Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
John 3 — with Whedon
Opening
In the quiet hours of daily devotion we turn again to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments, that sturdy Methodist witness to the living Word. With reverent clarity Whedon leads us through the third chapter of John, tracing the Savior’s midnight conversation with Nicodemus and the unfolding mysteries of the new birth. His Arminian heart beats steadily for the universal love of God and the free response of faith. May the same Spirit who moved upon the waters move upon our hearts as we listen.
Read
With open Bibles and attentive hearts let us read aloud the whole of John chapter 3. Hear the Lord’s words to Nicodemus, the testimony of the Baptist, and the promise of eternal life to every believer. Read slowly, pausing where the Spirit presses, that the sacred narrative may sink deeply into mind and soul.
Study
Whedon opens by placing Nicodemus before us as one who believes by miracle yet needs the deeper work of the Spirit.
Verse 3. 3 . Except a man Our Lord’s reply seems abrupt; but it was perfectly suited to the case. Nicodemus was a logical believer upon the ground of miracle. Jesus forthwith proceeds, therefore, to lead him from that starting-point, to the full heart reception of the deeper spiritual truths of Christianity, and to the full experience of their truth and power. His deeper points are, original sin, regeneration by the Spirit, atonement, salvation by faith, condemnation by unbelief. He cannot see Same as cannot enter, John 3:5 . So to see life, John 3:36 . Compare to see good days, Psalms 34:12 ; also Ecclesiastes 6:6 ; Hebrews 12:14 . It is not to be supposed that John has here given anything more than a very brief and free, though symmetrical, summary of this conversation. It would take an ordinary reader not more than two or three minutes to utter the whole; and it is not to be imagined that an interview so carefully sought should be so briefly transacted. We need feel no perplexity about the question proposed by sceptics, How did John come by his report of this secret conversation? If we are to suppose that Nicodemus came perfectly alone (which cannot conclusively be shown) we need not therefore conclude that Jesus was himself alone. Nicodemus may have been afraid to bring companions; but he could not have been afraid of John and his four fellow disciples, had he or they been present.He next unfolds the necessity of birth by water and the Spirit.
Verse 5. 5 . Jesus now proceeds to tell the how. Of water and of the Spirit Of water, as the external indication of the external kingdom; of Spirit, as the internal induction into the internal kingdom. The former supposes the latter as its previous condition, and is its external profession or sign. Those who refuse to perform and accept the sign, do wilfully exclude themselves from the kingdom of God. Yet, although the conditional duty, it does not stand on the same ground of an absolute condition without which salvation is in itself impossible, as is the case in being born of the Spirit. This we see intimated in Mark 16:16 , where baptism is required; but there is a careful avoidance of saying that he that is not baptized shall be damned. Baptism may in many eases be impossible.Whedon then presses the contrast between flesh and Spirit in regeneration.
Verse 6. 6 . Flesh… Spirit Flesh is not synonymous with body. The word is used in the Old Testament to designate the entire transient, perishable, fallen, and corrupt nature of man, both in body and soul. Hence the meaning of the first clause of this first verse is: That which is generated of fallen and depraved humanity, is itself fallen and depraved humanity. Like produces like. Through all the productive, procreative kingdoms, whether animal or vegetable, no offspring is of a higher species than its parentage. On the other hand, Spirit here refers to the Holy Spirit as so operating upon the human spirit, and so changing its nature, as to be said to beget it anew. For as generation is a modifying of substance or being, imparting to it a new principle of life, conforming it, as living being, to the likeness of the generator, so regeneration is a modification of the human spirit by the Holy Spirit, conforming the temper of the human to the Holy. Is spirit As flesh signifies a depraved nature, so spirit in this verse signifies a pure nature. For it is a pure and holy Spirit which is the generator, and it must be a pure and holy spirit which is generated. The whole text then is: As a depraved nature generates a depraved nature, so the holy nature generates a holy nature. And as we are first born of a depraved nature, and therefore depraved, so we must be born (or rather begotten) from a holy nature, and so be renewed.Finally he grounds the whole doctrine upon the Son’s heavenly authority.
Verse 9. 9 . How Nicodemus here does not so much ask the manner as imply that it cannot be in any manner. He is too respectful to give his doubt in any stronger form than a question. Our Lord has now firmly maintained the doctrine of regeneration propounded in the third verse, but his listener is in doubt. Jesus, therefore, in the following verses, First grounds himself on his own authority as a teacher, acknowledged by Nicodemus himself to be from God, affirming in the sublimest terms his own absolute knowledge, 10-13. Second, To this doctrine of regeneration he adds the second great spiritual truth of the kingdom of God, the doctrine of universal atonement, 14-17. Third, He affirms that upon faith depends our justification or condemnation, assigning for that doctrine its proper reason, 18-21.
Consider
On the atonement Whedon presses the universal scope of God’s love.
Verse 16. 16 . Whosoever believeth From this we learn: 1. That God loved the world before the atonement, and the atonement was the result of his previous love. 2. That in spite of that love the atonement was necessary, to save man from perishing. The atonement was God’s method, adopted by his love, of allowing man to exist and yet not be damned. 3. That the world for which Christ died was not part of the world, nor the elect world, but the whole world. 4. That faith, the faith which accepts Christ, is necessary to bring the atonement in application upon the soul so as to produce salvation. 5. That universal salvation would result but for the individual’s unbelief. 6. The doctrine of justification by faith is as clearly taught, though in different words, in the Gospels and in Christ’s teachings, as in any of the Epistles of Paul.He concludes by showing that the purpose of the Son’s coming is salvation, not condemnation.
Verse 17. 17 . Not… condemn the world The divine ideal, purpose, or object, is that the whole world should be saved. All that is necessary for this ideal to be realized is provided, on the basis that man remain a free agent, and that that free agency remain inviolate. If that free agent reject the offer of salvation by which he might be saved, he will be lost. Yet the purpose of the atonement was not to condemn but to save.
Respond
1. Where in my own life do I rest content with a merely logical faith, and how is the Spirit inviting me to a birth from above? 2. Am I willing to let the wind of the Spirit blow where it will, even if it crosses my plans or reputation? 3. How does the assurance that God sent his Son not to condemn but to save shape my witness to others today?
Pray
Gracious Father, who so loved the world that thou gavest thine only Son, breathe upon us again the renewing wind of thy Spirit. Grant that we who have been born of water may also be born of the Spirit, that we may see and enter thy kingdom. Deliver us from every fear of man that would keep us from the light. May the same love that sent Jesus to seek and to save move through our words and deeds, that whosoever believeth on him may not perish but have everlasting life. In the strong name of Jesus we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →