← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Hosea

Hosea 1-2 — with Whedon

Hosea 1-2Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Wesleyan inquiry and Arminian hope, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for its measured exposition of Hosea chapters 1-2. Whedon’s careful attention to the prophetic word invites us to trace both the severity of divine judgment and the persistent mercy that refuses to abandon the covenant people. His work models the patient study by which the church has long sought to hear Scripture afresh. As we open these chapters, we ask the Spirit to grant us the same clarity and reverence that marked the Methodist expositors of an earlier generation.
Read
Let us now give reverent attention to the opening oracles of Hosea. Read chapters 1 and 2 slowly, allowing the symbolic names and the tender yet stern address of the Lord to Israel to settle in the heart. Note the movement from judgment to promised restoration, and listen for the voice that both disciplines and woos the wayward beloved.
Study
Whedon opens by setting forth the divine summons that shapes the prophet’s domestic life. Verses 2-5. 2b-5. The marriage of Hosea and the birth of the first child. 2. Take… a wife Common expression for marry. A wife of whoredoms Not harlot, that is, a woman already a sinner, whether in a literal or a spiritual sense ( Hosea 2:5 ), but a woman with deeply rooted tendencies toward unchastity (Introduction, pp. 12ff.). Children of whoredoms Either children inheriting the mother’s evil tendencies, or children born of a woman with such tendencies, or both ( Hosea 2:4 ). The land hath committed [“doth commit”] great whoredom The reason for leading the prophet into this peculiar experience. By his own domestic life he was to apprehend more clearly the relation of Jehovah to Israel. As the prophet in his later life meditated over his own sad experience he recognized that the affliction came to him from Jehovah to teach him, in order that he might be a teacher of others. That does not mean that he was not a prophet until his eyes were thus opened. He was conscious of a prophetic call when his first son was born, as is clear from the giving of the symbolic name. In fact, he understood the significance of his own domestic experience because he had the prophetic gift. Nevertheless, his experience led him into a deeper appreciation of the most important phase of his message to the people. Israel, like his wife, had adulterous tendencies; for a while they were restrained, but at the slightest provocation they broke forth. He next unfolds the historical and symbolic force of the name given to the first child. Verse 4. 4 . Jezreel That is, God sows. The name was to be given, as the next line shows, not on account of its meaning but on account of its historical connections. Jezreel is the well-known city of that name in the Plain of Jezreel. Blood Or, blood-guiltiness (G.-K., 124n); the extinction of the house of Ahab by Jehu, about 842 B.C. ( 2 Kings 9:10 ). The name, therefore, points both backward and forward backward to the crime and forward to the punishment. Not only the dynasty of Jehu is to be destroyed, but also the northern kingdom. The events are thought to be imminent. Yet a little while In this the prophet was not mistaken, for the fulfillment in each case took place within a few years, though not at one time; the farmer in the assassination of Zechariah by the usurper Shallum ( 2 Kings 15:10 ), the latter in the fall of Samaria and the exile of the northern tribes in 722-721 B.C. ( 2 Kings 17:0 ). Whedon then treats the naming of the second child and its announcement of withheld mercy. Verses 6-7. 6, 7 . Birth of Lo-ruhamah. 6. The second child of the union was a daughter. Lo-ruhamah Meaning She is not pitied, or loved; that is, she does not experience the love which is ordinarily bestowed by parents upon their children. The reason for giving this name is also stated. Israel, the child of Jehovah ( Hosea 11:1 ), is no longer loved or pitied by him to the extent that a child might expect love and pity; but Jehovah has not yet entirely cast off the people ( Hosea 1:9 ). But I will utterly take them away Better, with R.V., “that I should in any wise pardon them”; a perfectly legitimate translation ( Jeremiah 12:1 ; compare Genesis 40:15 , G.-K., 166b). There is no grammatical necessity for the rendering, “No, rather I will surely pardon them,” which Marti makes the basis for omitting the clause as a later addition, because the thought expressed is out of place in this connection. His translation being unwarranted there is no necessity for omitting the words.
Consider
On the moral development between prophetic generations, he presses: One cannot fail to see that the standpoint of Hosea is not the same as that of 2 Kings 10:30 . There Jehu is highly commended for the very act condemned here. How are we to explain the difference? The attempt to prove that Hosea has in mind some other crime is futile. The explanation lies in the advance in religious and ethical conceptions during the intervening century. The character of Jehovah never changes; but the conceptions of his character, even by the inspired prophets, did change and advance. It seems that the prophets of the ninth century had not yet learned “that the cause of truth is not permanently advanced by intrigue and bloodshed,” while Hosea is advancing toward the Christian belief that the kingdom of God must be extended by the moral influence going out from the kingdom; a view held also by the author of Isaiah 2:2-4 . Finally he weighs the textual and theological questions surrounding the promise to Judah. It is not without reason, therefore, that many commentators regard Hosea 1:7 as a later interpolation, reflecting the experiences of Judah in 701 ( 2 Kings 19:35 ff; Isaiah 37:36 ff.) An additional objection is raised on the ground that the thought of Hosea 1:7 is foreign to the rest of the chapter, in which the prophet narrates his own domestic life, and sets forth its significance as illustrating the relation of Israel to Jehovah. By Jehovah their God For the sake of emphasis, instead of by me; describes very aptly the deliverance of 701, as a reading of the account in 2 Kings will show. It is the constant teaching of the prophets that Jehovah, and not human defenses, is the salvation of his people ( Hosea 14:3 ; Isaiah 7:1-17 ; Isaiah 31:8 ; compare Hosea 2:7 ).
Respond
1. Where in my own life has the Lord used personal sorrow to deepen my grasp of his covenant love? 2. How does the advance in ethical understanding shown by Hosea challenge me to grow beyond earlier, narrower views of divine justice? 3. In what ways am I tempted to credit the Baals of our age rather than the living God for daily bread and safety?
Pray
Gracious and holy God, who dost not forsake thy people though they stray, grant us the prophetic insight of Hosea and the patient exposition of Whedon. Teach us to name our sins plainly yet to trust the mercy that still calls us home. May the same Spirit who moved the eighth-century prophet move us to contend for the purity of thy church and to hope for the restoration of all who bear thy name. Through Christ our Lord, who gathers the scattered and makes them one people again, we pray. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →