Eterniseed › Curriculum › Tobit
Tobit 9-10 — drawing on Aquinas (Summa I q.22 providence + II-II q.136 patience)
Opening
The ninth and tenth chapters of Tobit chronicle the unfolding of the divine providence that has been hidden through the long trials of Tobit's blindness and Sarah's widowhood. Drawing on Aquinas's sustained treatment of divine providence in Summa I q.22 and his treatment of patience as a part of fortitude in II-II q.136, we may approach these chapters as the structural unfolding of the doctrine that the inspired narrative has been preparing throughout the book. Raphael retrieves the deposit of silver from Gabael at Rages while Tobiah remains with Sarah; the wedding feast at Ecbatana extends as Raguel keeps Tobiah longer than expected; and Anna at Nineveh, watching daily from the road for her son's return, gives way to the lament of a mother who fears her child has perished. The Church has long read the patience of Anna under the long delay as one of the great Old Testament prefigurations of the Mother of God at the foot of the cross, and Aquinas's scholastic apparatus enables the contemporary reader to see in the narrative the working out of theological principles that the Christian tradition has held since the patristic age.
Read
Read Tobit chapters 9 and 10 with attention to the parallel movements at Ecbatana and Nineveh. In chapter nine, mark Raphael's commissioning by Tobiah to journey from Ecbatana to Rages to retrieve the silver deposited with Gabael; the angel's success in fetching both the silver and Gabael himself for the wedding feast; and the seven-day extension of the celebration. In chapter ten, attend to the parallel scene at Nineveh: Anna's daily watch from the road for her son's return; her growing distress as the days exceed Tobit's expectation; her lament that her son has perished; Tobit's calm reassurance which Anna cannot accept; and finally Tobiah's preparation for departure from Ecbatana with Sarah, the angel, the silver, and a generous portion of Raguel's flocks and herds. Hold in mind both the patience of Tobit at Nineveh and the more anguished struggle of Anna whose maternal love resists the consolation of patience.
Study
Aquinas's treatment of divine providence in Summa I q.22 articulates the theological doctrine with scholastic precision. In q.22 a.1 he asks whether God's providence extends to all things; his response, drawing on Boethius's Consolation of Philosophy and on the patristic tradition, is yes — God's providence extends to every contingent event in the order of created causes, since nothing falls outside the order of the divine first cause. In q.22 a.2 he refines the doctrine: God's providence is exercised through the mediation of secondary causes (the natural processes of created things) without thereby being diminished, much as a craftsman's mastery is exercised through his tools without the craftsman ceasing to be the principal agent. In q.22 a.4 he asks whether providence imposes necessity on the things provided for; his response, drawing on Augustine and Aristotle, is that providence preserves the natural contingency of contingent things even as it ensures the achievement of the divine purposes — God provides for contingent events in such a way that they happen contingently, not necessarily, even though the divine will achieves its purposes infallibly. The hidden providence at work in the Tobit narrative is the paradigmatic Old Testament instance of this doctrine. The simultaneous prayers of Tobit and Sarah in chapter three, the simultaneous decision in heaven to send Raphael, the providential discovery of the fish whose organs will heal Tobit and bind Asmodeus, the providential timing of Raphael's appearance to Tobiah as he sought a guide, the providential conjunction of Gabael's holding of the deposit at Rages with Tobiah's journey to Ecbatana for marriage — each of these is an instance of the divine providence working through the secondary causes of created things without violating their contingent nature. Aquinas would draw particular attention to the angel's role: Raphael is the instrument of providence not as a substitute for the secondary causes but as an additional secondary cause integrated into the wider providential ordering. Saint Augustine in De Diversis Quaestionibus 83 (Q.24) and in the City of God Book V (chapters 8-11) had treated the doctrine of providence at length, distinguishing between the fatum of the Stoics (which denies the contingency of created causes) and the providentia of Christian doctrine (which preserves the contingency while ensuring the divine purpose). Aquinas in I q.22 takes Augustine's distinction as foundational. The patience of Anna and Tobit at Nineveh deserves attention drawing on Aquinas's treatment of patience in II-II q.136. In q.136 a.1 he asks whether patience is a virtue; his response is yes — patience is a part of fortitude by which the soul bears the evils that come from without (especially the evils of long duration) without yielding to sadness in a manner that would compromise the soul's adherence to the good. In q.136 a.2 he distinguishes between patience and the simple endurance of suffering: the latter is a natural disposition some persons have, while patience is the moral virtue of bearing suffering with the soul's adherence to reason and to charity. In q.136 a.3 he asks whether patience is the greatest of the virtues; his response, qualifying Saint Gregory the Great's statement in his Moralia on Job that patience is the root and guardian of all the virtues, is that patience is among the greatest of the virtues in respect to the present life because it preserves the soul under the trials by which the present life tests every other virtue — but patience itself is ordered to charity, which is greater because it is the form of all the virtues. The patience of Tobit at Nineveh — his calm reassurance to Anna that their son will return, his refusal to give way to the anxiety that has gripped Anna — exemplifies the scholastic articulation Aquinas provides. Tobit has been tested for years by his blindness; the additional trial of his son's delay is borne by him with the patience that long suffering has wrought into the soul as a stable habit. Anna's more anguished struggle is not a failure of patience but a different mode of suffering: maternal love bears the absence of the only child in a particular intensity that the spousal love does not bear, and her lament discloses the precise quality of that intensity. Saint Augustine in De Civitate Dei XIX (chapters 4-10) had treated at length the question of whether the saints in this life can achieve perfect tranquility of soul under all trials; his response, which Aquinas accepts in q.136 a.4, is that perfect tranquility belongs only to the beatific vision and that in this life the saints bear their trials with patience but not without the affective movements that the trials produce. Anna's lament does not contradict her patience but expresses the affective movement that her maternal love necessarily produces under the trial of her son's delay. The Church has read Anna's daily watch from the road as a particular foreshadowing of the Blessed Virgin Mary at the foot of the cross. Mary too watches her only Son under a trial that maternal love bears in a particular intensity; Mary too does not yield to the temptation to deny what her eyes behold; Mary too neither resists the affective movement her love produces nor allows it to compromise her adherence to the will of God. Aquinas in his commentary on John 19 (preserved in the Catena Aurea) threads the patristic discussion of the standing of Mary at the cross with the discussion of patience, and the Mariological reading of Anna in Tobit 10 is a particular instance of the typological discipline Aquinas brings to the Old Testament.
Consider
Drawing on Aquinas's articulation in I q.22 of the divine providence working through the secondary causes of created things, consider whether the structure of your own trust in providence acknowledges this scholastic precision. The contemporary culture has tended either to dissolve providence into a vague background sense of meaning (which fails to acknowledge the divine governance) or to caricature it as the kind of micromanagement that violates the natural contingency of created causes. Aquinas's mediated providence preserves both: God truly governs all events, and the events themselves remain contingent and natural. Have you cultivated the patience that this doctrine sustains — the patience that does not demand to see the divine ordering in advance but trusts that the trial through which you pass is integrated into the ordering even when you cannot perceive how? Consider too the distinction Aquinas draws in II-II q.136 a.4 between patience as a stable habit and patience as the suppression of affective movement. The Tobit narrative shows both Tobit (whose long blindness has wrought patience into him as habit) and Anna (whose maternal love produces affective movement that her patience permits without yielding to). The Catholic moral tradition has been careful to insist that patience does not require the suppression of natural feeling — Christ wept at the tomb of Lazarus, Mary stood at the foot of the cross, the saints have grieved their losses without abandoning their adherence to God. Have you allowed the contemporary stoic caricature of patience to dim the more capacious reality the scholastic articulation preserves? Consider finally the Mariological reading of Anna at the road. The Catholic tradition's typological reading of the Old Testament — by which figures like Eve, Sarah, Rebekah, Anna, Esther, Judith, and others are read as prefigurations of the Mother of God — is not an arbitrary imposition on the text but the recognition of the deeper structures that the divine providence has woven into salvation history. Have you cultivated the discipline of typological reading, or have you allowed the modern preference for literal-only exegesis to flatten the richness the patristic and scholastic tradition has preserved?
Respond
Identify one specific trial in your present life that has the character of long duration — a chronic illness, a prolonged uncertainty about a vocational decision, a slow conversion you are praying for, an institutional difficulty whose resolution recedes — and renew before God your acknowledgment of his providence over it. Drawing on Aquinas's I q.22, articulate to yourself that the trial is integrated into the providential ordering even when you cannot perceive how, that the contingency of secondary causes is preserved, and that the patience the trial works in you is itself the substantive fruit the providence intends. Pray a decade of the Rosary on the Sorrowful Mysteries for the grace of this patience.
Pray
O God, whose provident hand guided Tobias and Sarah through hidden ways and restored sight to Tobit in thy perfect time, deepen our trust in thy loving governance of all things. Grant us patient hearts that wait upon thy will without murmuring, through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and the communion of saints. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →