Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 31 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal study we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. His careful exposition of First Samuel chapter thirty-one invites us to trace the final days of King Saul with both historical clarity and spiritual seriousness, allowing the sacred record to speak afresh to our own hearts.
Read
Let us now read First Samuel chapter thirty-one in full, attending to the sober close of Saul’s reign. May the Holy Spirit steady our minds as the narrative moves from battlefield defeat to the quiet faithfulness of Jabesh-gilead.
Study
Whedon opens by setting the historical frame of the chapter.
Introduction. DEATH OF SAUL AND HIS SONS, 1 Samuel 31:1-13 . From this chapter on, through the subsequent history of the Kings, we have the parallel, and ofttimes supplementary, compilations of the books of Chronicles. Compare with this chapter 1 Chronicles 10:0 . This chapter resumes the account of the Philistine war which was commenced at 1 Samuel 28:1 , and broken off at 1 Samuel 29:11 .He then examines the decisive moment of Saul’s death.
Verse 4. 4 . His armourbearer would not He dared not stretch forth his hand against the Lord’s anointed; the very thought of such an act filled him with fear. Saul took a sword Rather, took the sword, that is, the sword of the armourbearer just referred to. Fell upon it Thrust it through himself by falling over upon it. This account of Saul’s death is every way consistent with itself and with Saul’s character, and is to be regarded as the true and authentic record of the sacred historian himself. The story of the Amalekite, who stole the king’s crown and bracelet, and brought them to David, ( 2 Samuel 1:4-10 ,) is to be treated as a fabrication, feigned with the hope of finding favour with the successor of Saul.Whedon next considers the loyalty of the armourbearer and the fate of Saul’s house.
Verse 5. 5 . His armourbearer saw that Saul was dead He probably drew the sword from the body of the king and hoped to save him, but all too late. He fell likewise upon his sword The same sword by which the Lord’s anointed had been slain. Touching and beautiful was this devotion of the faithful armourbearer to his king. It not only evidences the deep attachment of a true and tender heart, but also shows that Saul was not without a strong personal magnetism, which drew others to him, and kept them firmly there. At his public election at Mizpeh there clave to Saul a number of men whose hearts were touched by God, ( 1 Samuel 10:26 ,) and at no time during his reign did he want for attendants who were thus tenderly attached to his person and interests.He turns finally to the courageous act of the men of Jabesh-gilead.
Verse 11. 11 . The inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead Who ever preserved a tender and grateful remembrance of what they owed to the heroism of Saul. See chap. 11.
Consider
Whedon presses the true theocratic judgment upon Saul’s reign.
With the prospects and the position of a David, he remained to the end a Jephthah or a Samson, with this difference, that, having outlived the age of Jephthah and of Samson, he could not be as they; and the struggle, therefore, between what he was and what he might have been, grew fiercer as years went on; and the knowledge of Samuel, and the companionship of David, became to him a curse instead of a blessing.” Stanley. The true theocratic view of Saul’s reign is appropriately given in Jehovah’s own words. Hosea 13:11 : “I gave thee a king in mine anger, and took him away in my wrath.” We must not understand, then, that Saul was chosen because God saw in him the proper qualifications for a king, but quite the contrary.He closes with a final reflection on the mingled tenderness and warning that the sacred historian leaves us.
They were the religious crises of his history, and at each point he failed. But though Saul’s reign was a failure, his whole career is sketched with a plaintive tenderness. Not only did Samuel greatly mourn for Saul, ( 1Sa 15:11 ; 1 Samuel 15:35 ; 1 Samuel 16:1 ,) but the sacred historian, caught the sad, tender spirit of that saintly judge, and breathed it into his narrative. In the same spirit David pours forth his touching elegy over the fallen beauty and might of Israel. 2 Samuel 1:19-27 . In the same spirit let us remember that “pride goeth before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall.”
Respond
Where in my own life have I sought to grasp what God has not given? How does the loyalty of Saul’s armourbearer challenge my own faithfulness to those God has placed over me? In what ways am I heeding the warning that pride goes before destruction?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank Thee for the faithful witness of Thy servant Whedon and for the sobering record of Saul’s end. Keep us from the half-converted heart that cannot bear the weight of Thy calling. Grant us instead the full surrender that marked David after Thy own heart. May we walk humbly, serve loyally, and rest at last in the sepulchre of Thy saints, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →