← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians

1 Corinthians 14 — with Whedon

1 Corinthians 14Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the quiet discipline of daily Scripture study we turn again to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. This venerable Wesleyan voice guides us through the apostolic ordering of spiritual gifts in First Corinthians fourteen, holding together the supernatural and the orderly life of the Church. With reverent attention we prepare our hearts to receive both the word of Scripture and the measured wisdom of this Methodist commentator, that love may abound and the body of Christ be built up in truth.
Read
Let us now read together the fourteenth chapter of First Corinthians, listening for the Spirit who both bestows gifts and requires their orderly exercise. Read slowly, allowing the apostolic counsel to search the life of the congregation and the motives of the heart. Pause after each paragraph, inviting the same Spirit to apply the word for the edification of all.
Study
Whedon opens the treatment of charismatic gifts by establishing their proper rank. Verse 1. a. Tongues inferior to prophecy, as less building-up the Church, 1 Corinthians 14:1-21 . 1 . Follow after love Which all are able to attain, and which is the ordinary, central, permanent grace of the Church. Desire Be emulous for. Spiritual gifts Which are for the few, and are transient. He next turns to the distinctive work of prophecy within the assembly. Verse 3. 3 . Prophesieth As the Spirit selects for its instruments the persons most qualified by nature for its special work, so the individual naturally susceptible to presentiment would be gifted with the prophetic charism. Whedon then shows how prophecy serves the whole Church. Verse 4. 4 . Edifieth himself The very inspiration elevates and delights his spirit, while his own utterance of divine mysteries reacts upon and edifieth himself . Though he keep silence , ( 1 Corinthians 14:28 ,) he goes not unblest. Edifieth the Church By clear and instructive thought, and, perhaps, supernatural prediction. He continues by weighing the comparative value of tongues and prophecy. Verse 5. 5 . I would… all spake with tongues Not a mere concession to the prejudices of the Corinthians, but a hearty endorsement of the gift as good in its place. But rather… prophesied The apostle is wisely utilitarian. He adjudges the palm of superiority to the more useful gift. Catalepsies and trances are viewed with wonder; but that very wonder is not religious or sanctifying, and may take the place of holier thought. Nor has it been found that the subjects of them are the holiest persons in the Church; just as the Corinthian Church, though most exercised by these gifts, was by no means eminent among the Churches for its holiness. And so the existence of this phenomenon in the Irvingite assemblies was no proof of superior holiness. Except he interpret For either the charismatic speaker may follow his utterance with an interpretation, (as in the case adduced by Dr. Bushnell,) or another person gifted with interpretation might interpret. This clause seems to imply that the utterer with tongues could not always explain his own utterance. The inspiration reached the spirit , and wakened powerful emotions, but did not quicken the understanding ; so that the vocality, though expressive, was not understood as words by the subject himself.
Consider
Whedon presses the apostolic illustration of tongues and prophecy to its decisive conclusion. Verse 22. b. Illustration of the inferiority of tongues to prophecy, 1 Corinthians 14:22-25 . 22 . Wherefore In peculiar conformity with this type. Tongues… a sign… to them that believe not Their miraculous and startling character rendered them a sign for the conviction of unbelievers; just as the Assyrian tongues were for the bringing Israel to repentance. For the conviction of unbelievers were the charismatic tongues intended, and this they would often effect if rightly exercised. The notion of some commentators, that Paul teaches that tongues are a sign of judgment upon incorrigible unbelievers, is contrary to the whole history and character of that charism and entirely unsustained by Paul’s words. The pentecostal tongues, though rejected by the mockers, were intended to convert all who heard them, and did effect the object to a glorious extent. The charism, by its very nature, points to a reception of the gospel by the nations. If they are an adumbration of the one tongue of Paradise, they are a cheerful and glorious image. By their appealing to the ear of the foreigner in his own home dialect, as well as by their thrilling, supernatural impressiveness, they were a sign most convincing to the unbeliever; just as Paul says the signs of an apostle were wrought by him for the conversion of the Corinthians themselves. Yet all happy results depended upon their proper use, otherwise unbelievers would reject those displaying them as mad; as in next verse. He closes the section by displaying the searching power of prophetic ministry upon the hearer. Verse 25. 25 . Secrets of his heart The man (as has often been the case under a searching ministry) feels as if the speaker knew him through and through, and was preaching at, and to, and through him alone. Falling… face In complete submission, self-surrender, and worship . Report As Dr. Hodge says, “The man who has had such an experience cannot keep it to himself.” He will joyfully declare, in substance, that he “has experienced religion;” or, if witlings will so have it, he “has got religion.” That God No longer identified with the deities of heathen mythology. Is in you Both among you as a Church, and in your hearts individually by his Spirit.
Respond
1. In what ways am I seeking gifts that build others rather than merely stir my own spirit? 2. How does the call to orderly worship shape my participation in the gathered Church? 3. Where might the Spirit be inviting me to yield my preferences for the sake of another’s edification?
Pray
Gracious God, who distributes gifts by the same Spirit and orders them for the common good, grant us the wisdom to prize prophecy above every lesser sound. May love govern every utterance in Thy house, that strangers may be convicted, saints built up, and Thy name glorified. Keep us from the childish love of noise and lead us into the manly exercise of gifts that edify. Let the amen of a believing people rise with understanding and holy awe. Through Christ our Lord, Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →