← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel

1 Samuel 17-18 — with Whedon

1 Samuel 17-18Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry we open today’s lesson with Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s careful exposition of First Samuel chapters seventeen and eighteen invites us to trace the rise of David, the steadfast love of Jonathan, and the darkening jealousy of Saul. His Arminian-Wesleyan lens highlights both divine providence and human responsibility, urging readers to see how grace meets courage amid conflict. As we listen, may the same Spirit that anointed David stir holy affections within us.
Read
With hearts prepared by prayer, let us read aloud First Samuel chapters seventeen and eighteen. Attend to the valley of Elah, the sling that felled a giant, the covenant of souls between David and Jonathan, and the first shadows of royal envy. Read slowly, allowing each scene to awaken both wonder and self-examination before the living God.
Study
Whedon opens by establishing the broader setting of the Philistine conflict. Introduction. DAVID’S VICTORY OVER GOLIATH, 1 Samuel 17:1-58 . Of this Philistine war, in which Goliath was slain, the time and causes are unknown; but as there was bitter war against the Philistines all the days of Saul, ( 1 Samuel 14:52 ,) we need not suppose that there was any special provocation on the part of the Israelites. Those obstinate enemies on the seacoast, who had held Israel in subjection forty years, ( Judges 13:1 ,) were loath to lose them from among their tributaries; and their sufferings from the ark, (chap. 5,) and by the hand of Samuel, ( 1 Samuel 7:10 ,) and still more recently by the heroism of Jonathan, (chap. 14,) were sufficient provocation for them to attempt war at any time. Possibly, also, they had heard of the madness of Saul, and therefore deemed the present a favourable opportunity to wreak their fill of vengeance. As to the time of this war, Josephus tells us that it was shortly after the events narrated in the last chapter. But as we learn from 1 Samuel 17:15 that David had returned from Saul to his father, and from 1 Samuel 17:55 that Saul had forgotten Jesse, we incline to the belief that this war occurred some years after David’s introduction to Saul’s court. He then unfolds the covenant of souls between David and Jonathan. Verse 1. FRIENDSHIP OF DAVID AND JONATHAN, 1 Samuel 18:1-4 . 1 . When he had made an end of speaking unto Saul That is, after the interview mentioned in the last verse of the preceding chapter, in which David informed Saul of his father. All their conversation on that occasion is not recorded, for it is manifest that that verse contains but a very small part of it. Enough is given, however, to acquaint us with the main subject of their conversation. The soul of Jonathan was knit with the soul of David An instance of more touching and tender friendship is not recorded on the page of history, nor even in works of fiction. Here was a fellowship of souls. On the part of Jonathan it was the more remarkable, inasmuch as David became his rival for the throne. Next he records the swift honours granted David and the first stirrings of royal suspicion. Verse 5. DAVID’S HONOURS AND SAUL’S JEALOUSY, 1 Samuel 18:5-9 . After the battle, and after the covenant between Jonathan and David, the latter was advanced to great honour in the kingdom. The heart of the king, as well as that of the army, turned towards the heroic youth with one common feeling of gratitude and love. But the glories of this youthful warrior are soon to be clouded. 5 . Saul set him over the men of war We have no data to determine the exact chronology of the events recorded in this verse. But his appointment over the men of war, and his going out in obedience to Saul’s orders, are probably identical with what is related in 1 Samuel 18:13-14 . The writer seems to have inserted them here to show the immediate results of David’s victory and Jonathan’s friendship.
Consider
Whedon extols the friendship that stands as an eternal type for every age. But even after this became well known Jonathan’s love never cooled, but rather warmed with intenser devotion to his friend, and he often gave aid and comfort to the son of Jesse in the time of his persecution. 1 Samuel 23:17 . Well might the psalmist king say, in his requiem over the fallen hero, ( 2 Samuel 1:26 ,) “Thy love to me was wonderful, passing the love of women.” On this subject Ewald’s note is fine. “Nothing can establish a true bond between two friends and produce pure friendship except a loftier necessity which stands above them both, and which both alike burn to satisfy with ever-increasing fulness the necessity. namely, of finding and loving in others, if possible in a yet higher degree, the purely divine power already felt within, and thus mutually living under its influence. He presses the moment when suspicion first pierces the king’s heart. Verse 8. 8 . Saul was very wroth His passionate nature could not brook such insinuations without yielding to foul thoughts and deepest envy, What can he have more but the kingdom Immediately there flashes upon him the suspicion that this son of Jesse is that neighbour of whom Samuel had spoken, ( 1 Samuel 15:28 ,) who was destined to supersede him on the throne.
Respond
1. Where do I see God’s providence quietly ordering events that appear merely human? 2. How does the covenant love of Jonathan challenge my own commitments to friends and rivals? 3. In what hidden places might envy still whisper against the successes God grants others?
Pray
Gracious Lord of hosts, who chose the shepherd boy and strengthened his arm, grant us courage like David’s and loyalty like Jonathan’s. Deliver us from every root of envy that troubled Saul, and knit our souls to those whom Thou hast anointed. May the same Spirit that left the rejected king abide in us, producing holy boldness, humble service, and steadfast love. Through Christ our Captain we pray. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →