He devoutly kept his word. He had opened his mouth unto the Lord, and, notwithstanding all his anguish, he went not back from his solemn oath. So, according to the previous exposition of his language, we can understand nothing else than that he offered her for a burnt offering unto the Lord. And she knew no man This fact the sacred writer adds as that alone which, in the estimation of that age, was the sting of death to the heroic maiden.
Respond
How does Jephthah's election challenge our notions of fitness for leadership? In what ways does the vow expose the peril of hasty speech before God? Where do we see the mercy of the Lord still at work amid human rashness?
Pray
O Lord of hosts, who didst raise up Jephthah in the day of Israel's distress, grant us wisdom to speak and vow with holy fear. Keep us from rash promises and from every compromise with the spirit of the age. May the same Spirit that came upon thy servant rest upon thy church, that we may contend earnestly for the faith once delivered to the saints. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →