← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Job

Why Do the Wicked Prosper?

Job 21-22Morals on the Book of Job (Moralia in Iob) by St. Gregory the Great21 min
Opening
It is the oldest scandal of the godly heart: the wicked flourish. Their houses are at peace, their children dance, their flocks never miscarry, and "the rod of God" seems never to fall on them. Job's friends took his ruin as proof of guilt; Job answers them not with bitterness but with a question that pierces their whole theology — "Wherefore do the wicked live, are lifted up, and strengthened by riches?" St. Gregory the Great hears in Job's reply the patient voice of the Church, who bears the darts of the proud without leaving "the pathway of her humility," and who knows that the present life's good fortune is no measure of a soul's worth. Then Eliphaz speaks his third and harshest speech (Job 22), heaping invented crimes on a righteous man — and Gregory reads in his words the very accents of heretics who mistake affliction for condemnation.
Read
Read Job 21 — Job's plea, "Hear diligently my speech"; his unanswerable question, "Wherefore do the wicked live, become old, yea, are mighty in power?" Their seed is established, their houses are safe from fear, their cattle never fail, they spend their days in wealth and "in a moment go down to the grave" — these are the very ones who say unto God, "Depart from us; for we desire not the knowledge of thy ways." Then read Job 22 — Eliphaz asking, "Can a man be profitable unto God?"; charging Job falsely with stripping the naked, withholding bread from the hungry, sending widows away empty; insinuating that Job thinks "thick clouds are a covering to him, that he seeth not"; and urging him, "Acquaint now thyself with him, and be at peace."
Study
Why does the godless man's prosperity last? Gregory's answer is not that God is absent but that God is patient. For except the patience of God bore with them, they would never live long in their sins; the very length of their days is a forbearance, not a verdict. The friends erred precisely here — reading present fortune as a register of merit — and Gregory states the principle they lacked: prosperity in the present life is no witness to innocency. For the accounts are not settled on earth at all. real goods are reserved for the good, and real ills for the bad, in the season of the eternal recompensing. And the inmost sin of these comfortable ones is not their wealth but their words — "Depart from us." Gregory exposes how that exile is worked: as to think of His precepts, is to introduce Him into one's self, so to resist His commandments is to keep Him away from the dwelling-place of the heart.
Consider
Eliphaz opens his speech by asking whether a man can profit God — and here, beneath his cruelty, lies a true word that Gregory gladly receives: in all that we do well, we are doing good to ourselves and not to God, who needs nothing of the goodness He bestows and then crowns. But Eliphaz cannot keep to truth; he descends from idle words to slander, inventing sins to fit the suffering he sees. Gregory reads in him the heretic who, finding a faithful soul afflicted, supposes it stricken for misbelief. The root of all such pride Gregory names by contrast with Christ: As the 'way' of our Redeemer is humility, so the way of the world is pride. The wicked who say "Who is the Almighty, that we should serve him?" walk that worldly way, while the afflicted righteous, bearing the rod in silence, walk the Redeemer's. So Job's seeming defeat is no defeat at all. The dunghill is nearer the kingdom than the comfortable house, because humility is nearer to God than pride.
Respond
Stop reading prosperity as a scoreboard. When the ruthless thrive and you, trying to do right, are pressed down, you have not been forgotten; you have been told the truth Job's friends never learned — that "the complexion of the present life does not in the least degree prove the worth of men's conduct." God's patience with the wicked is not His approval of them; it is space for repentance they are squandering, and you would not trade your affliction for their unbilled reckoning. Watch your own heart for the quiet "Depart from us" — not spoken in words but lived in resistance to His commandments, which shuts Him out of the dwelling-place of the heart as surely as any blasphemy. And when, like Eliphaz, others read your suffering as your guilt, do not answer pride with pride. Keep "the pathway of humility," for that is the way of your Redeemer, and it runs straight to the recompense the world's brief winners will never see.
Pray
O Lord our God, whose patience bears long with the unrighteous and whose justice forgets nothing: deliver us from envy of the prosperous wicked and from the friends' error that measures a soul by its fortunes. Teach us that real goods are reserved for the good in the season of Thine eternal recompensing, and that every good we do, we do to ourselves by Thy gift, who hast no need of our righteousness. Guard our hearts from the secret "Depart from us" of disobedience, and lead us in the way of our Redeemer, which is humility, away from the way of the world, which is pride. Let us bear the rod in silence and await Thy reckoning in hope. To Thee be glory and thanksgiving, now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.

Morals on the Book of Job (Moralia in Iob) by St. Gregory the Great · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →