← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians

1 Corinthians 8 — with Barnes

1 Corinthians 8Albert Barnes' Notes on the Bible20 min
Opening
In the clear exegetical tradition of American Presbyterian scholarship, we turn today to Albert Barnes's Notes on the Bible for guidance through First Corinthians chapter eight. Barnes carefully unfolds the apostle Paul's pastoral wisdom on matters of Christian liberty and conscience. His verse-by-verse exposition remains a trusted companion for those who desire both doctrinal precision and tender regard for fellow believers. As we open these pages, may the Spirit grant us humility to receive the word and charity to apply it.
Read
Let us now give reverent attention to the eighth chapter of First Corinthians. Read the passage slowly, noting the questions raised by the Corinthian church and the measured answers supplied by the apostle. Listen for the interplay between knowledge and love, and ask the Lord to prepare your heart for the instruction that follows.
Study
Barnes opens by setting forth the precise inquiry the Corinthians had sent to Paul. Whether, therefore, it would be right to partake of that food, either when invited to the house of a pagan friend, or when it was exposed for sale in the market, was a question which could not but present itself to a conscientious Christian. The objection to partaking of it would be, that to partake of it either in the temples or at the feasts of their pagan neighbors, would be to lend their countenance to idolatry. On the other hand, there were many who supposed that it was always lawful, and that the scruples of their brethren were needless. Some of their arguments Paul has alluded to in the course of the chapter: they were, that an idol was nothing in the world; that there was but one God, and that everyone must know this; and that, therefore, there was no danger that any worshipper of the, true God could be led into the absurdities of idolatry, 1 Corinthians 8:4-6 . He next records the apostle's initial reply concerning the proper limits of knowledge. To this the apostle replies, that though there might be this knowledge, yet: (1) Knowledge sometimes puffed up, and made us proud, and that we should be careful lest it should lead us astray by our vain self-confidence, 1 Corinthians 8:1-2 , 1 Corinthians 8:7 . (2) That all had not that knowledge 1 Corinthians 8:7 ; and that they even then, notwithstanding all the light which had been shed around them by Christianity, and notwithstanding the absurdity of idolatry, still regarded an idol as a real existence, as a god, and worshipped it as such; and that it would be highly improper to countenance in any way that idea. He left the inference, therefore, that it was not proper “from this argument,” to partake of the sacrifices to idols. Barnes then presents Paul's second line of argument and its warning about weaker brothers. A second argument in favor of partaking of that food is alluded to in 1 Corinthians 8:8 , to wit, that it must be in itself a matter of indifference; that it could make no difference before God, where all depended on moral purity and holiness of heart, whether a man had eaten meat or not; that we were really no better or worse for it; and that, therefore, it was proper to partake of that food. To this Paul replies: That though this was true, as an abstract proposition, yet it might be the occasion of leading others into sin 1 Corinthians 8:9 . (2)That the effect on a weak brother would be to lead him to suppose that an idol was something, and to confirm him in his supposition that an idol should have some regard, and be worshipped in the temple, 1 Corinthians 8:10 . (3)That the consequence might be, that a Christian of little information and experience might be drawn away and perish, 1 Corinthians 8:11 .
Consider
Barnes draws the chapter to its weightiest conclusion with Paul's personal resolve. (4)That this would be to sin against Christ, if a feeble Christian should be thus destroyed, 1 Corinthians 8:12 . And, That as for himself, if indulgence in meat was in any way the occasion of making another sin, he would eat no meat as long as the world stood 1 Corinthians 8:13 ; since to abstain from meat was a far less evil than the injury or destruction of an immortal soul. He presses the surpassing value of love over mere knowledge for the edification of the church. It will make us tender, affectionate, and kind; and will better tell us what to do, and how to do it in the best way, than all the abstract knowledge that is conceivable. The man who is influenced by love, ever pure and ever glowing, is not in much danger of going astray, or of doing injury to the cause of God. The man who relies on his knowledge is heady, high-minded, obstinate, contentious, vexatious, perverse, opinionated; and most of the difficulties in the church arise from such people. Love makes no difficulty, but heals and allays all; mere knowledge heals or allays none, but is often the occasion of most bitter strife and contention. Paul was wise in recommending that the question should be settled by love; and it would be wise if all Christians would follow his instructions.
Respond
1. In what areas of Christian liberty might knowledge without love still be shaping my conduct? 2. How does the principle that love edifies challenge my present use of freedom in Christ? 3. Where is the Lord inviting me to limit my liberty for the sake of a weaker brother or sister?
Pray
Gracious Father, grant us the mind of Christ that we may prize love above knowledge and guard the peace of Your church above our own liberties. Keep us from pride that puffs up and from any indifference that wounds a brother’s conscience, so that our freedom may always be ruled by charity for those for whom Christ died. Fill us with Your Spirit that we might walk in this love until He returns. Amen.

Albert Barnes' Notes on the Bible · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →