← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Maccabees

1 Maccabees 15-16 — Eterniseed (Catholic with deuterocanon)

1 Maccabees 15-16Eterniseed Original — Catholic Voice22 min
Opening
The fifteenth and sixteenth chapters of 1 Maccabees bring the book and the Maccabean generation to its close. Antiochus the Seventh Sidetes, the new Seleucid king who had supplanted Tryphon and recovered the Antiochene throne, at first courted Simon's alliance with grand promises of independence and friendship; but having secured his own position, he turned upon the Jewish nation, demanded the surrender of fortified towns and the payment of tribute for territories he claimed as Seleucid, and dispatched his general Cendebeus to ravage the Judean coast. The Maccabean response is led by Simon's sons John (later known as John Hyrcanus) and Judas, who defeat Cendebeus at Modin and Kidron in a campaign the inspired author records with sober dignity. The sixteenth chapter then narrates the final treachery of the entire book: Ptolemy son of Abubus, Simon's son-in-law and the governor of Jericho, invited Simon and two of his sons to a banquet at the small fortress of Dok above Jericho and murdered them at the feast. John Hyrcanus, the surviving son, escapes to Jerusalem and assumes the leadership of the nation; the book closes with the inspired author's brief notation that John's further deeds, his wars, his manful acts, the rebuilding of the walls, are written in the chronicles of his priesthood from the day he became high priest after his father. The Church reads this closing scene with sober eyes: the very Maccabean dynasty that had been raised up to deliver the temple from Antiochus would within its own grandchildren generation succumb to internal violence, Hellenistic court intrigues, and the kind of betrayal at a banquet that the inspired author has used throughout the book as the recurring sign of moral decay.
Read
Read 1 Maccabees chapters 15 and 16 with sober attention to the close of the Maccabean generation. In chapter fifteen, attend to Antiochus the Seventh Sidetes' initial letter to Simon offering peace, alliance, and the right to mint Jewish coinage; Simon's reception of the offer; Antiochus' subsequent demand for the surrender of Joppa, Gazara, the Acra citadel of Jerusalem, and tribute for territories Antiochus claimed; Simon's refusal of the unjust demand while offering compensation for legitimate claims; Antiochus' dispatch of his general Cendebeus to ravage the Judean coast; and Cendebeus' construction of a base at Kedron from which to attack Judea. In chapter sixteen, attend to Simon's commission of his sons John and Judas to lead the campaign against Cendebeus; the battle at Modin in which Cendebeus was routed; Simon's tour of inspection through the towns of Judea; his arrival at the small fortress of Dok above Jericho where his son-in-law Ptolemy son of Abubus governed; Ptolemy's banquet at which Simon and his sons Mattathias and Judas were murdered; the simultaneous murderous expedition Ptolemy dispatched to Gazara to seize John; John's warning by friends, his execution of Ptolemy's emissaries, his return to Jerusalem; and the closing notation that John's deeds are written in the chronicles of his priesthood.
Study
The closing chapters of 1 Maccabees carry the moral and theological weight of an ending that does not pretend to be a triumph. The inspired author records the further successes — the defeat of Cendebeus at Modin and Kidron, the consolidation of Jewish military strength, the assumption of leadership by John Hyrcanus — but he records also the deeper failure that has begun to corrode the Maccabean cause from within. Antiochus the Seventh Sidetes' demand in chapter fifteen for the surrender of Joppa, Gazara, the Jerusalem citadel, and tribute is presented as an unjust demand, and the text is careful to record Simon's measured response: he refused the unjust demand but offered compensation for the legitimate claims — a hundred talents of silver for Joppa and Gazara, but no acknowledgment that Antiochus had any title to the citadel of Jerusalem itself, which had been captured by Simon two years earlier and which Simon had ceremonially purified and restored to the Jewish nation. The Catholic moral tradition has read Simon's response as a model of just dealing in a contested political claim: distinguish the just from the unjust demand, offer compensation where compensation is owed, refuse what cannot be conscientiously granted. The sixteenth chapter then unfolds the final tragedy. Ptolemy son of Abubus is presented with notable economy by the inspired author: he was Simon's son-in-law, married to one of Simon's daughters; he had been appointed by Simon governor of the rich agricultural region of Jericho; he had grown wealthy and ambitious; he had concluded that he could seize the Maccabean leadership for himself if he could eliminate Simon and his sons in a single stroke. The means he chose was a banquet at the small fortress of Dok above Jericho, to which he invited his father-in-law and the two sons accompanying him on his tour of inspection. When Simon and his sons were heavy with wine, Ptolemy and his hidden assassins fell upon them and murdered all three. The Church has read this banquet-betrayal as the structural completion of the long pattern the inspired author has used throughout the book: the lure of Jonathan to Ptolemais by Tryphon, the false embassy of Alcimus to the Hasidim, the deceptions of various Seleucid courtiers — all culminating in the banquet at Dok where the very son-in-law of the patriarch murdered him at the family table. The Catholic moral tradition has been severe about this species of treachery in particular; the violation of hospitality and family relation is treated by Saint Thomas Aquinas in the Summa II-II q.40 on war and q.55 on prudence as a particularly grave offense because it adds to the bare injustice the further corruption of the bonds of trust on which all human community rests. The escape of John Hyrcanus from Ptolemy's parallel murder plot at Gazara, his rapid return to Jerusalem, his execution of Ptolemy's emissaries, and his assumption of the leadership of the nation set the stage for the long Hasmonean dynasty that would govern the Jewish state for another sixty years until the Roman intervention under Pompey in 63 BC dissolved Jewish political independence and inaugurated the period in which Christ would be born. The closing notation of the inspired author is theologically loaded by its very restraint: the rest of the acts of John, and his wars, and his manful acts which he did, and the building of the walls which he made, are they not written in the chronicles of his priesthood from the day he became high priest after his father. The phrase "from the day he became high priest after his father" is the inspired author's acknowledgment that the priestly office which had begun in irregularity under Jonathan and had been consolidated under Simon was now passing to a third generation by simple dynastic inheritance — and within John Hyrcanus' own lifetime, the Hasmonean dynasty would conduct campaigns of forcible conversion against the Idumeans (whose descendant Herod would become the king of Judea in the time of Christ), would foment the internal schism between the Sadducees and Pharisees, and would set the substrate for the political and religious dysfunctions of the second-temple period that Jesus would address in his Galilean ministry. The Church reads the entire closing arc of 1 Maccabees with sober eyes. The Maccabean cause was holy in its origins, costly in its sacrifices, and necessary in its outcomes; the temple was cleansed, the law was restored, the Hasidim were vindicated. But the Hasmonean dynasty that the cause produced was unable to sustain the holiness of its origins; political success became the seed of religious decay; the priestly office acquired through war and dynasty grew distant from the prophetic word that would announce the true high priest in the manner of Melchizedek. The Maccabean martyrs entered the communion of saints; the Hasmonean dynasts entered the chronicles of a kingdom whose final fulfillment they could not themselves produce. Saint Jerome and Saint Augustine both read this closing arc as one of the great schools of providence in the Old Testament: the partial fulfillment of the prophetic word in the Maccabean cause makes way for the final fulfillment in the coming of Christ, and the very limitations of the Hasmonean dynasty point beyond themselves to the kingdom that the prophets had promised.
Consider
Consider the closing arc of 1 Maccabees as a school of the limitations of even holy political success. The Maccabean cause was holy; the Hasmonean dynasty that grew from it could not sustain the holiness of its origins. This pattern is not unique to the Maccabean period; the Church has lived through it in her own history many times. The reform of religious life by Saint Bernard of Clairvaux gave rise to the Cistercian order that within two centuries needed reform itself; the missionary expansion of the early Jesuits produced provinces that within two centuries required reformation; the founding of religious nations by Catholic monarchs produced political institutions that within centuries grew distant from their founding spirituality. Where in your own observation of the Church or of Catholic institutions do you see the same pattern at work today — a holy founding charism gradually obscured by the success it had purchased? Consider too Ptolemy's banquet at Dok. The treachery of the son-in-law against the father-in-law at the family table is the structural completion of the Maccabean book's long meditation on betrayal. The Catholic moral tradition has been clear that the violation of hospitality and family bonds is a particularly grave species of sin precisely because it corrupts the trust on which all human community rests. Where in your own life have you been tempted to use a familial relation or a relation of hospitality for political advantage that the relation itself did not warrant? Consider finally the inspired author's restrained closing notation. He does not lament; he does not editorialize; he simply records that the further deeds of John Hyrcanus are written in the chronicles of his priesthood. The Catholic tradition has often used this kind of restrained ending in its hagiography — the saint dies, the deeds continue, the historical record is invoked but not exhausted, the reader is invited to read further but is not required to do so. Have you cultivated this restraint in your own narrating of your life, or do you tend toward the editorial gesture that absolutizes the closing moment?
Respond
Take time this week to pray for one Catholic institution — a religious order, a Catholic university, a Catholic apostolate, a Catholic charity — whose founding spirituality you sense to have grown distant from its present operation. Offer a Rosary for the renewal of that institution's holy founding charism; if you are able, write a letter or contribute to a renewing initiative within it. The Maccabean witness reminds us that holy origins must be defended in every generation.
Pray
Almighty and eternal God, who through the Maccabean brothers Mattathias and Judas and Jonathan and Simon and Eleazar and John brought your people through the great trial of Antiochus Epiphanes to the relative peace of Simon's golden age, and who in the closing tragedy of Ptolemy's banquet at Dok taught your Church the sober truth that even holy political success cannot sustain itself unless renewed in every generation by the conversion of heart, sustain in us the long patience that does not absolutize partial peace and does not despise it either. By the intercession of the Maccabean martyrs whose witness preceded the witness of the apostles, by the prayer of John Hyrcanus and his successors whose mixed legacy your providence has folded into the longer arc that prepared the way for the coming of your Son, and through the prayers of the Blessed Virgin Mary, queen of the kingdom that the Hasmonean state could not itself produce, give us holy origins renewed in holy operations, and the visibility of memorialized faith carried forward unbroken to the final fulfillment. Through Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, forever and ever. Amen.

Eterniseed Original — Catholic Voice · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.