← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Job

Job 15-16 — with Barnes

Job 15-16Albert Barnes' Notes on the Bible20 min
Opening
In the clear exegetical tradition of American Presbyterian scholarship, we turn today to Albert Barnes's Notes on the Bible for a careful reading of Job chapters 15 and 16. Barnes guides us through Eliphaz's second discourse with measured attention to the ancient text, its arguments, and their enduring implications for the life of faith. His commentary helps the church hear both the weight of the friends' charges and the deeper questions they raise about suffering, wisdom, and the fear of the Lord.
Read
With reverence for the word, let us now read Job chapters 15 and 16. Listen prayerfully to Eliphaz's renewed address and to Job's anguished reply. Ask the Spirit to open the text so that its ancient dialogue may instruct the heart and deepen our trust in the righteous Judge of all the earth.
Study
Barnes opens by examining Eliphaz's opening charge against Job. Verse 4. Yea, thou castest off fear - Margin, Makest void. Fear here means the fear or reverence of God; and the idea is, that Job had not maintained a proper veneration or respect for his Maker in his argument. He had defended principles and made assertions which implied great disrespect for the Deity. If those doctrines were true; if he was right in his views about God, then he was not a being who could be reverenced. No confidence could be placed in his government; no worship of such a being could be maintained. Eliphaz does not refer here so much to what was personal with Job, as to his principles. He does not mean so much to affirm that he himself had lost all reverence for God, as that his arguments led to that. Job had maintained that God did not in this life reward and punish people strictly according to their deserts. He then traces Eliphaz's further accusation concerning the mouth and its speech. Verse 5. For thy mouth uttereth thine iniquity - Margin, “teacheth.” That is, “your whole argument shows that you are a guilty man. A man who can defend such positions about God cannot be a pious man, or have any proper veneration for the Most High.” A man may pursue an argument, and defend positions, that shall as certainly show that he is destitute of religion as though he lived an abandoned life; and he who holds opinions that are dishonorable to God, can no more be a pious man than if he dishonored God by violating his law. Thou choosest the tongue of the crafty - Instead of pursuing an argument with candor and sincerity, you have resorted to miserable sophisms, such as running disputants use. You have not showed a disposition to ascertain and defend the truth, but have relied on the arts and evasions of the subtle disputant and the rhetorician. His whole discourse, according to Eliphaz, was a work of mere art, designed to blind his hearers; to deceive them with a favorable opinion of his piety; and to give some plausible, but delusive view of the government of God. Barnes next sets forth Eliphaz's appeal to the oracle concerning human purity. Verse 14. What is man that he should be clean? - The object of Eliphaz in this is to overturn the positions of Job that he was righteous, and had been punished beyond his deserts. He had before maintained Job 4:7 , that no one ever perished being innocent, and that the righteous were not cut off. This was with him a favorite position; and indeed the whole drift of the argument maintained by him and his friends was, to prove that uncommon calamities were proof of uncommon guilt. Job had insisted on it that he was a righteous man, and had not deserved the calamities which had come upon him - a position which Eliphaz seems to have regarded as an assertion of innocence. To meet this he now maintains that no one is righteous; that all that are born of women are guilty; and in proof of this he goes back to the oracle which had made so deep an impression on his mind, and to the declaration then made to him that no one was pure before God; Job 4:0 : He does not repeat it exactly as the oracle was then delivered to him, but adverts to the substance of it, and regards it as final and indisputable. The meaning is, “What are all the pretensions of man to purity, when even the angels are regarded as impure and the heavens unclean?” He which is born of a woman - Another mode of denoting man. No particular argument to maintain the doctrine of man’s depravity is couched in the fact that he is born of a woman. The sense is, simply, how can anyone of the human family be pure?
Consider
Barnes presses the doctrinal consequences that follow from the position under review. But I see not how the considerations here urged by this ancient sage of the tendency of Job’s doctrine can be avoided, if it be applied to the views of those who hold that all people will be saved at death. If that be the truth, then who can fail to see that the tendency must be to make people cast off the fear of God and to undermine all devotion and prayer? Why should people pray, if all are to be treated alike at death? How can people worship and honor a Being who will treat the good and the bad alike? How can we have confidence in a being who makes no distinction in regard to character? And what inducement can there be to be pious, when all people shall be made as happy as they can be forever whether they are pious or not? He concludes by underscoring the practical outcome for piety and prayer. We are not to wonder, therefore, that the system tends every where to sap the foundations of virtue and religion; that it makes no man better; and that where it prevails, it banishes religion and prayer from the world.
Respond
How does the fear of the Lord guard our speech when we speak of God's ways? In what ways might we be tempted to press another's words beyond their intended meaning? Where do we find our deepest confidence that God distinguishes between the righteous and the wicked?
Pray
O Lord most holy, we thank thee for the light of thy word and for faithful expositors who have gone before us. Grant us the reverence that Eliphaz rightly prized, lest our thoughts of thee become small or our prayers grow cold. Keep us from every doctrine that would blur the difference between the righteous and the wicked, and teach us to rest in the finished work of Christ, in whom mercy and truth have met together. Preserve in thy church a spirit of humble prayer and holy fear, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Albert Barnes' Notes on the Bible · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →