Eterniseed › Curriculum › Romans
Romans 9 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal witness we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s forthright Arminian reading of Romans 9 restores the apostle’s argument to its original current of free-agency and faith. His exposition confronts later distortions while recovering the ancient Christian conviction that God’s electing purpose honors the responsible choices of those whom grace enables to believe. We listen with gratitude for this clear and conclusive defense of scriptural truth.
Read
Let us now hear the sacred text itself. With open hearts we receive the word that Paul delivered to the Roman believers, trusting the Spirit to quicken our understanding as we prepare to study Whedon’s faithful exposition of the chapter.
Study
Whedon opens by framing the apostle’s argument within the larger defense of impartial free-agency.
Introduction. III. THE DEFENCE OF GOD IN ESTABLISHING A SYSTEM OF IMPARTIAL FREE-AGENCY BASED ON FAITH EVEN THOUGH RESULTING IN UNBELIEVING ISRAEL’S DOWNFALL, Romans 9:1 to Romans 11:36 . Our “Plan of the Epistle,” given at page 290, gives what our Commentary on these chapters will, we trust, show to be the true current of the apostle’s argument and thought. But it is well known that since the time of Augustine, in the fourth century, and later, of John Calvin, this chapter has been wrenched from the train of the apostle’s argument and made the basis of what is called the Doctrine of “Divine Sovereignty,” “Predestination,” and “Unconditional Election and Reprobation.” These dogmas were unknown or rejected by the Church of the first three centuries, and by the great majority of Christendom in all ages.He then unfolds the ancient Christian view of divine foreknowledge and the best possible plan for free agents.
The omniscient God, foreknowing from all eternity all things possible, did in view of such foresight, originally select the plan of his own conduct, preferring of all possible actions or plans of action that which is best. Adopting for the highest reason a system of free-agents, he does, in view of what he knows that in every possible case any free-agent will do, so plan his own conduct as, without violating the freedom of the agent, to prevent evil in the greatest attainable degree, and to secure the highest amount of good. He, therefore, endures sin, but neither approves, foreordains, necessitates, decrees, or permits it; and the sinner is punished not for God’s decree, but for his own avoidable sin.Next Whedon articulates the true doctrine of election according to foreseen faith.
God’s comprehensive plan is thus so far contingent as that it recognises the free acts which the free agent is able to withhold; yet, inasmuch as, whichever way the agent will do, His foreknowledge of all is perfectly accurate, so the Divine Mind can neither be deceived in its expectations or frustrated in its purposes. As to election, the true doctrine of the Church is that God, being eternally holy, does prefer and elect to himself all beings who are holy, or who do freely by his grace accept and consent, in faith, to become holy, with him; and so every human free-agent accepting God’s terms is in time elected, according to an eternal purpose of election. On the other hand, all in opposition to God’s holiness, freely preferring and persisting in sin, become reprobated, with an eternal reprobation, to everlasting death. Mr.
Consider
Whedon concludes by enumerating the decisive objections to unconditional predestination.
For without reprobation election itself cannot stand; whom God passes by, those he reprobates.” B. III, chap. 23, sec. 1. “All men are not created for the same end, but some are foreordained to eternal life, others to eternal damnation. So, according as every man was created for the one end or the other, we say he was elected or predestinated to destruction.” Chap. 21, sec. 1. To these views we object: 1. They make God the responsible author of sin. 2 . They destroy the free-agency of Man 1:3 . They render all penalty for sin unjust. 4. They destroy all divine government by transforming it into a mere machinery. 5. They degrade God and destroy the divine sovereignty by sinking the sovereign into a mere machinist. 6. They impute infinite cruelty to God by making him decree the sin and damn the sinner.
Respond
How does the priority of faith over birth or merit reshape our assurance of God’s electing love? In what ways might we guard against any teaching that makes God the author of sin? Where do we see the Spirit inviting us to embrace both divine sovereignty and human responsibility today?
Pray
Gracious and holy God, we thank thee for the clear witness of thy servant Daniel D. Whedon. Grant us hearts to receive the ancient truth that thy electing purpose rests upon faith freely given through grace. Deliver us from every doctrine that would charge thee with the authorship of sin or destroy the liberty of thy creatures. May we walk as children of the promise, chosen in Christ according to thy foreknowledge, and may our lives display the holiness that flows from justifying faith. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →