Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
John 20 — with Whedon
Opening
In the quiet hours before dawn we turn again to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments, that steady Wesleyan guide whose careful harmony of the Gospels lets the resurrection light fall upon every seeking heart. With Arminian warmth and Methodist clarity Whedon shows how the risen Lord meets each degree of faith and unbelief, turning doubt itself into testimony. Today his exposition of John chapter twenty invites us to stand once more at the empty tomb and hear the living voice that still calls disciples by name.
Read
Let us now read the twentieth chapter of John, listening for the measured steps of Mary Magdalene, the hurried feet of Peter and John, and the gentle yet decisive word of the risen Christ. As the narrative unfolds, notice how each witness moves from sorrow to recognition and how the Evangelist gathers every testimony into one coherent witness. Read slowly, allowing the Spirit to quicken the same faith that once turned weeping into proclamation.
Study
Whedon opens by laying out the ordered sequence of events surrounding the first announcement of the resurrection.
Introduction. The following seems to be the true harmony of the evangelical histories of the first announcement of the resurrection of Jesus. 1 . The women in a body (Mary Magdalene in advance of the whole) approach the sepulchre. 2 . Mary Magdalene, seeing the stone removed, and hastily concluding that the body has been abstracted, runs for Peter and John, thus separating herself from the rest of the women. 3 . While she is thus gone, the other women arrive at the sepulchre and see two angels, and depart to inform the disciples, who reside at a distance. 4 . While they are gone, Peter and John run to the sepulchre, find it empty, and return to their own homes. 5 . Mary Magdalene, having followed them to the sepulchre, stands outside weeping, and when Peter and John depart, she sees first two angels and then Jesus, and according to his command departs to carry his message to the other apostles. 6 . The women on their way before their arrival at the abode of the apostles, but after the appearance of Jesus to Mary Magdalene have a sight of Jesus. 7 . At last all the women, including Mary Magdalene, unite in relating their story to the incredulous apostles.He next unfolds the divine symmetry that unites the several Gospel accounts without any conscious collaboration among the Evangelists.
Verses 1-10. § 145, 146. WOMEN VISIT THE SEPULCHRE, AND ALSO PETER AND John 20:1-10 . Matthew 28:1-8 ; Mark 16:1-8 ; Luke 24:1-12 . In the histories of the resurrection, brought under one view, we may discern a divine, overruling plan, giving a unity to the whole. This symmetry of plan could not have been fabricated by the Evangelists, for each, with evident unconsciousness, furnishes his share without knowing what the other contributes; so that the whole is made up of unintentional parts. Some traits of this design are the following: (1.) The female sex is here placed in a true position of love to Christ, and of recognition by him, of a kind transcendently raised above all possible imputation of impurity. Women could not be apostles; they could but distantly and reservedly serve our Lord in his life.Whedon then traces the successive degrees of faith that appear among the women and the apostles.
But here the great compensation is given that they are first witnesses, apostles to the apostles, nighest to Jesus himself in his resurrection state. See note on Luke 1:2 . (2.) The unbelief to which the apostles abandon themselves is made the means of bringing out more fully our Lord’s self-manifestations at his resurrection. Their scepticism is made the instrument for removing the scepticism of all ages. (3.) There are manifested the various natural degrees of faith. There is the simple faith, ready and sympathizing, of the women, meritorious and crowning because, from a pure heart, believing the testimony of the angels, and clinging in worship at the knees of our Lord. There is the scriptural and truly Christian faith of the two brothers of Emmaus, receiving with burning hearts the verification of prophecy unfolded in the words of Jesus.On the appearance to Mary he presses the reverent restraint that preserved her pre-eminence of faith.
Verse 17. 17 . Touch me not Several manuscripts have the words she ran forward to touch him. As if in order to realize that it was truly her Lord, and not a pure spirit, she rushed forth to touch him. The word touch here, never signifies, as some interpret it, to embrace. That she, like the other women, ( Matthew 28:9 ,) kneeling to him, embraced his knees, has no authority from any word of the Evangelists. She had the testimony of two of her senses, sight and hearing, that it was the Lord; and she now seeks the testimony of a third, namely, of feeling, in order to be sure that it is a body and not a pure spirit which addresses her. Our Lord forbids her touch, that she may not lose the honour of her pre-eminence of faith. He tests that faith by a command which she obeys, and stands first of faithful witnesses.
Consider
Whedon concludes by declaring the blessedness promised to all who believe without having seen.
Verse 29. 29 . Hast seen The word seen here implies the evidence not only of sight but of either or all the senses. Have not seen, and yet have believed The visible tangible Christ will soon depart from the earth, to be seen no more. The doctrine and the power of his life and death will come forth to the faith of the world. The hearts and souls that rightly will to accept it, must do it by a faith that is above sight and above sense. Many will say, like Thomas, that they can only believe upon sensible demonstration. They will not be convinced but upon the highest possible proof; proof which shall meet their utmost exaction and leave doubt impossible. Some will do this in a spirit of low sensuality; some in a spirit of scientific indifference or intellectual pride. But all who in a true sense deserve to be saved will be saved; and none but those who deserve to be damned will be damned. Blessed In what sense blessed? In no single, but in every divine sense. As faith in its full power procures, so this blessedness includes the full fruition of all that the Gospel offers or the atonement brings to man. Very wise were the words of Pfenninger, quoted by Stier: “Is not Thomas a pledge of all who, like him, are slow to believe, that every severe word spoken to unbelief refers to those who will not believe? As to this not-able and not-willing, God will judge.” That is, God will judge whether the not-able is an honest inability to believe when there is the spirit of faith, or whether it be a not-willing, deceiving the obstinate unbeliever into the false opinion that he is not able to believe.Finally he summarizes the Evangelist’s purpose that readers throughout the ages might believe and have life through Christ’s name.
Verse 30. § 157. ST. JOHN’S FIRST CONCLUSION, John 20:30-31 . 30 . Many other signs The Greek word for signs here is often rendered miracles; for the miracles of Jesus were all signs, indicating the divinity of their author. In the presence of his disciples The appointed witnesses to testify them to the world. See note on Luke 1:2 . This book The entire Gospel. From which it appears that we are not to infer that the Evangelists were ignorant of a given fact because they omit to notice it. It is no presumption against the truth of the narrative because it is given by but one Evangelist. It is no proof that the Lord’s Supper was not instituted because John does not mention it. That ye might believe This ye addresses every reader to the end of the world. It speaks from John to the person that now peruses this commentary, inviting him to believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and have life through his name. Jesus is the Christ Is the Messiah. Christ lived, his apostles preached, and his Evangelists wrote, that the world might shape its conceptions to the true idea of the Messiah, not as the emancipator of the nation, but as the Saviour of the world. We have in these two verses what the best scholars of modern times consider to be a proper summary and ending of the book. The chapter which follows has been considered a later addition. See introductory note.
Respond
1. In what area of my life am I still waiting at the tomb rather than running to share the news of the risen Lord?
2. How does the progression from Mary’s tears to Thomas’s confession invite me to bring my own honest doubts before the living Christ?
3. Where is the Spirit prompting me to bear witness today, even if others may at first find the testimony hard to believe?
Pray
Gracious and risen Savior, we thank Thee for the faithful labors of Thy servant Daniel D. Whedon, whose commentary opens the Scriptures with clarity and love. Grant us, like Mary, ears quickened by Thy voice and, like Thomas, hearts ready to confess Thee Lord and God. Strengthen every degree of faith within Thy Church, that doubt may be turned to testimony and sorrow to joyful proclamation. Breathe upon us again Thy Holy Spirit, that we may remit sins through the Gospel and retain only what hinders Thy kingdom. Keep us steadfast until we see Thee face to face and join the company of all who have believed without having seen. In the name of the risen Christ we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →