← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Apology of the Augsburg Confession

Apology — Of the Marriage of Priests — Book of Concord

Apology of the Augsburg Confession 22The Book of Concord15 min
Opening
Today we turn to the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, specifically its article Of the Marriage of Priests. This section of the Lutheran Confessions addresses the requirement of clerical celibacy imposed by Rome and sets forth the evangelical freedom of pastors to marry. It matters for Lutheran faith because it upholds both the Word of God and the created order against human traditions that burden consciences. The article shows how the Gospel liberates the church from laws that contradict Scripture and nature while still honoring true continence as a gift.
Read
Read the full article Of the Marriage of Priests from the Apology of the Augsburg Confession. The text rests chiefly on Genesis 1, 1 Corinthians 7, Matthew 19, and 1 Timothy 4, together with references to natural law and the ancient canons. As you read, notice how the Confession defends the right of priests to marry without denying the value of continence for those who receive that gift.
Study
The Confession opens its positive arguments by turning to the creation account. First, Gen. 1:28 teaches that men were created to be fruitful, and that one sex in a proper way should desire the other. For we are speaking not of concupiscence, which is sin, but of that appetite which was to have been in nature in its integrity [which would have existed in nature even if it had remained uncorrupted], which they call physical love. And this love of one sex for the other is truly a divine ordinance. But since this ordinance of God cannot be removed without an extraordinary work of God, it follows that the right to contract marriage cannot be removed by statutes or vows. It next appeals directly to the apostle Paul. Thirdly, Paul says, 1 Cor. 7:2: To avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife. This now is an express command pertaining to all who are not fit for celibacy. The adversaries ask that a commandment be shown them which commands priests to marry. As though priests are not men! We judge indeed that the things which we maintain concerning human nature in general pertain also to priests. Does not Paul here command those who have not the gift of continence to marry? For he interprets himself a little after when he says, 7:9: It is better to marry than to burn. And Christ has clearly said, Matt. 19:11: All men cannot receive this saying, save they to whom it is given. Because now, since sin [since the fall of Adam], these two things concur, namely, natural appetite and concupiscence, which inflames the natural appetite, so that now there is more need of marriage than in nature in its integrity, Paul accordingly speaks of marriage as a remedy, and on account of these flames commands to marry. The Confession then compares the pontifical law with earlier canons. Fourthly, The pontifical law differs also from the canons of the Councils. For the ancient canons do not prohibit marriage, neither do they dissolve marriages that have been contracted, even if they remove from the administration of their office those who have contracted them in the ministry. At those times this dismissal was an act of kindness [rather than a punishment]. But the new canons, which have not been framed in the Synods, but have been made according to the private judgment of the Popes, both prohibit the contraction of marriages, and dissolve them when contracted; and this is to be done openly, contrary to the command of Christ, Matt. 19:6: What God hath joined together, let not man put asunder. In the Confutation the adversaries exclaim that celibacy has been commanded by the Councils. We do not find fault with the decrees of the Councils; for under a certain condition these allow marriage; but we find fault with the laws which, since the ancient Synods, the Popes of Rome have framed contrary to the authority of the Synods.
Consider
The Confession closes by summarizing its reasons for rejecting the law of perpetual celibacy. We have explained the reasons why we cannot assent with a good conscience to the adversaries when they defend the pontifical law concerning perpetual celibacy, because it conflicts with divine and natural law and is at variance with the canons themselves, and is superstitious and full of danger, and, lastly, because the whole affair is insincere. For the law is enacted not for the sake of religion [not for holiness' sake, or because they do not know better; they know very well that everybody is well acquainted with the condition of the great cloisters, which we are able to name], but for the sake of dominion, and this is wickedly given the pretext of religion. Neither can anything be produced by sane men against these most firmly established reasons. The Gospel allows marriage to those to whom it is necessary. Nevertheless, it does not compel those to marry who can be continent, provided they be truly continent. We hold that this liberty should also be conceded to the priests, nor do we wish to compel any one by force to celibacy, nor to dissolve marriages that have been contracted.
Respond
How does the freedom to marry strengthen a pastor’s service to the church? In what ways might human traditions still burden consciences today? Where do you see the Confession’s appeal to creation and Scripture shaping your own view of marriage and vocation?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank You for the clear witness of the Apology concerning the marriage of priests. Guard Your church from every law that contradicts Your Word and the order of creation. Grant pastors the freedom to marry or remain continent according to the gifts You give. Keep us from trusting in human traditions and lead us to rest only in Christ’s righteousness. Bless all Christian households and strengthen those who serve in public ministry. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

The Book of Concord · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →