← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Hosea

Hosea 5-6 — with Whedon

Hosea 5-6Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
Beloved, we gather in the spirit of Wesleyan holiness to hear from Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments as it unfolds the solemn message of Hosea chapters 5 and 6. With forthright Arminian clarity Whedon traces how divine justice confronts national apostasy while ever inviting the penitent heart to seek the Lord. May these ancient words, illumined by his faithful exposition, awaken us to the urgency of true repentance and the steadfast mercy that still waits for those who return with their whole heart.
Read
Let us now read together Hosea chapters 5 and 6, listening for the prophet's summons to priests, people, and princes alike. As the words of judgment and invitation sound, may the Spirit prepare our hearts to receive both the warning and the call to return, that we might not rest in outward forms but press on to know the Lord.
Study
Whedon opens by setting forth the overall theme of chapters 5-8. Introduction. THE UTTER CORRUPTION OF ISRAEL THE IMMINENT DOOM, chap. 5-8. Chapters 5-8, which are closely connected, present a detailed account of the manner in which corruption penetrated the entire public life and affected the state from the highest to the lowest. Interspersed are exhortations, warnings, threats of inevitable destruction. REBUKE OF ISRAEL’S APOSTASY TIME OF MERCY IS PAST, Hosea 5:1-15 . Chapter 5 falls naturally into two parts: Hosea 5:1-7 , where the emphasis is upon guilt; Hosea 5:8-15 , which deals primarily with judgment. The address is directed against (1) the priests, (2) the people, (3) the king and his courtiers. Which of these receives primary attention it is not always easy to say. The civil and religious leaders are largely to blame, but all must suffer the consequences. Whedon next expounds the section on the time of mercy being past. Verses 8-15. The time of mercy is past, Hosea 5:8-15 . The hopelessness of the situation is manifest: Jehovah can show mercy no longer, judgment is inevitable; it is about to break upon the sinful nations. The prophet, summons them to prepare for it, and declares that Assyria and Egypt can offer no effective help; there can be no salvation until the people with heartfelt repentance return to Jehovah. Whedon then takes up the mutual exhortation that follows in chapter 6. Verses 1-3. THE PEOPLE’S RETURN TO JEHOVAH, Hosea 6:1-3 . The first three verses of chapter 6 form the natural continuation of Hosea 5:15 , with which LXX. connects them by prefixing “saying.” This addition explains them as a mutual exhortation to return to Jehovah. While saying may have been added by the Greek translator, it embodies undoubtedly a correct interpretation. As expected, they will return, but without real, heartfelt repentance. There is not one expression of sorrow for wrongdoing, only anxiety to have distress and calamity removed. Therefore Jehovah is not impressed with the supplication ( Hosea 6:4 ff.) The verses offer “but one symptom of the optimism of this light-hearted people, whom no discipline and no judgment can impress with the reality of their incurable decay.” Giesebrecht’s interpretation of the passage as a new exhortation by the prophet is less natural.
Consider
Whedon concludes the section by presenting Jehovah's direct reply to superficial repentance. Verses 4-5. 4, 5 . What shall I do unto thee What more can I do to move you to heartfelt repentance? Goodness In Hosea 2:19 , “lovingkindness” (see comment there); here the loving attitude and disposition toward Jehovah. It is unstable and fickle; “evanescent and transient, like the morning cloud which is dispersed by the rising sun,” and like the dew which remains but for a little time. Therefore This fickleness has compelled Jehovah to use severe means. Hewed… by the prophets He carefully carved them like a piece of hard wood or marble, which requires hard and effective blows. He sought to make Israel a holy nation through the efforts of the prophets. Slain them by the words of my mouth As spoken by the prophets. The words of Jehovah have power to kill ( Isaiah 11:4 ; compare Isaiah 9:8 ; Isaiah 49:2 ); here is meant not so much extinction of life as infliction of severe judgments. The activity of Elijah and Elisha may be in the prophet’s mind. Thy judgments are as the light that goeth forth Better, R.V. margin, following several ancient versions, “my judgments,” that is, the penal judgments of Jehovah. The thought is the same as in the preceding clauses, and the whole sentence is translated most naturally, “My judgment went forth as the light,” that is, so that all could see it and profit thereby. Sometimes the Hebrew light is used in the sense of lightning; if so in this case, it calls attention to the terrible character of the divine judgments.
Respond
1. Where in my own life have I mistaken outward religious activity for the deep repentance the Lord requires? 2. How does the certainty of divine judgment stir me to intercede for the church and nation today? 3. In what ways am I being invited to press on to know the Lord rather than merely seek relief from trouble?
Pray
Gracious and holy God, we thank Thee for the faithful witness of Thy servant Daniel D. Whedon and for the searching light of Thy word in Hosea. Convict us of every shallow devotion and every hidden compromise. Grant us the grace of genuine repentance that we may return to Thee with undivided hearts. As Thou hast promised healing to those who seek Thy face, raise us up to live before Thee in righteousness and true holiness. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →