← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Maccabees

2 Maccabees 13-14 — Eterniseed (Catholic with deuterocanon)

2 Maccabees 13-14Eterniseed Original — Catholic Voice22 min
Opening
The thirteenth and fourteenth chapters of 2 Maccabees set forth the second campaign of Lysias accompanied by the boy king Eupator and the rise of the Syrian general Nicanor under King Demetrius I. The thirteenth chapter records the death of the apostate high priest Menelaus, executed by Antiochus Eupator at the suggestion of Lysias, in a manner the inspired editor presents with theological emphasis — the man who had introduced the Greek gymnasium near the temple and who had purchased the high priesthood by simony was put to death by being thrown from a tower into a great quantity of ashes, the inspired commentary noting that he died without burial in foreign soil, as fit punishment for one who had sinned against the altar of the Lord whose fire was on the holy ashes. The fourteenth chapter then introduces the figure of Nicanor and presents the dramatic martyrdom of Razis the elder, one of the most theologically complex martyrdom passages in the entire deuterocanonical literature.
Read
Read 2 Maccabees chapters 13 and 14 with attention to the contrasting deaths of Menelaus and Razis. In chapter thirteen, attend to the second campaign of Lysias with the boy king Eupator and one hundred ten thousand infantry, the death of Menelaus by being thrown from the ash-tower at Berea, Judas's preparations and his prayer, the night attack on the king's pavilion, the diplomatic resolution that left the religious liberties intact, and the return of Eupator to Antioch. In chapter fourteen, attend to the rise of Demetrius I to the Seleucid throne, the political intrigues of Alcimus the apostate Jewish priest seeking restoration of his high-priestly position, the dispatch of Nicanor with orders to seize Judas, the initial peaceful negotiations between Judas and Nicanor, Alcimus's renewed accusations that broke the peace, Nicanor's blasphemous oath against the temple, and the suicide of Razis the elder when the Syrian soldiers came to arrest him.
Study
The death of Menelaus in chapter thirteen is recorded with the theological emphasis the inspired editor has used throughout the book to disclose providence's working in the historical events. The text describes how the regent Lysias, recognizing that Menelaus was the principal cause of all the troubles between the Seleucid government and the Jewish nation, persuaded the boy king Eupator to have him put to death. The manner of execution — being thrown from a tower into a great quantity of ashes at the city of Berea — was a Syrian custom for those guilty of sacrilege, the inspired commentator notes, and was particularly fitting for one who had committed sins against the altar of the Lord whose fire was on the holy ashes. The Catholic tradition has read this passage as a particular instance of providence's working through the very judgments of the persecuting power to vindicate the moral order. Menelaus is destroyed not by the resistance of the persecuted Jewish community but by the apparent allies who had used him for their own purposes. Saint Augustine in De Civitate Dei treats the broader providential pattern: the wicked who have served as instruments of trial for the people of God often perish at the hands of their own associates rather than at the hands of those they had persecuted, and this is itself a particular form of divine judgment. The figure of Razis the elder in chapter fourteen presents one of the most theologically complex episodes in the deuterocanonical literature. The text describes Razis as one of the elders of Jerusalem, a man who loved his fellow citizens deeply, who was called father of the Jews because of his goodwill, and who in former times had been accused before Antiochus IV of refusing to abandon the Jewish religion. When Nicanor sent five hundred soldiers to arrest him, Razis took refuge in his tower; the soldiers broke through the doors and were about to capture him alive. Razis preferred to die nobly rather than fall into the hands of the wicked, so he fell upon his own sword. Wounded but not killed, he ran up the wall, threw himself down upon the crowd below; still alive but dying, he ran through the crowd, climbed a high rock, and tore out his entrails throwing them down upon the multitude, calling upon the Lord of life and spirit to give them back to him at the resurrection. The Catholic moral tradition has read this passage with particular care because of the question it raises about the moral evaluation of suicide in the face of capture by an unjust persecutor. Saint Augustine in De Civitate Dei Book I (chapters 16-27, treating particularly the case of the Christian virgins violated by the Visigoths during the sack of Rome in 410) addressed the broader question at length, and his treatment is foundational for the Catholic tradition's evaluation. Augustine distinguished the case of those who, like Razis, chose death rather than capture from the case of those who chose death to avoid the prospect of being forced to apostasy or sexual violation. His judgment was that suicide as such is forbidden by the fifth commandment, but that the case of Razis is presented in the inspired text not as a moral exemplar but as a particular instance of the noble pagan-influenced ideal of dying with honor that the Maccabean martyrs as a whole reflect with varying degrees of theological precision. Augustine declined to commend Razis's act as model behavior, but he also declined to condemn it as unambiguously sinful, noting that the inspired text presents Razis sympathetically and that the practice of his time and culture allowed for the noble death in defense of one's people. The Catholic moral tradition since Augustine has held with steadiness that direct suicide is forbidden by the fifth commandment, that one may never directly will one's own death even to escape the worst evils that may threaten, and that the case of Razis as the inspired text presents it is not a recommendation of the practice but a witness to the deep complexity of the moral situation under imperial persecution. Saint Thomas Aquinas in Summa II-II q.64 a.5 (whether it is lawful to kill oneself) treats the question explicitly and follows Augustine in distinguishing the broader principle (suicide is forbidden) from the difficult cases (where the agent's culpability may be diminished by extreme duress, by lack of clear teaching, by the cultural assumptions of the time). The Catholic tradition's reception of Razis is therefore characterized by sympathy without endorsement. The Roman Martyrology does not include Razis in its commemorations on August 1 alongside the seven brothers, their mother, and Eleazar; the distinction is intentional and reflects the moral judgment that the manner of Razis's death, however nobly intended, falls outside the proper category of martyrdom that the Church has historically recognized. The doctrinal substance Razis's death does preserve — the cry to the Lord of life and spirit to give back the entrails at the resurrection — is an important Old Testament witness to the doctrine of bodily resurrection, paralleling the confessions of the seven brothers in chapter seven. The inspired text records the doctrine even where it does not endorse the means of confession.
Consider
Consider the death of Menelaus as a school of the providence that uses the very judgments of the persecuting powers to vindicate the moral order. Menelaus is not killed by Judas or the Jewish resistance but by the regent of the very Seleucid dynasty he had served, who recognized him as the principal cause of trouble and procured his execution at the boy king's hands. The Catholic tradition has long observed this providential pattern: the wicked who have served as instruments of trial often perish at the hands of their associates, and this perishing is itself a form of judgment. Where in the political life of your own time do you see this pattern at work? Consider too the suicide of Razis. The Catholic moral tradition has been careful about this passage — sympathy without endorsement, the inspired text preserved but not made into the model behavior. The fifth commandment forbids direct suicide; the agent's culpability in difficult cases may be diminished by extreme duress, by lack of clear teaching, by the cultural assumptions of the time; the inspired text records the doctrine of resurrection that Razis cried out even where it does not endorse the means. The Catholic pastoral tradition's care for the families of those who have died by suicide draws on precisely this kind of theological complexity — the firm doctrinal principle held alongside the deep mercy that recognizes the manifold circumstances that may diminish culpability. Consider whether you have allowed simplistic theological judgment to dim either the firm principle or the deep mercy that the Catholic tradition has held together. Consider finally the doctrinal substance Razis confesses even at the moment of his death. The cry to the Lord of life and spirit to give back the entrails at the resurrection is among the foundational Old Testament witnesses to the doctrine of bodily resurrection. The same God who created the body from nothing (chapter seven) and who will restore the soul that has been faithfully ordered toward him (chapter twelve) can give back even the dismembered body to its proper integrity at the last day. Have you cultivated this confidence in the resurrection of the body as the substantive content of the hope your funeral rites express?
Respond
Pray this week the Office for the Dead from the Liturgy of the Hours (or its abbreviated form, the De Profundis with the Eternal Rest prayer), for the souls of those who have died by their own hand whose memory you carry. The Catholic tradition has long cultivated this prayer precisely because the theological complexity of the case calls for sustained intercession rather than for hasty judgment. The deep mercy of God toward those who have died in such circumstances is one of the substantive truths the Catholic pastoral tradition has held.
Pray
O God of hosts, who in the days of trial upheld your people against the fury of the nations and kindled within them the sure hope of bodily resurrection, strengthen your Church to stand firm in faith and to entrust every suffering to your just and merciful hand. Through the prayers of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the holy martyrs, keep us steadfast until we share in the victory of your Son. Amen.

Eterniseed Original — Catholic Voice · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.