Eterniseed › Curriculum › Matthew
Matthew 17 — with Simeon
Opening
In the spirit of the via media, we turn today to Charles Simeon’s Horae Homileticae, that treasury of expository warmth fashioned for the Church of England. Across two discourses on Matthew 17, Simeon traces the harmony of prophecy and miracle, showing how every word of Scripture finds its appointed fulfilment in Christ. His method invites us to examine the evidences of the faith with candour, to receive the Lord’s own solution to apparent difficulties, and to rest in the assurance that nothing spoken by God can fail. As we listen, may the same Spirit who inspired the text open our hearts to receive the Saviour whom Elijah’s representative heralded and whom the tribute money itself confessed.
Read
Let us now hear the seventeenth chapter of Matthew, attending especially to the question of the disciples concerning Elijah and to the miracle by which our Lord supplied the temple tax. Read slowly, allowing the narrative to place you among the three disciples on the mount and beside Peter at the lakeside. Note each prophecy cited and each act of sovereign power displayed, that the word may prepare the heart for the exposition that follows.
Study
Simeon opens by presenting the disciples’ question after the transfiguration.
Verses 10-13. DISCOURSE: 1378 ELIJAH’S ADVENT IN JOHN BAPTIST Matthew 17:10-13 . And his Disciples asked him. saying. Why then say the Scribes that Elias must first come? And Jesus answered and said unto them, Elias truly shall first come, and restore all things. But I say unto you, That Elias is come already, and they knew him not, but have done unto him Whatsoever they listed. Likewise shall also the Son of man suffer of them. Then the Disciples understood that he spake unto them of John the Baptist . IT is desirable that the evidences of our holy religion should be candidly examined, and clearly understood. The three favoured Disciples, Peter, James, and John, had just been admitted to behold a most extraordinary vision of their Lord in a state of transcendent glory, and had received from heaven this direct and audible testimony to his Messiahship, “This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased: hear ye him.”He then unfolds the difficulty proposed by the scribes’ expectation.
Hence they asked of their Lord an explanation of this matter: “Why, then, say the Scribes that Elias must first come,” when we are not at liberty to attest his advent? Here was a real difficulty; and it is felt no less by the Jews at this day than it was at that time; it being with them a very principal objection against the Messiahship of Jesus, that Elias, who was foretold as his harbinger, has never yet arrived. Let us then consider, I. The difficulty proposed— Nothing can be more clear than that, if Christ be the Messiah, every prophecy concerning him must be fulfilled— [St. Peter, affirming that “he and his fellow-Apostles had not followed cunningly-devised fables,” appeals to this very evidence which he and they had been favoured with, when, on Mount Tabor, they were made “eye-witnesses of Christ’s Majesty, and heard from the excellent glory the voice which bare witness to him.”Simeon proceeds to the solution given concerning John the Baptist.
] But let us, for the removing of this difficulty, attend to, The solution given of it— Our Lord, in reply to his Disciples, acknowledged that Elias was certainly foretold as his harbinger, but affirmed that “he was already come,” in the person of John the Baptist— [John was born in a preternatural way, of parents who were at an advanced period of life. And the Angel who announced his formation in the womb declared, that “he should turn many of the children of Israel to the Lord their God; and should go before him in the spirit and power of Elias , to turn the hearts of the fathers to (with) the children, and the disobedient to the wisdom of the just; to make ready a people prepared for the Lord [Note: Luke 1:13-17 .].” Now this distinctly applied to John the very prophecy on which the Jews founded their expectation of Elias , [Note: Malachi 4:5-6 .] and which our blessed Lord declares in my text to have been fulfilled in him.He next draws the inference that Jesus is indeed the Christ.
Let this be conceded, as it must of necessity be; and the whole difficulty is solved at once: and we are prepared for that which we are next to contemplate,] III. The inference to be deduced from it— We say, then, without fear, that Jesus is the Christ, the Saviour of the world— [To the testimony of John our Lord himself appealed [Note: Matthew 21:25-26 .]: but “he had greater witness than that of John, even the works which he wrought [Note: John 5:33 ; John 5:36 .];” and to these he appealed, for the satisfaction of the messengers whom John sent to him, to inquire whether he were the Christ [Note: Matthew 11:2-6 .]. He acknowledged indeed, that, under existing circumstances, there was some difficulty in receiving John the Baptist as the representative of Elijah: “If ye will receive it, this is Elias which was for to come [Note: Matthew 11:14 .].”
Consider
Simeon presses the final testimony that Jesus is the Son of the living God.
But that difficulty being removed, I will bear the same testimony to Christ as this Elias did: “He is the Son of the Living God,” even “Emmanuel, God with us [Note: Matthew 1:21-23 .].” “He is that Lamb of God that taketh away the sin of the world:” nor is there a person in the world whose iniquities, though red like crimson, shall not, when washed in his blood, become white as snow [Note: Isaiah 1:18 . Zec 13:1 . 1 John 1:7 .]” — — — Moreover, if only we believe in him, “he will baptize us with the Holy Ghost and with fire,” even as he did the three thousand on the day of Pentecost. Beloved brethren, think of all that ye can need, for body or for soul, for time or for eternity; and assure yourselves that ye shall find it all in him: for there is “a fulness of it all treasured up in him;” and “out of that fulness shall ye all receive,” according to the utmost extent of your necessities or desires.He concludes by urging candid examination of the evidences of the faith.
And so far are we from wishing any one to receive it without inquiry, that we challenge inquiry from every living man; and pledge ourselves, that the more the evidences of this blessed truth are examined, the more satisfactory will they be found; and that the more cordially the truth itself is embraced, the more influential will it become, for the comforting and sanctifying and saving of every believing soul.
Respond
Where in your own reading of Scripture have you encountered an apparent difficulty that later proved to be a doorway into deeper assurance? How does the Lord’s willingness to waive his rightful exemption from the temple tax speak to the way you meet lawful demands placed upon you? In what measure does the promise that all needful things shall be added to those who seek first the kingdom shape your daily trust?
Pray
O God, who upon the holy mount didst reveal the glory of thy Son and by thy voice from the cloud didst declare him to be the Beloved in whom thou art well pleased, and who by his word didst bring forth tribute from the depths of the sea: Grant us so to receive every promise of thy word as already fulfilled in him, that we may walk humbly in charity, content with the portion thou appointest, and patient until the day when all things shall be accomplished in thy kingdom; through the same Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →