← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › James

James 4 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary

James 4Haydock Bible Commentary20 min
Opening
In today's lesson we turn to Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary on the Letter of James, chapter 4. This venerable compilation gathers the insights of Witham, Calmet, Challoner and other Catholic exegetes to illuminate the apostle's urgent call to humility and purity of heart. As we listen to these voices from the Church's tradition, may the Spirit plant eternal seeds that reorder our desires and draw us closer to the Lord who gives grace to the humble.
Read
Prepare your heart in silence and read James chapter 4 slowly, allowing every verse to echo within you. Notice the apostle's plain language about conflicts, disordered loves, and the fleeting nature of earthly plans. Let the Word expose whatever resists God's friendship so that you may receive the greater grace he promises to the humble.
Study
Haydock opens by tracing the origin of wars and contentions to disordered passions. Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Whence are wars [1] and contentions, in all kinds, but from your lusts and disorderly passions, coveting to have and enjoy what you have not, as to pleasures, riches, honours, &c. (Witham) The commentary next examines the reasons prayers remain unanswered. You covet, and have not. Though God has promised that whosoever asks shall receive, (Matthew vii. 8.) yet no wonder you receive not, because you ask amiss, by asking such temporal things as would be prejudicial to your soul, or because you ask not with humility, devotion, and perseverance. (Witham) Haydock then unfolds the figurative meaning of adulterers in this passage. Adulterers: which is here taken in a figurative sense for those who love creatures more than God, the true spouse of their souls; who reflect not that the love and friendship of this world is an enemy to God, and the true manner of serving him. (Witham) On detraction and rash judgment the commentary offers a special admonition. Detract not one another, (nor judge rashly) brethren. Though he spoke so much against the evils of the tongue, he give them a special admonition against the vice of detraction, so common in the world, as also against rash judgments, which happen so frequently where there are dissensions and divisions. He that detracteth, judgeth, and rashly condemneth his brother, may be said to detract and judge the law, inasmuch as he seem to contemn and condemn the law, by which these sins are forbidden; when, instead of obeying and complying with the law, he rather takes upon himself to act as a judge,[5] without fear of the law and of God, the only lawgiver, who is to judge all our actions, and who alone is able to destroy, or to free us and deliver us from the punishments we have deserved. (Witham)
Consider
Haydock explores the obscure scriptural allusion concerning envy and the indwelling spirit. Do you think that the scripture saith in vain: To envy doth the spirit covet, with dwelleth in you? [2] This verse is obscure, and differently expounded. By some, of an evil spirit in men, by which they covet and envy others for having what they have not. Others understand God's spirit inhabiting in them; and then it is an interrogation, and reprehension, as if he said: Doth God's spirit, which you have received, teach or excite you to covet and envy others, and not rather to love and wish their good? And to enable men to do this, God is not wanting, who gives us greater grace, especially to the humble that ask it, though he resists the proud. (Witham) --- It is not evident to what part of Scripture St. James here alludes, the exact words are nowhere in the sacred writings. That which seems the most like this text, and the most adapted to his subject, is a passage from Ezechiel, "I will set my jealousy against thee:" (Ezechiel xxiii. 25.) i.e. I have loved thee with the love of jealousy, and I will revenge upon thee my slighted affections. (Calmet) The commentary closes with a sober warning against presuming on the uncertainty of life. To-day or to-morrow, &c. An admonition against that presumption, when persons forget the uncertainty of life, and the vanity of all things in this world, which vanish like a vapour, and can never be relied upon, so as to count upon years and the time to come. All things here appear and disappear in a moment. Take heed, therefore, not to glory or boast in your arrogancies; (ver. 16.) literally, pride; like the rich man, (Luke x.) who thought of nothing but a long and merry life, and was cut off that very night. And being now admonished, reflect that it is sinful to know what is good, what is your duty, and not to comply with it. (Witham)
Respond
Where do my own desires fuel unnecessary conflicts with others? How might I ask God more humbly and perseveringly for what truly serves my soul? In what small way can I practice greater detachment from the world's fleeting promises today?
Pray
Lord Jesus, friend of the humble, purify our hearts from every disordered craving that sets us at enmity with you. Grant us the grace to ask rightly, to love you above every creature, and to speak only what builds up our brothers and sisters, so that our lives may be marked by peace, perseverance, and childlike trust. We ask this through the intercession of Mary, your immaculate mother, and all the saints who learned to resist the world and draw near to you. Amen.

Haydock Bible Commentary · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →